三种生物陶瓷根管封闭剂单尖法封闭性能比较
该研究采用显微CT定量比较iRoot SP、cRoot SP和nRoot SP三种生物陶瓷封闭剂在单尖法根管充填中的封闭性能。30颗离体前磨牙随机分为三组(每组10颗),充填固化14天后扫描测量根管各段空隙率。结果显示三组在根下、中、上段的总空隙率、开口空隙率和闭口空隙率差异均无统计学意义,表明cRoot SP和nRoot SP的短期体外封闭性能与iRoot SP相近。
要点
- cRoot SP与nRoot SP在单尖法充填中的短期体外封闭性能与iRoot SP相近。
- 三组在根下、中、上段的总空隙率、开口空隙率和闭口空隙率差异均无统计学意义。
- 该结论基于离体牙短期体外实验,尚需临床研究进一步验证。
核心结论
- 基于显微CT定量分析,cRoot SP和nRoot SP在规则根管中的短期体外封闭性能与iRoot SP相近。
研究设计与样本
- 收集14~24岁因正畸拔除的单根管前磨牙30颗,随机分为三组,每组10颗。
- 使用ONE-PLEX单支锉预备根管后分别以iRoot SP、cRoot SP、nRoot SP配合单尖法充填。
- 样本在37℃、100%湿度环境中固化14天后行显微CT扫描,用CTAn软件三维重建并计算根管各段空隙率。
- 采用方差分析或非参数检验比较三组数据,显著性水平设为P<0.05。
主要发现
- 总空隙率根下段:iRoot SP组(16.81±3.15)%、cRoot SP组(15.21±3.62)%、nRoot SP组(13.52±2.90)%,P=0.093。
- 总空隙率根中段:iRoot SP组(14.52±4.21)%、cRoot SP组(12.66±2.37)%、nRoot SP组(11.63±2.39)%,P=0.129。
- 总空隙率根上段:iRoot SP组(11.96±5.31)%、cRoot SP组(12.59±4.98)%、nRoot SP组(10.09±1.77)%,P=0.417。
- 开口空隙率在根下、中、上段三组间差异均无统计学意义(P=0.112,P=0.147,P=0.463)。
- 闭口空隙率在根下、中、上段三组间差异均无统计学意义(P=0.388,P=0.810,P=0.584)。
临床怎么用
- 在规则根管单尖法充填中,cRoot SP和nRoot SP可作为iRoot SP的短期替代选择。
局限性
- 研究为体外离体牙实验,仅评估短期封闭性能,未涉及长期效果和临床结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To analyze and compare the sealing ability of three bioceramic root canal sealers (iRoot SP, cRoot SP, nRoot SP) in root canal obturation using the single-cone technique by means of micro-CT. Methods: Single-rooted premolars freshly extracted from patients aged 14-24 years for orthodontic reasons at the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Shanghai Stomatological Hospital were collected. Thirty extracted teeth were strictly included according to the five inclusion criteria to ensure baseline consistency of the experiment and randomly divided into three groups (n=10) by lottery. The root canals were prepared using the ONE-PLEX single-file system. The three groups of extracted teeth were then obturated using the single-cone technique with iRoot SP, cRoot SP, and nRoot SP sealers, respectively. The obturated specimens were stored in a 100% humidity environment at 37 ℃ for 14 days to allow complete setting. Subsequently, the specimens were scanned using micro-CT. Three-dimensional reconstruction of the root canal system was performed using CTAn software. The void volume within the root canal was measured in the apical third (2-3 mm from the root apex), middle third (>3-5 mm from the root apex), and coronal third (>5-7 mm from the root apex), respectively. The root canal filling void percentage was calculated. Data regarding the total void percentage, interfacial gap percentage, and isolated void percentage in the apical, middle, and coronal thirds of the obturated specimens from the three groups were analyzed using analysis of variance or non-parametric tests with SPSS software. The significance level was set at P<0.05. Results: In the iRoot SP group, cRoot SP group, and nRoot SP group, the total void percentage after obturation showed no statistically significant differences in the apical segment [(16.81±3.15)%, (15.21±3.62)%, (13.52±2.90)%], the middle segment [(14.52±4.21)%, (12.66±2.37)%, (11.63±2.39)%], or the coronal segment [(11.96±5.31)%, (12.59±4.98)%, (10.09±1.77)%], respectively (P=0.093, P=0.129, P=0.417). No statistically significant differences were observed in the interfacial gap percentage among the groups in the apical segment, middle segment, or coronal segment after obturation (P=0.112, P=0.147, P=0.463). Similarly, no statistically significant differences were found in the isolated void percentage among the groups in the apical segment, middle segment, or coronal segment after obturation (P=0.388, P=0.810, P=0.584). Conclusions: Based on quantitative analysis of root filling void volume using micro-CT scanning, the short-term sealing abilities of the novel bioceramic root canal materials cRoot SP and nRoot SP in standardized root canals are comparable to that of the classical bioceramic sealer iRoot SP in vitro. 目的: 使用显微CT分析比较3种生物陶瓷根管封闭剂(iRoot SP、cRoot SP、nRoot SP)在单尖法根管充填中的封闭性能。 方法: 收集2025年8月上海市口腔医院口腔颌面外科门诊14~24岁因正畸治疗需要新鲜拔除的单根管前磨牙,严格按纳入标准纳入30颗,以控制基线条件一致。采取随机抽签法将离体牙分为3组,每组10颗,使用ONE-PLEX单支锉预备根管后分别使用iRoot SP、cRoot SP、nRoot SP根管封闭剂、采用单尖法对3组离体牙进行充填,分别为iRoot SP组、cRoot SP组、nRoot SP组。将根充后的样本置于37 ℃、100%湿度环境中固化14 d后行显微CT扫描。使用CTAn软件对根管系统行三维重建,测量根下段(距根尖2~3 mm)、根中段(距根尖>3~5 mm)、根上段(距根尖>5~7 mm)根管内的空隙体积并计算根充空隙率。对3组充填后样本牙在根下、中、上段的开闭口及总空隙率数据采用SPSS软件进行方差分析或非参数检验。 结果: 在iRoot SP组、cRoot SP组、nRoot SP组中,充填后总空隙率根下段[(16.81±3.15)%、(15.21±3.62)%、(13.52±2.90)%]、根中段[(14.52±4.21)%、(12.66±2.37)%、(11.63±2.39)%]和根上段[(11.96±5.31)%、(12.59±4.98)%、(10.09±1.77)%]相比差异均无统计学意义(P=0.093,P=0.129,P=0.417);充填后开口空隙率在根下、中、上段间差异均无统计学意义(P=0.112,P=0.147,P=0.463);充填后闭口空隙率在根下、中、上段间差异均无统计学意义(P=0.388,P=0.810,P=0.584)。 结论: 基于显微CT扫描法对根充空隙率的定量分析,新型生物陶瓷根管材料cRoot SP、nRoot SP在规则根管的短期体外封闭性能与经典生物陶瓷封闭剂iRoot SP相近。.
引用
- Yang LF, Yu DS, Yang DQ, et al. [Comparison of the sealing ability of three bioceramic root canal sealers using single-cone technique]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2026. PMID: 41469008. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20251031-00436
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。