非手术根管治疗中牙科橡皮障使用的影响因素:全国牙科PBRN研究
本研究利用全国牙科实践研究网络数据,纳入153名牙医完成的1860例需根管治疗的成人患者,最终分析1701例。结果显示牙髓专科医生橡皮障使用率接近普及(99%),而全科牙医使用率为72%,且从业者间差异大(SD=40%)。诊所设置和网络区域是全科牙医使用橡皮障的最强预测因素。
要点
- 牙髓专科医生橡皮障使用率接近普及(99%),全科牙医仅72%。
- 全科牙医中,大型团体或学术机构执业者使用橡皮障的OR=6.2(p=.04)。
- 中西部或西部网络区域的全科牙医使用橡皮障的OR=5.2(p=.005)。
核心结论
- 尽管橡皮障使用较既往报告有所改善,全科牙医间仍存在显著差异。
- 诊所设置和网络区域是全科牙医使用橡皮障的最强预测因素。
研究设计与样本
- 全国牙科实践研究网络(Network)的观察性研究,纳入153名网络牙医(49名牙髓专科医生,104名全科牙医)。
- 共纳入1860名需根管治疗的成人患者,排除后分析1701例患者的数据。
- 牙医记录每次根管治疗的详细治疗前后数据,包括是否使用橡皮障。
- 统计分析包括双变量和多变量模型,并调整了患者在从业者内的聚类效应。
主要发现
- 牙髓专科医生报告橡皮障使用率接近普及(99%)。
- 全科牙医在72%的根管治疗牙齿中使用了橡皮障,从业者间变异性大(SD=40%)。
- 全科牙医中,大型团体或学术机构执业与更高橡皮障使用显著相关(OR=6.2,p=.04)。
- 位于中西部或西部网络区域与更高橡皮障使用显著相关(OR=5.2,p=.005)。
- 自我认同为白人、亚裔或西班牙裔的全科牙医橡皮障使用率更高(OR=2.9,p=.09)。
临床怎么用
- 全科牙医在根管治疗中应提高橡皮障隔离的依从性,尤其在非大型团体/学术机构和非中西部/西部区域。
- 针对机构和区域层面的策略可能改善橡皮障使用合规性,提升治疗安全与质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Dental dam (DD) isolation is widely recognized as the standard of care during non-surgical root canal treatment (RCT), yet its routine use by general dentists (GDs) remains inconsistent. This study utilized real-world data from the National Dental Practice-Based Research Network ("Network") to quantify the frequency of DD use and identify practitioner and practice characteristics associated with it. METHODS: A total of 153 Network dentists (49 endodontists, 104 GDs) enrolled 1860 adult patients requiring RCT across all six Network regions. After exclusions, data from 1701 patients were analyzed. Dentists recorded detailed pre- and post-treatment data for each RCT completed, including whether DD isolation was used. Statistical analyses were performed, including bivariate and multivariable models that adjusted for clustering of patients within practitioners. RESULTS: Endodontists reported near-universal DD use (99%). GDs used DDs in 72% of the teeth that received RCT, with wide inter-practitioner variability (SD=40%). Among GDs, higher DD use was significantly associated with practicing in large group or academic settings (OR=6.2, p=.04) and being located in the Midwest or Western Network region (OR=5.2, p=.005). GDs who identified as White, Asian, or Hispanic had higher DD use compared to other groups (OR=2.9, p=.09). DD use among GDs was not associated with tooth type, nor with the GD's sex, age, or professional membership. CONCLUSIONS: Despite improvements in DD use compared to prior reports, substantial variation persists among GDs. Practice setting and Network region are the strongest predictors of adherence to DD use. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: DD use during RCT remains inconsistent among GDs, with practice setting and Network region strongly associated with adherence. Targeted institutional and regional strategies may improve compliance, ensuring safer, higher-quality care and reinforcing DD isolation as a critical clinical standard in endodontics.
引用
- Law AS, Berg R, Funkhouser E, et al. Factors associated with dental dam use during non-surgical root canal treatment: A national dental PBRN study. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 41274628. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.106258
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。