美学区单牙支持修复体不同美学指数评估的验证研究
本研究纳入45例美学区单牙支持修复体患者照片,由4个牙科专业的8名观察者使用PES/WES、PICI、ICAI和CIS四种指数评估美学效果。结果显示ICAI和CIS观察者间一致性最高,PES/WES和PICI较低;ICAI评分显著低于其他指数,氧化锆全冠PES/WES评分显著高于PFM和玻璃陶瓷。
要点
- ICAI和CIS在评估单牙支持修复体美学时观察者间一致性最高。
- ICAI评分显著低于其他美学指数,PES/WES和PICI可靠性较低。
- 氧化锆全冠PES/WES美学评分显著高于PFM和玻璃陶瓷全冠。
核心结论
- 不同专业间评分模式因所用美学指数而异,专业与评分系统存在显著交互效应。
研究设计与样本
- 可行性临床研究,8名观察者(修复、正畸、牙周、口腔外科各2名)评估45例患者照片,每材料组15例。
主要发现
- ICAI和CIS在所有全冠类型中观察者间一致性最高,PES/WES和PICI可靠性较低。
- ICAI评分显著低于其他所有指数(P=.006)。
- 氧化锆全冠PES/WES评分显著高于PFM(P<.001)和玻璃陶瓷全冠(P=.048)。
- 各专业组内PES/WES、PICI和CIS评分均显著高于ICAI。
关键数值与推荐
- 观察者间可靠性用组内相关系数(ICC)分析,指数类型与专业为组内因素、治疗组为组间因素采用ANOVA型检验(ATS)。
临床怎么用
- 美学评估时应考虑指数选择对结果的影响,ICAI和CIS一致性较高,PES/WES可区分不同材料全冠的美学差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To validate the reproducibility and inter-observer variability of 4 different indices Pink Esthetic Score/White Esthetic Score (PES/WES), Peri-Implant and Crown Index (PICI), Implant Crown Aesthetic Index (ICAI), and Copenhagen Index Score (CIS) in assessing the esthetics at single anterior maxilla tooth-supported prosthesis fabricated of 3 materials. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Eight observers, 2 from each dental specialty (Prosthodontics, Orthodontics, Periodontics, and Oral Surgery) evaluated 45 patient photographs, with 15 patients randomly assigned to 1 of 3 treatment groups: porcelain-fused-to-metal (PFM), monolithic zirconia, or lithium disilicate single tooth-supported prostheses. Standardized photographs of each prosthesis were assessed in comparison with the contralateral tooth using 4 esthetic indices: PES/WES, ICAI, CIS, and PICI. Inter-examiner reliability within each specialty group was analyzed using the Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC). To evaluate the effects of the index type and dental specialty (as within-subject factors), treatment group (as a between-subject factor), and their interactions, an ANOVA-type test statistic (ATS) was applied. RESULTS: Among the evaluated indices, ICAI and CIS demonstrated the highest levels of interobserver agreement across all crown types, whereas PES/WES and PICI exhibited comparatively lower reliability. Post hoc test with Bonferroni correction revealed that ICAI consistently yielded significantly lower esthetic scores compared to all other indices across crown types. (P=.006), Inter-group comparisons based on PES/WES scores indicated that zirconia crowns achieved significantly higher esthetic ratings than both PFM (P<.001) and lithium disilicate crowns (P=.048). Intra-group comparisons showed that, for each specialty, scores assigned using PES/WES, PICI and CIS were significantly higher than those obtained with ICAI. CONCLUSIONS: Pattern differences among specialties varied depending on the esthetic index utilized, indicating a significant interaction effect between specialty and scoring system. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The findings of this study highlight that the choice of index significantly influences the esthetic assessment outcomes, and that certain indices may be more appropriate for detecting subtle esthetic differences, depending on examiner's clinical experience.
引用
- Srivastava G, Dash S, Padhiary SK, et al. Validation of different indices for the assessment of single tooth-supported prostheses in the esthetic zone: A feasibility clinical study. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 41138997. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.106195
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。