牙髓穿孔对牙齿保留与治疗成本的影响:成本效果分析
本研究采用Markov模型模拟25岁患者磨牙根管治疗中发生穿孔的情景,比较穿孔修复与拔牙后种植的成本效果。结果显示穿孔修复虽成本较高,但牙齿保留时间更长;在治疗后前13年,穿孔修复相比拔牙种植具有成本低且效果好的优势。
要点
- 穿孔修复后累积保留时间49.4年,成本3485.94欧元,优于拔牙种植的44.0年与2813.46欧元。
- 治疗后前13年穿孔修复相比拔牙种植成本更低且效果更好。
- 无穿孔对照的累积保留时间为52.9年,累积终身成本2000.78欧元。
核心结论
- 穿孔修复可延长牙齿保留时间,且根据年龄组仅带来有限或无额外成本。
- 穿孔与显著的治疗需求和成本相关,牙髓治疗应着重避免穿孔,必要时额外努力可能是合理的。
研究设计与样本
- 成本效果分析采用Markov模型,模拟一名25岁患者磨牙在根管治疗中发生穿孔后的终身结局。
- 穿孔处理方式为修复或拔牙后种植,以无穿孔为对照。
- 成本以2025年欧元计算,按3%年贴现率贴现,转移概率来自系统综述。
主要发现
- 无穿孔根管治疗后累积保留时间52.9年,累积终身成本2000.78欧元。
- 穿孔修复后累积保留时间49.4年,成本3485.94欧元。
- 拔牙后种植的累积保留时间44.0年,成本2813.46欧元。
- 治疗后前13年,穿孔修复相比拔牙种植成本更低且效果更好(占优)。
临床怎么用
- 临床应优先避免根管治疗中发生穿孔,因其显著增加治疗需求与成本。
- 对于已发生的穿孔,修复治疗在长期牙齿保留方面具有成本效果优势,尤其在治疗后前13年。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Perforations are complications that may occur during root canal treatment (RCT), requiring complex management if the tooth is to be retained. The influence of perforations and their management on long-term tooth retention and treatment costs remains unclear. AIM: Here, we evaluate endodontic perforations and resulting or alternative treatments for their cost-effectiveness. MATERIALS & METHODS: A Markov model was developed to follow a molar with a perforation occurring during RCT in an initially 25-year-old patient. The perforation was either managed by repair or tooth extraction with subsequent implant placement. The absence of a perforation served as a control. Our health outcome was the retention time of the tooth or implant. Tooth or implant costs, as well as costs for treatments during follow-up were drawn from public and private fee item catalogues (BEMA and GOZ) in Germany. Costs were calculated in euros (EUR) in the year 2025 and discounted at an annual rate of 3%. Transition probabilities were drawn from systematic reviews. RESULTS: The cumulative retention time after RCT without perforation was 52.9 years at cumulative lifetime costs of 2000.78 EUR. Perforation repair resulted in a longer retention time of 49.4 years but was also more costly (3485.94 EUR) compared to extraction and implant placement, which yielded a retention time of 44.0 years at a cost of 2813.46 EUR. In the first 13 years after treatment, perforation repair dominated extraction and implant placement, with lower costs and higher effectiveness, because initially perforation repair was less expensive. CONCLUSION: Perforation repair increases tooth retention time and comes with only limited or no additional costs depending on the age group. Perforations are associated with significant treatment needs and costs, and endodontic therapy should focus on avoiding them, likely justifying additional efforts if needed to do so.
引用
- Benz L, Leontiev W, Schwendicke F, et al. Effects of Endodontic Perforations on Tooth Retention and Treatment Costs: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis. Int Endod J. 2025. PMID: 41188638. doi:10.1111/iej.70051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。