文献速递儿童口腔

社区饮水氟化的争议与公共卫生意义

Controversies and Public Health Implications of Community Water Fluoridation.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent Res · 2025-11-30

本文综述了社区饮水氟化(CWF)在有效性、安全性和实施方法三个方面的主要争议。文章总结了CWF有效性的科学证据,讨论了利用观察性数据和现代因果推断方法评估龋病因果效应的必要性,并呈现了CWF减少口腔健康社会经济不平等的证据。全球既有CWF项目在儿童智力、行为发育和执行功能指标上的安全性证据得到呈现和讨论。综述提供了一致证据确认CWF是预防龋病的有效且安全的公共卫生项目,并讨论了科学证据、卫生政策制定与政治行动者参与之间的联系。

要点

  • CWF是预防龋病的有效且安全的公共卫生项目,需维持和扩大以改善人群口腔健康。
  • 应利用观察性数据和现代因果推断方法评估氟化对龋病的因果效应。
  • CWF可减少口腔健康的社会经济不平等,但此点此前未获充分认识。

核心结论

  • 综述提供了一致证据确认CWF是预防龋病的有效且安全的公共卫生项目。
  • 需要维持和扩大CWF作为公共卫生项目以改善人群口腔健康。
  • 科学家、公共卫生从业者和政策制定者需紧密合作以应对CWF相关争议并继续实施该措施。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为综述,讨论了与CWF有效性证据、安全性和实施方法相关的三个主要争议。
  • 综述总结了CWF有效性的科学证据,并讨论了应用现代因果推断方法利用观察性数据评估氟化对龋病因果效应的必要性。

主要发现

  • CWF在过去8十年中为改善人群口腔健康做出了贡献。
  • 综述呈现了CWF减少口腔健康社会经济不平等的科学证据,指出此点此前未获充分认识。
  • 综述呈现并讨论了全球既有CWF项目安全性的科学证据,安全性以儿童智力、行为发育和执行功能指标衡量。

关键数值与推荐

  • CWF的有效性证据已获总结,但原文未报告具体效应量或数值。
  • CWF安全性的证据以儿童智力、行为发育和执行功能指标衡量,原文未报告具体数值。

临床怎么用

  • 临床中可依据本综述向患者说明CWF是预防龋病的有效且安全的公共卫生项目。
  • 应认识到CWF有助于减少口腔健康的社会经济不平等。
  • 支持维持和扩大CWF项目,并促进科学家、公共卫生从业者与政策制定者的合作。

局限性

  • 作为综述,本文未报告原始研究的具体样本量、效应量或统计显著性数值。
  • CWF的有效性证据面临证据学挑战,需扩展观察性数据与因果推断方法的应用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Community water fluoridation (CWF) is one of the most significant public health programs targeting oral health. It has contributed to improving population oral health over the past 8 decades. As a public health program, CWF faces numerous evidentiary challenges. This review discusses 3 major controversies related to CWF's evidence of effectiveness, safety, and approaches to its implementation. Scientific evidence of CWF's effectiveness has been summarized. We discuss the need to expand the use of observational data to address the causal effects of fluoridation on dental caries by applying modern causal inference approaches. We present scientific evidence that CWF reduces socioeconomic inequalities in oral health, which has been inadequately acknowledged. The scientific evidence of the safety of established CWF programs worldwide, measured by indicators of child intellectual and behavioral development and executive functioning, is presented and discussed. The review provides consistent evidence to confirm CWF as an effective and safe public health program in preventing dental caries. The third controversy is related to the implementation approaches of CWF as a public health program. The connection between scientific evidence, health policy development, and the engagement of political and other actors in implementing policies to improve health is discussed. Different types of policy implementation are discussed. Maintenance and expansion of CWF as a public health program are needed to improve the population's oral health. A strong collaboration among scientists, public health practitioners, and policymakers will be necessary to address the controversies associated with CWF and continue the implementation of this public health measure.

来源:J Dent Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Do LG, Ha DH, Spencer AJ, et al. Controversies and Public Health Implications of Community Water Fluoridation. J Dent Res. 2025. PMID: 41320855. doi:10.1177/00220345251394295

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。