文献速递儿童口腔

Hall技术修复乳磨牙大面积龋的预后与咬合评价临床研究

[Clinical study on prognosis and occlusal evaluation of large area caries of deciduous molars restored by Hall technique].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2025-01-01

该研究纳入Hall技术组21例与传统金属预成冠组22例患儿,随访术后1、2、3个月预后,并对Hall组在术前至术后8周用Dental Prescale Ⅱ分析咬合、用三维有限元分析应力。两组失败率差异无统计学意义,Hall组咬合面积、咬合力、覆牙合及尖牙关系术后即刻下降后于8周恢复至术前水平。

要点

  • Hall技术与传统金属预成冠在术后3个月内失败率差异无统计学意义。
  • Hall技术术后即刻咬合面积、咬合力、覆牙合及尖牙关系下降,8周恢复至术前。
  • 三维有限元显示Hall技术术后即刻应力升高,咬合调整后降至与传统预成冠相近。

核心结论

  • 研究观察期内Hall方案治疗后咬合及临床预后与传统金属预成冠技术未见明显差别,支持Hall方案用于乳磨牙大面积龋损治疗。

研究设计与样本

  • 纳入2021年5月至2022年12月四川大学华西口腔医院儿童口腔科患儿,Hall方案组21例(男12、女9,年龄(5.0±1.4)岁),传统金属预成冠组22例(男15、女7,年龄(5.1±1.3)岁)。
  • 两组术后1、2、3个月随访疗效,结局分为成功、部分失败和完全失败。
  • Hall方案组另于术前、术后即刻及术后2、4、8周用Dental Prescale Ⅱ系统分析咬合,并记录垂直距离、覆牙合覆盖及尖牙关系。
  • 采用三维有限元对传统金属预成冠与Hall方案患牙建模并比较受力差异。

主要发现

  • 术后1个月两组完全失败和部分失败均为0例;术后2个月Hall组完全失败0例、部分失败1例,传统组均为0例;术后3个月Hall组完全失败和部分失败均为1例,传统组均为0例。
  • 两组完全失败及部分失败发生率差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。
  • Hall组咬合面积由术前(14.79±3.55)mm2降至术后即刻(10.15±3.17)mm2(P=0.001),术后8周恢复至(15.58±3.39)mm2(与术前比P>0.05)。
  • Hall组咬合力由术前(436.94±109.59)N降至术后即刻(292.70±96.05)N(P=0.001),术后8周恢复至(441.86±104.31)N(与术前比P>0.05)。
  • Hall组覆牙合由术前(2.54±1.05)mm降至术后即刻(1.80±0.94)mm(P=0.044),术后8周恢复至(2.35±1.02)mm(与术前比P>0.05);尖牙关系由术前(3.12±0.54)mm降至术后即刻(2.17±0.89)mm(P=0.001),术后8周恢复至(3.05±0.61)mm(与术前比P>0.05)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 成功定义为牙冠在位、无牙髓炎或根尖周炎症状、咬合未见明显异常且无需进一步治疗。
  • 部分失败定义为牙冠脱落或破损但牙体缺损可修复,或可逆性牙髓炎;完全失败定义为不可逆性牙髓炎或根尖周炎、牙冠脱落且牙体缺损不可修复。
  • 三维有限元中金属预成冠垂直向及斜向载荷由180.11和496.16 MPa降至108.05和297.69 MPa,牙釉质由94.83和255.94 MPa降至57.21和156.44 MPa,牙本质由55.19和124.77 MPa降至33.19和74.59 MPa。

临床怎么用

  • 乳磨牙大面积龋可考虑Hall技术修复,其短期预后与传统金属预成冠相近。
  • Hall技术术后即刻可能出现咬合面积、咬合力及覆牙合暂时下降,需向家长说明并随访至恢复。
  • 术后应关注咬合调整,有限元提示咬合调整后应力可降至与传统预成冠相近水平。

局限性

  • 研究观察期较短,仅随访至术后3个月(预后)及术后8周(咬合)。
  • 样本量较小,Hall组21例、传统组22例。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To evaluate the prognosis of Hall technique and traditional performed metal crown (PMC) restoration technique, and to follow up the occlusal changes before and after treatment with Hall technique, providing references for the promotion of Hall technique. Methods: Children who visited the Department of Pediatric Dentistry, West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University from May 2021 to December 2022 were screened according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The therapeutic effects of the two groups were followed up at three time points: 1, 2 and 3 months after operation. The observation results were divided into three outcomes: success (crown in place, no symptoms of pulpitis or periapical periodontitis, no obvious abnormality in occlusion, no need for further treatment), partial failure (crown falling off or crown broken, tooth defect can be repaired, reversible pulpitis) and complete failure (irreversible pulpitis or periapical periodontitis, crown falling off and tooth defect irreparable), and statistical analysis was made. At the same time, the Hall technique group was followed up at five time points as before operation, immediately after operation, 2 weeks after operation, 4 weeks after operation and 8 weeks after operation respectively, in which the occlusion was analyzed by Dental Prescale Ⅱ system. The vertical dimension of occlusion (VDO), overbite and coverage, and canine relationship were recorded and compared. Three-dimensional finite element method was used to model and analyze the stress of the teeth treated with traditional PMC treatment and Hall technique, and the differences between them were compared. Results: Finally, 21 children were included in the Hall technique group, including 12 boys and 9 girls, with age of (5.0±1.4) years. Meanwhile, 22 children including 15 boys and 7 girls were in the traditional PMC group, with age of (5.1±1.3) years. There were 0 cases of complete failure and 0 cases of partial failure both in the Hall technique group and in the traditional PMC group within 1 month. There were 0 cases of complete failure and 1 case of partial failure in the Hall technique group, while 0 cases of complete failure and 0 cases of partial failure in the traditional PMC group within 2 months after operation. Hall technique group failed completely in 1 case and partially in 1 case, while the traditional pre-crown group failed completely in 0 cases and partially in 0 cases 3 months after operation. There was no significant difference in the incidence of primary index/complete failure and secondary index/partial failure between Hall technique group and traditional PMC group (all P>0.05). The occlusal area and occlusal force of children treated with Hall technique decreased immediately after operation compared with those before operation, but gradually recovered to the preoperative level at 2, 4 and 8 weeks after operation. To elaborate, the occlusal area decreased significantly from (14.79±3.55) mm2 before operation to (10.15±3.17) mm2 immediately after operation (P=0.001), and recovered to (15.58±3.39) mm2 at 8 weeks after operation (P>0.05 compared with pre-operation). The occlusal force decreased significantly from (436.94±109.59) N before operation to (292.70±96.05) N immediately after operation (P=0.001), and recovered to (441.86±104.31) N at 8 weeks after operation (P>0.05 compared with pre-operation). Overbite decreased significantly from (2.54±1.05) mm before operation to (1.80±0.94) mm immediately after operation (P=0.044) and then recovered to (2.35±1.02) mm (P>0.05 compared with pre-operation). The coverage changed from (2.41±0.66) mm before operation to (2.27±0.61) mm immediately after operation (P>0.05) and then recovered to (2.48±0.62) mm (P>0.05 compared with pre-operation). The canine relationship was (3.12±0.54) mm before operation, and decreased significantly immediately after operation (2.17±0.89) mm (P=0.001), and recovered to (3.05±0.61) mm after 8 weeks (P>0.05 compared with pre-operation). In the three-dimensional finite element analysis, the maximum stress of all parts of the affected tooth increased immediately after Hall technique treatment, but with occlusal adjustment, the maximum stress of all parts of the affected tooth decreased, which was similar to that of the traditional metal pre-crown group. The vertical load and oblique load of pre-crown decreased from 180.11 and 496.16 MPa to 108.05 and 297.69 MPa, respectively. The vertical load and oblique load of enamel decreased from 94.83 and 255.94 MPa to 57.21 and 156.44 MPa, respectively. The vertical load and oblique load of dentin decreased from 55.19 and 124.77 MPa to 33.19 and 74.59 MPa, respectively. Conclusions: During the experimental observation period, there is no obvious difference between Hall technique and traditional PMC treatment technology in terms of post-treatment occlusion and clinical prognosis, which supports clinical application. 目的: 评估比较金属预成冠Hall方案与传统金属预成冠修复技术的疗效,追踪随访Hall方案治疗前后的咬合改变,为Hall方案的临床推广提供参考。 方法: 根据纳入和排除标准,对2021年5月至2022年12月期间就诊于四川大学华西口腔医院儿童口腔科的患儿进行筛选,按随机数字表法将筛选出的患儿纳入Hall方案组及传统金属预成冠组。分别对两组患儿术后1、2、3个月的治疗效果进行追踪随访。将观察结果分为成功(牙冠在位,无牙髓炎或根尖周炎症状,咬合未见明显异常,无需进一步治疗)、部分失败(牙冠脱落或牙冠破损,牙体缺损但可进行修复,可逆性牙髓炎)、完全失败(牙齿出现不可逆性牙髓炎或根尖周炎,牙冠脱落且牙体缺损不可修复)3个结局,对两组患儿3个时间点的观察结果进行统计学分析。同时对Hall方案组分别于术前、术后即刻及术后2、4、8周5个时间点进行追踪,采用Dental Prescale Ⅱ系统进行咬合分析;对患儿(牙合)垂直距离(VDO)、覆(牙合)覆盖及尖牙关系进行记录并比较。采用三维有限元对采用传统金属预成冠治疗以及采用Hall方案治疗的患牙进行建模和受力分析,比较两者在受力时的差异。 结果: Hall方案组纳入21例,其中男性12例,女性9例,年龄(5.0±1.4)岁;传统金属预成冠组22例,其中男性15例,女性7例,年龄(5.1±1.3)岁。Hall方案组和传统金属预成冠组术后1个月完全失败和部分失败均为0例;术后2个月,Hall方案组完全失败0例、部分失败1例,传统金属预成冠组完全失败和部分失败均为0例;术后3个月,Hall方案组完全失败和部分失败均为1例,传统金属预成冠组完全失败和部分失败均为0例;两组在完全失败及部分失败上的发生率差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。Hall方案组患儿咬合面积由术前的(14.79±3.55)mm2显著降低至术后即刻的(10.15±3.17)mm2(P=0.001),术后8周时恢复至(15.58±3.39)mm2(与术前相比P>0.05);咬合力由术前的(436.94±109.59)N显著降低至术后即刻的(292.70±96.05)N(P=0.001),术后8周时恢复至(441.86±104.31)N(与术前相比P>0.05);覆(牙合)由术前的(2.54±1.05)mm显著降低至术后即刻的(1.80±0.94)mm(P=0.044),术后8周时恢复至(2.35±1.02)mm(与术前相比P>0.05);尖牙关系术前为(3.12±0.54)mm,术后即刻显著降至(2.17±0.89)mm(P=0.001),术后8周时后恢复至(3.05±0.61)mm(与术前相比P>0.05)。三维有限元分析显示,Hall方案治疗后即刻,患牙各部分承受的最大应力值升高,但随着咬合调整,患牙各部分最大应力值降低,与传统金属预成冠组相近,其中金属预成冠的垂直向载荷及斜向载荷由180.11和496.16 MPa分别降低至108.05和297.69 MPa;牙釉质的垂直向载荷及斜向载荷由94.83和255.94 MPa分别降低至57.21和156.44 MPa;牙本质的垂直向载荷及斜向载荷由55.19和124.77 MPa分别降低至33.19和74.59 MPa。 结论: 在研究观察时期内,Hall方案治疗后咬合及临床预后与传统金属预成冠治疗技术未见明显差别,支持Hall方案用于乳磨牙大面积龋损的治疗。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. He PC, Li YT, Wang SW, et al. [Clinical study on prognosis and occlusal evaluation of large area caries of deciduous molars restored by Hall technique]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2025. PMID: 41015454. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20250301-00059

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。