文献速递牙体牙髓病

基于计算流体力学的改良根管冲洗针性能模拟研究

[Performance simulation study of a modified root canal irrigation needle based on computational fluid dynamics].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2026-01-01

该研究采用计算流体力学方法,模拟3%次氯酸钠在理想根管中分别使用底-侧开口改良针(FS针)、传统平头针(F针)和侧方开口针(S针)在1、3、5 mm工作深度下的冲洗过程,共9组。结果显示FS针在1~3 mm深度下根尖压力低于F针且接近S针,有效置换深度远高于S针,呈现压力控制与冲洗效率的平衡优势。

要点

  • FS针在1~3 mm工作深度下根尖压力低于F针,接近S针,压力控制更安全。
  • 1 mm深度下FS针有效置换深度远高于S针,5 mm深度下与S针持平。
  • FS针有效剪切应力跨度接近或高于S针,兼顾冲洗效率。

核心结论

  • FS针在1~3 mm工作深度下呈现较低的根尖压力及较好的液体置换能力,显示出压力控制与冲洗效率之间的平衡优势。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用计算流体力学模拟,以3%次氯酸钠为冲洗液,建立理想根管和FS针、F针、S针三种几何模型。
  • 模拟1、3、5 mm工作深度下三种针的冲洗过程,共9组,提取根尖压力、壁面剪切应力和流速数据。

主要发现

  • FS针在1、3、5 mm工作深度下根尖压力分别为14.22、11.79、9.43 kPa,低于F针的35.09、25.04、17.78 kPa,接近S针的9.49、7.66、5.92 kPa。
  • FS针有效置换深度分别为1.25、1.65、1.95 mm;1 mm深度下略低于F针(1.30 mm)且远高于S针(0.15 mm),5 mm深度下与S针持平(1.95 mm)。
  • FS针有效剪切应力深度分别为5.07、3.36、1.56 mm,略低于F针;有效剪切应力跨度分别为3.18、1.93、1.40 mm,接近或高于S针。

临床怎么用

  • 在1~3 mm工作深度下可优先考虑FS针,以兼顾根尖压力控制和冲洗液置换效率。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To evaluate the irrigation performance of a modified flat-side open-ended needle (FS needle) in comparison with a traditional flat needle (F needle) and a side-vented needle (S needle), aiming to optimize clinical irrigation strategies. Methods: A 3% sodium hypochlorite solution was selected as the irrigant. Idealized root canal and three irrigation needle geometries were modeled using FreeCAD. Mesh generation and computational setup were performed using Fluent software to simulate the irrigation process with three needle types at working depths of 1, 3, and 5 mm (nine groups in total). Apical pressure, wall shear stress, and velocity data were extracted. Data were processed using Python, and flow field characteristics and irrigation efficacy were comparatively analyzed based on velocity and wall shear stress distributions, as well as four evaluation metrics: apical pressure, effective replacing depth, and effective shear stress depth and span. Results: The apical pressures of the FS needle were 14.22, 11.79, and 9.43 kPa at working depths of 1, 3, and 5 mm, respectively, which were lower than those of the F needle (35.09, 25.04, 17.78 kPa) and close to those of the S needle (9.49, 7.66, 5.92 kPa). The effective replacing depths of the FS needle were 1.25, 1.65, and 1.95 mm, slightly lower than those of the F needle (1.30 mm) but much higher than those of the S needle (0.15 mm) at 1 mm working depth, and comparable to the S needle (1.95 mm) at 5 mm working depth. The effective shear stress depths were 5.07, 3.36, and 1.56 mm, with spans of 3.18, 1.93, and 1.40 mm, respectively, slightly lower than those of the F needle in depth but close to or higher than the S needle in span. Conclusions: At working depths of 1-3 mm, the FS needle was associated with low apical pressure and superior fluid replacement capacity, indicating a favorable balance between pressure control and irrigation efficiency. 目的: 通过计算流体力学评估底-侧开口改良针(FS针)与传统平头针(F针)、侧方开口针(S针)的根管冲洗性能差异,优化临床冲洗策略。 方法: 选取3%次氯酸钠溶液作为冲洗液,应用FreeCAD软件建立理想根管和3种根管冲洗针几何模型。使用Fluent软件进行网格划分并设置计算条件,模拟3种根管冲洗针在1、3、5 mm工作深度下的冲洗过程(共9组),并获取根尖压力、壁面剪切应力和冲洗液流速数据。通过Python软件对数据进行处理,结合冲洗液流速分布、壁面剪切应力分布以及4种指标(根尖压力、有效置换深度、有效剪切应力深度和跨度)对流场细节和冲洗效率进行对比分析。 结果: 1、3、5 mm工作深度下FS针根尖压力分别为14.22、11.79和9.43 kPa,低于F针(35.09、25.04、17.78 kPa),接近S针(9.49、7.66、5.92 kPa);有效置换深度分别为1.25、1.65和1.95 mm,1 mm工作深度下有效置换深度略低于F针(1.30 mm)且远高于S针(0.15 mm),5 mm工作深度下有效置换深度与S针持平(1.95 mm);有效剪切应力深度分别为5.07、3.36和1.56 mm,略低于F针;但有效剪切应力跨度分别为3.18、1.93和1.40 mm,接近或高于S针。 结论: FS针在1~3 mm工作深度下呈现较低的根尖压力及较好的液体置换能力,显示出压力控制与冲洗效率之间的平衡优势。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Li JH, Liu XJ, Bai XX, et al. [Performance simulation study of a modified root canal irrigation needle based on computational fluid dynamics]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2026. PMID: 41469013. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20250707-00250

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。