锥形束CT重建乳牙三维解剖模型的准确性评估:以显微CT为金标准
本研究以显微CT为金标准,验证锥形束CT(CBCT)重建乳牙三维解剖模型的准确性。收集13颗离体乳牙(5颗前牙、8颗磨牙,共34个根管),分别行显微CT(体素0.018 mm)和CBCT(体素0.125 mm)扫描并重建模型,配准后进行偏差分析和关键解剖参数测量。结果显示CBCT模型硬组织形态较准确,准确识别97.1%(33/34)根管,匹配点平均距离硬组织为(0.01±0.03)mm、髓室根管系统为(0.00±0.03)mm,长度测量值整体偏小但临床影响可接受,证实CBCT用于乳牙解剖重建具有可行性。
要点
- CBCT(体素0.125 mm)重建乳牙模型可准确识别97.1%(33/34)根管。
- CBCT与显微CT模型匹配点平均距离硬组织(0.01±0.03)mm、髓室根管(0.00±0.03)mm。
- CBCT模型硬组织及髓室根管长度测量值较显微CT偏小,但临床影响可接受。
核心结论
- 以显微CT为金标准,体素0.125 mm的CBCT是重建乳牙的有效工具,重建模型适用于乳牙解剖研究。
研究设计与样本
- 收集13颗因疾病拔除、牙根完整的离体乳牙(5颗乳前牙、8颗乳磨牙,共34个根管),分别行显微CT(体素0.018 mm)和CBCT(体素0.125 mm)扫描并重建三维解剖模型。
- 基于迭代最近点算法将两种CT重建模型配准后进行偏差分析,并在两种模型上测量关键解剖数据、计算差值。
主要发现
- CBCT重建模型硬组织形态较准确,准确识别97.1%(33/34)的根管数目。
- CBCT与显微CT模型匹配点平均距离:硬组织(0.01±0.03)mm,髓室根管系统(0.00±0.03)mm,不影响临床观察。
- CBCT模型硬组织及髓室根管系统长度测量值均小于显微CT模型(P<0.05),差值95%一致性界限分别为(-0.70,0.14)mm和(-1.93,1.00)mm,对临床操作的影响均在可接受范围内。
关键数值与推荐
- CBCT体素大小0.125 mm,显微CT体素大小0.018 mm。
- 根管识别准确率97.1%(33/34)。
- 硬组织长度差值95%一致性界限(-0.70,0.14)mm,髓室根管系统长度差值95%一致性界限(-1.93,1.00)mm。
临床怎么用
- 体素0.125 mm的CBCT可用于乳牙三维解剖重建,支持乳牙解剖学研究。
- CBCT模型长度测量值整体偏小,临床解读时应考虑该偏差,但影响在可接受范围内。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To validate the accuracy of three-dimensional anatomical models reconstructed from cone beam CT (CBCT) using micro-CT as the gold standard, and to evaluate the feasibility of performing anatomical analyses on such models. Methods: A total of 13 isolated deciduous teeth with intact roots were collected, including 5 anterior teeth and 8 molars, with a total of 34 root canals. The teeth were extracted from children aged 3-9 years who visited Peking University Hospital of Stomatology from January 2019 to April 2022 due to trauma or periapical disease, and were then scanned by micro-CT (with a voxel size of 0.018 mm) and CBCT (with a voxel size of 0.125 mm), respectively. Using a threshold-based semi-automated region segmentation method, anatomical models of these isolated teeth were reconstructed from the two CTs. Subsequently, the two CT reconstructed models were registered based on the iterative closest point algorithm, followed by deviation analysis. The key anatomical parameters were measured on the micro-CT and CBCT models, respectively, and the differences were calculated. Results: The CBCT reconstruction models were relatively accurate in the hard tissue morphology, and 97.1% (33/34) of the root canals were identified accurately. When it comes to the deviation analysis, the average distance between the matched points on the CBCT reconstruction models and the micro-CT models was (0.01±0.03) mm for the hard tissue, and (0.00±0.03) mm for the pulp chambers and canals, which did not affect clinical observation. The hard tissue and root canal length of CBCT models were both smaller than those of micro-CT models (P<0.05), with a 95% limits of agreement of (-0.70, 0.14) mm for the hard tissue, and a 95% limits of agreement of (-1.93, 1.00) mm for the pulp chambers and canals. The impact of these differences on clinical operations was all within the acceptable range. Conclusions: Using micro-CT as a validate standard, CBCT with a voxel size of 0.125 mm was proved to be an effective tool for the reconstruction of deciduous teeth. Therefore, the reconstructed models were appropriate for studying deciduous teeth anatomy. 目的: 以显微CT为金标准,验证使用锥形束CT影像重建乳牙三维解剖模型的准确性,及使用锥形束CT重建模型进行乳牙解剖学研究的可行性。 方法: 收集2021年6月至2025年1月期间于北京大学口腔医学院·口腔医院儿童口腔科就诊的3~9岁儿童因疾病原因拔除、具有完整牙根的离体乳牙共13颗,其中包括5颗乳前牙和8颗乳磨牙,根管数目共计34个。分别进行体素大小0.018 mm的显微CT和体素大小0.125 mm的锥形束CT扫描。从两种CT数据中重建离体牙的三维解剖模型,基于迭代最近点算法将两种CT重建模型配准后进行偏差分析,并在两种重建模型上分别进行关键解剖数据的测量,计算二者间的差值。 结果: 锥形束CT重建模型准确识别了97.1%(33/34)的根管数目。在锥形束CT重建模型与显微CT模型进行匹配分析时,硬组织与髓室根管系统部分的匹配点平均距离分别为(0.01±0.03)和(0.00±0.03)mm。锥形束CT模型的硬组织及髓室根管系统长度测量值较显微CT模型整体偏小,差值的95%一致性界限分别为(-0.70,0.14)及(-1.93,1.00)mm。上述差异对临床操作的影响均在可接受范围内。 结论: 本研究以显微CT为金标准,证实了使用体素大小为0.125 mm的锥形束CT进行乳牙解剖结构三维重建的准确性,使用锥形束CT重建模型进行乳牙解剖学研究具有可行性。.
引用
- Li KF, Bai J, Zhao YJ, et al. [Accuracy assessment of cone beam CT-reconstructed three-dimensional anatomical models of primary teeth using micro-CT]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2025. PMID: 41015455. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20250718-00273
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。