文献速递牙体牙髓病

双重热处理对类金刚石碳涂层镍钛旋转器械冶金学与力学性能的影响

Influence of Dual Heat Treatment on the Metallurgy and Mechanical Behaviour of Diamond-Like Carbon-Coated NiTi Rotary Systems: A Multimethod Investigation.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2025-12-30

研究比较了双重热处理制造的Rainbow Ultra与Rainbow One镍钛旋转器械(25/0.06,25 mm)的冶金学特征与力学性能。两者几何形态与元素组成相近,但Ultra相变温度更高并具双奥氏体峰;Ultra抗循环疲劳、最大旋转角度与切割效率更优,One抗扭强度与抗屈曲性更强。

要点

  • 双重热处理改变镍钛器械相变温度与力学性能平衡。
  • Ultra抗循环疲劳与切割效率更优,One抗扭与抗屈曲更强。
  • 两者几何形态与镍钛元素组成基本一致。

核心结论

  • 制造过程中的双重热处理显著影响受试镍钛旋转器械的力学性能。
  • Rainbow Ultra表现为更高柔韧性、抗循环疲劳性和切割效率。
  • Rainbow One表现为更高抗扭强度和抗屈曲性。

研究设计与样本

  • 体外多方法研究,评估Rainbow One(n=58)与Rainbow Ultra(n=58)器械(25/0.06,25 mm)。
  • 采用光学3D扫描与SEM进行几何分析,EDS与DSC进行冶金学表征。
  • 力学测试包括循环疲劳、扭转强度、弯曲阻力、屈曲强度和切割效率,遵循ASTM与ISO指南。
  • 统计采用Shapiro-Wilk与Levene检验后行独立样本t检验,显著性水平5%。

主要发现

  • 两种器械几何形态等效,偏差低于100 μm,尖端设计与表面特征相似。
  • EDS确认两者均为近等原子比镍钛成分。
  • DSC显示室温下两者均为R相结构;Ultra相变温度更高(Rs 35°C vs 25°C;Rf 45°C vs 31°C;As 30°C vs 24°C;Af 50°C vs 38°C)。
  • Ultra具双奥氏体相变峰,One为单峰。
  • Ultra抗循环疲劳(95.5°±7 vs 79.1±6 s)、最大旋转角度(485°±49° vs 402°±50°)和切割效率更优(p<0.05)。

关键数值与推荐

  • Rainbow Ultra相变温度:Rs 35°C、Rf 45°C、As 30°C、Af 50°C。
  • Rainbow One相变温度:Rs 25°C、Rf 31°C、As 24°C、Af 38°C。
  • Ultra抗循环疲劳95.5°±7 s,One为79.1±6 s。
  • Ultra最大旋转角度485°±49°,One为402°±50°。
  • One失效扭矩1.8°±0.2 N·cm,Ultra为1.4°±0.1 N·cm。

临床怎么用

  • 需高柔韧性与抗循环疲劳时可选双重热处理Ultra类器械。
  • 需高抗扭强度与抗屈曲性时可选One类器械。
  • 选择器械时应结合根管解剖与临床操作需求权衡性能差异。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To investigate how the application of dual heat treatment during the manufacturing process influences the mechanical performance (flexibility, cyclic fatigue resistance, torsional strength, bending, buckling and cutting efficiency) of rotary nickel-titanium endodontic instruments. METHODOLOGY: Rainbow One (n = 58) and Rainbow Ultra (n = 58) instruments (size 25/0.06, 25 mm length) were evaluated. Geometric analysis was performed using optical 3D scanning and SEM to assess cutting edges, tip design and surface features. Metallurgical characterisation included EDS for elemental composition and DSC for phase transformation temperatures, with segments obtained from the tip, middle and coronal blade regions. Mechanical testing comprised cyclic fatigue, torsional strength (torque to failure, maximum angle of rotation), bending resistance, buckling strength and cutting efficiency. Standardised testing protocols were applied, including ASTM and ISO guidelines for mechanical assessments. Statistical analyses were conducted using Shapiro-Wilk and Levene tests to assess assumptions, followed by independent Student's t-tests, with significance set at 5%. RESULTS: Both instruments shared equivalent geometries, with deviations below 100 μm, and similar tip designs and surface characteristics. EDS confirmed near-equiatomic NiTi composition for both systems. DSC revealed R-phase crystallographic structure at room temperature for both instruments; however, Rainbow Ultra exhibited higher phase transformation temperatures (Rs 35°C vs. 25°C; Rf 45°C vs. 31°C; As 30°C vs. 24°C; Af 50°C vs. 38°C) and a double austenitic transformation peak, compared with a single peak for Rainbow One. Mechanically, Rainbow Ultra demonstrated greater cyclic fatigue resistance (95.5° ± 7 vs. 79.1 ± 6 s), higher maximum rotation angle (485° ± 49° vs. 402° ± 50°), and improved cutting efficiency (p < 0.05). Rainbow One exhibited higher torque to failure (1.8° ± 0.2 vs. 1.4° ± 0.1 N·cm), greater bending load (369 ± 34 vs. 336 ± 14 gf), and higher buckling resistance (339 ± 32 vs. 273 ± 24 gf), indicating stiffer behaviour. CONCLUSIONS: The application of dual heat treatment during manufacturing significantly influenced the mechanical performance of the tested rotary NiTi instruments. Rainbow Ultra, subjected to sequential heat treatments, exhibited higher flexibility, cyclic fatigue resistance and cutting efficiency, whereas Rainbow One demonstrated greater torsional strength and buckling resistance.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Silva EJNL, Cardoso TO, Martins JNR, et al. Influence of Dual Heat Treatment on the Metallurgy and Mechanical Behaviour of Diamond-Like Carbon-Coated NiTi Rotary Systems: A Multimethod Investigation. Int Endod J. 2025. PMID: 41469750. doi:10.1111/iej.70089

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。