文献速递牙体牙髓病

应用当代复杂度分级系统评估根管治疗病例复杂度:一项临床服务评价

Assessment of Case Complexity of Root Canal Treatments Using Contemporary Complexity Grading Systems: A Clinical Service Evaluation.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2025-10-06

AIM: To assess the complexity of root canal treatments allocated to Postgraduate Endodontology trainees at Cardiff University Dental Hospital (CUDH) using the English Clinical Standards for Restorative Dentistry (ECS) in comparison with the Dental Practicality Index (DPI), the En…

要点

  • 多数病例被ECS、EA和E-CAT评为3级复杂度,DPI评为3-5分。
  • E-CAT与ECS一致性中等至较高(加权kappa=0.647)。
  • DPI与各系统仅弱正相关,作者认为专科转诊截断值3合理。

核心结论

  • 卡迪夫大学牙科医院治疗的大多数病例为高复杂度。
  • E-CAT相比ECS和EA分配的复杂度评分略低,可能因其对因素评估更详细。
  • 各复杂度分级系统之间仅呈弱正相关。
  • DPI更广泛的评估支持将专科转诊截断值定为3,因该阈值下与ECS、E-CAT和EA的一致性增加。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用Cohen kappa系数计算检查者间和检查者内变异性。
  • 统计分析比较同一病例在不同系统下的评分。

主要发现

  • 使用ECS、EA和E-CAT时多数病例被分配为3级复杂度(分别为82%、92%和74.1%),使用DPI时评分为3-5分(78.6%)。
  • EA相比ECS和E-CAT一致分配更高的复杂度评分,E-CAT相比ECS分配更低的复杂度评分。
  • E-CAT与ECS之间显示统计学显著的中等至较高一致性(加权kappa=0.647,95%CI:0.517至0.776,p<0.001)。
  • EA与ECS(加权kappa=0.290,95%CI:0.113至0.466,p<0.001)及EA与E-CAT(加权kappa=0.385,95%CI:0.226至0.544,p<0.001)之间显示统计学显著的一般一致性。
  • DPI与ECS(rs=0.202,p=0.004)、DPI与EA(rs=0.344,p<0.001)、DPI与E-CAT(rs=0.364,p<0.001)之间显示统计学显著的弱正相关。

关键数值与推荐

  • ECS中复杂度评分增加最常见原因为「根管可疏通性」(47%)。
  • DPI中复杂度评分增加最常见原因为「牙髓治疗需求」(84.1%)。
  • EA和E-CAT使用的未知算法妨碍了识别导致牙髓治疗复杂度增加的具体因素。

临床怎么用

  • 在牙髓病学培训病例分配中,可参考ECS和E-CAT进行复杂度分级,两者一致性中等至较高。
  • DPI评估范围更广,其专科转诊截断值3与ECS、E-CAT和EA的一致性更高,可考虑用于转诊决策。
  • EA倾向于给出更高复杂度评分,使用时需注意其与ECS的差异。

局限性

  • EA和E-CAT的算法未知,无法识别具体复杂度贡献因素。
  • 研究仅基于卡迪夫大学牙科医院的病例记录,外推需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To assess the complexity of root canal treatments allocated to Postgraduate Endodontology trainees at Cardiff University Dental Hospital (CUDH) using the English Clinical Standards for Restorative Dentistry (ECS) in comparison with the Dental Practicality Index (DPI), the EndoApp (EA), and the Endodontic Complexity Assessment Tool (E-CAT). MATERIAL AND METHODS: Two-hundred-and-one case records were evaluated by two calibrated examiners using each complexity assessment system. Inter-examiner and intra-examiner variability was calculated using Cohen's kappa coefficient. Statistical analyses compared the scores obtained for the same case using the different systems. RESULTS: Most cases were assigned level 3 complexity using ECS, EA and E-CAT (82%, 92% and 74.1%, respectively), and scores of 3-5 (78.6%) using DPI. EA consistently assigned higher complexity scores compared with ECS and E-CAT. E-CAT assigned lower complexity scores compared with ECS. A statistically significant moderate-substantial level of agreement was demonstrated between E-CAT and ECS (weighted kappa = 0.647 [95% CI: 0.517 to 0.776], p < 0.001). A statistically significant fair level of agreement was demonstrated between EA and ECS (weighted kappa = 0.290 [95% CI: 0.113 to 0.466], p < 0.001) and EA and E-CAT (weighted kappa: 0.385 [95% CI: 0.226 to 0.544], p < 0.001). A statistically significant weak positive correlation was found between DPI and ECS [Spearman's correlation coefficient (rs) = 0.202, p = 0.004], DPI and EA (rs = 0.344, p < 0.001), and DPI and E-CAT (rs = 0.364, p < 0.001). The most common cause of increase in complexity scores was 'canal negotiability' for ECS (47%) and the 'endodontic treatment need' for DPI (84.1%). The unknown algorithm used by EA and E-CAT prevented the identification of specific factors that contributed to the endodontic treatment complexity. CONCLUSION: The majority of cases treated at CUDH were of high complexity. E-CAT assigned slightly lower complexity scores compared with ECS and EA, potentially due to its detailed assessment of factors. A weak positive correlation was found between the complexity grading systems. DPI's broader assessment justifies a cut-off score of 3 for specialist referral due to the increased agreement with ECS, E-CAT and EA at this threshold.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ghazi N, Singh HA, Longbottom E, et al. Assessment of Case Complexity of Root Canal Treatments Using Contemporary Complexity Grading Systems: A Clinical Service Evaluation. Int Endod J. 2025. PMID: 41051079. doi:10.1111/iej.70039

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。