下颌磨牙近中根管阶梯式扩大:micro-CT与CFD分析
本研究通过micro-CT和计算流体动力学评估下颌第一磨牙近中根管使用ProTaper Next逐步扩大后的成形效果与冲洗液流场。结果显示扩大显著增加根管容积和表面积并减少未预备区域,但根分叉下1-2 mm处最小牙本质厚度从术前均值约1 mm降至40/.06v后的0.60 mm,且牙本质<0.5 mm的截面比例从0%升至26%。冲洗有效性更多受针头设计影响而非尺寸本身。
要点
- 阶梯式扩大改善成形与冲洗流场,但额外扩大获益有限。
- 40/.06v后根分叉下1-2 mm最小牙本质厚度降至0.60 mm,需警惕。
- 开口针较侧开口针更易将冲洗液送达工作长度并产生更高壁面剪切应力。
核心结论
- 逐步根尖扩大改善成形和冲洗液动力学,但进一步扩大获益有限。
- 冲洗有效性更多受针头设计影响而非仅尺寸,优化输送系统可在减少不必要的牙本质去除的同时提高清洁效率。
研究设计与样本
- 采用micro-CT和计算流体动力学评估下颌第一磨牙近中根管用ProTaper Next(25/.06v、30/.07v、40/.06v)扩大后的成形能力与冲洗液流型。
- 用3D扫描、扫描电镜、能谱分析和差示扫描量热法评估器械设计与冶金特性以确保制造一致性。
- 选取一颗含两个弯曲近中根管的离体下颌磨牙,经micro-CT扫描生成3D模型用于CFD模拟。
- 数据采用重复测量方差分析(ANOVA)及Bonferroni校正(P < .05)。
主要发现
- 除尺寸外,所有器械具有相似的冶金特征和设计特点,仅表面有轻微瑕疵。
- 开口针始终能将冲洗液送达工作长度,而侧开口针则不能。
- 扩大略微增加根尖流速和冲洗液密度,开口针尤为明显,并产生更高壁面剪切应力和根尖压力。
- 根管容积和表面积随较大器械显著增加(P < .05),未预备区域减少。
- 逐步扩大显著降低近中根管远中侧最小牙本质厚度(根分叉下1-2 mm处最明显),从术前均值约1 mm降至40/.06v后的0.60 mm(P < .05),牙本质<0.5 mm的截面比例从0%增至26%,>1 mm的比例明显下降。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用ProTaper Next 25/.06v、30/.07v、40/.06v进行阶梯式扩大。
- CFD模拟在ANSYS Fluent中计算冲洗液流速、壁面剪切应力和根尖压力。
- 统计学显著性设定为P < .05,采用重复测量ANOVA及Bonferroni校正。
临床怎么用
- 临床进行近中根管逐步扩大时应权衡成形与冲洗改善的获益与牙本质去除风险。
- 根分叉下1-2 mm区域牙本质厚度有限,扩大至40/.06v时需警惕牙本质<0.5 mm比例增加。
- 冲洗效果受针头设计影响较大,选择合适输送系统可能比单纯增大器械尺寸更重要。
局限性
- CFD模拟基于单颗离体牙的3D模型,可能无法完全代表体内复杂情况。
- 研究为离体实验,未评估临床长期 outcomes。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: To evaluate how stepwise enlargement in the mesial root canals of mandibular first molars affect shaping outcomes and irrigant dynamics. METHODS: The shaping ability and irrigant flow patterns in mesial canals of mandibular first molars enlarged with ProTaper Next instruments (25/.06v, 30/.07v, 40/.06v) were evaluated using micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) and computational fluid dynamics (CFD). Instrument design and metallurgical properties were assessed by 3D scanning, scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, and differential scanning calorimetry to ensure manufacturing consistency. An extracted mandibular molar with two curved mesial root canals was selected and scanned by micro-CT to generate 3D models for CFD simulation. Root canals were prepared stepwise with the ProTaper Next. Digital canal and needle geometries were reconstructed from micro-CT and scanning electron microscopy data. CFD simulations were conducted in ANSYS Fluent to calculate irrigant velocity, wall shear stress, and apical pressure. For shaping analysis, ten mesial canals from 5 mandibular molars were scanned before and after each preparation step. Canal volume, surface area, unprepared surfaces, and pericervical dentine thickness were quantified. Data were analyzed using repeated measures ANOVA with Bonferroni correction (P < .05). RESULTS: Excluding for dimensions, all instruments shared similar metallurgical features and design characteristics, with minor surface imperfections. The open-ended needle consistently delivered irrigant to the working length, unlike the side-vented needle. Enlargement slightly increased apical velocity and irrigant density, particularly with the open-ended needle, which also generated higher wall shear stress and apical pressure. Canal volume and surface area increased significantly with larger files (P < .05), while unprepared areas decreased. Progressive canal enlargement significantly reduced minimal dentine thickness at the distal aspect of the mesial canals (most at 1-2 mm below the furcation), dropping from preoperative means of ∼1 mm to 0.60 mm after the 40/.06v instrument (P < .05), with the proportion of sections with dentine <0.5 mm increasing from 0% to 26%, while those >1 mm decreased markedly. CONCLUSIONS: Progressive apical enlargement improved shaping and irrigant dynamics, but additional increases offered limited benefits. Irrigant effectiveness was more influenced by needle design than by size alone, suggesting that optimizing delivery systems may enhance cleaning efficiency while minimizing unnecessary dentine removal.
引用
- Furtado SM, Martins JNR, Silva EJNL, et al. Integrated Micro-Computed Tomography and Computational Fluid Dynamics Analysis of Stepwise Enlargement in Mesial Root Canals of Mandibular Molars. J Endod. 2025. PMID: 40930490. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2025.09.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。