单冠与大面积直接充填的长期临床结局:瑞典注册队列研究
该注册队列研究纳入2014至2019年瑞典某地区189,195例患者的343,809颗患牙,比较单冠与三面及以上直接充填的5-10年生存率。结果显示10年累积生存率单冠为92.77%、直接充填为89.09%,直接充填再治疗风险显著更高(IRR 1.59),既往根管治疗或桩核显著增加拔牙风险。
要点
- 大面积直接充填10年累积生存率89.09%,低于单冠的92.77%。
- 直接充填再治疗风险为单冠的1.59倍(95%CI 1.578-1.611)。
- 既往根管治疗或桩核显著增加拔牙风险,HR分别为2.90和1.40。
核心结论
- 大面积直接充填牙在10年内再治疗更频繁且拔牙风险高于单冠修复牙,非活髓牙尤其是有桩核或既往根管治疗者更明显。
- 因回顾性设计和潜在纳入偏倚,上述差异可能同时反映治疗选择与病例复杂度,需谨慎解读。
研究设计与样本
- 基于瑞典某地区公共口腔诊所2014至2019年注册数据的回顾性队列研究。
- 纳入189,195例患者的343,809颗患牙,随访5-10年,比较单冠与三面及以上直接充填。
- 结局包括拔牙、根管治疗以及再次直接或间接修复。
主要发现
- 10年累积生存率单冠为92.77%,直接充填为89.09%。
- 直接充填相对单冠的再治疗发生率比IRR为1.59(95%CI 1.578-1.611)。
- 既往根管治疗者拔牙风险HR为2.90(95%CI 2.8389-2.9824)。
- 有桩核者拔牙风险HR为1.40(95%CI 1.3269-1.4928)。
临床怎么用
- 对大面积缺损牙选择单冠或直接充填时,应结合牙髓状态与桩核情况评估长期再治疗和拔牙风险。
- 非活髓牙尤其有桩核或既往根管治疗者,宜更谨慎权衡修复方式并加强随访。
局限性
- 回顾性非随机设计,治疗选择基于临床判断和牙体状况而非随机分配。
- 存在潜在纳入偏倚,观察到的差异可能混杂病例复杂度。
- 需要匹配队列或随机设计研究来明确修复类型与长期牙生存的因果关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: There is a lack of consensus regarding the optimal method for restoring teeth with extensive defects. In particular, it is not clear whether a direct restoration (tooth filling) can achieve comparable tooth survival rates to a dental crown (indirect restoration). This study compares the survival rates with up to 10 years post-intervention for large direct restorations (fillings involving three or more surfaces) with those of indirect restorations (single crowns), using a large dataset. METHODS: All patients (N = 189,195) who received either single crowns (indirect restorations) or direct restorations (involving three or more surfaces) between 2014 and 2019 in the public dental clinics of a Swedish region were followed retrospectively for a period of 5-10 years (N: 343,809 teeth). Outcome measures included tooth extraction, root canal treatment, and retreatment with either direct or indirect restorations. RESULTS: The 10-year cumulative survival rates were 92.77% for indirect restorations and 89.09% for direct restorations. Direct restorations were associated with a significantly greater need for retreatment over the 10-year period compared to indirect restorations. Specifically, the incidence rate ratio (IRR) for retreatment among direct restorations was 1.59 (95% CI 1.578-1.611) relative to indirect restorations. Previous root canal treatment or the presence of a post and core significantly increased the risk of extraction, with hazard ratios of 2.90 (95% CI 2.8389-2.9824) and 1.40 (95% CI 1.3269-1.4928), respectively. CONCLUSION: Teeth restored with large direct restorations tended to require more frequent retreatments and showed a higher risk of extraction over a period of up to 10 years compared with teeth restored with indirect restorations. This trend was particularly evident among non-vital teeth, especially those with a post and core or previous root canal treatment. However, due to the retrospective design and potential inclusion bias, these findings should be interpreted with caution. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Within the limitations of this retrospective, non-randomized study, teeth restored with large direct restorations appeared to have slightly lower long-term survival and a somewhat higher need for retreatment than teeth restored with crowns. Because treatment selection was based on clinical judgment and tooth condition rather than random allocation, the observed differences likely reflect both treatment choice and case complexity. Future studies using matched cohorts or randomized designs are needed to clarify the causal relationship between restoration type and long-term tooth survival.
引用
- Olander J, Kowar J, Barkarmo S, et al. Long-term clinical outcomes for single dental crowns versus extensive direct restorations: A register-based cohort study with up to 10 years of follow-up in a Swedish population. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 41314371. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.106267
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。