牙医对活动性非龋洞性病变修复治疗阈值的多国差异
3680名牙医提供7360份有效回复,高龋风险显著预测更早干预(咬合面OR=0.34;邻面OR=0.38,p<0.001),总体指南依从率低(低风险22.7%,高风险32.7%),国家间差异显著。
要点
- 高龋风险显著预测更早干预,咬合面OR=0.34,邻面OR=0.38,p<0.001。
- 总体指南依从率低:低风险22.7%,高风险32.7%。
- 女性牙医和修复专科医生更保守,年龄无显著影响。
核心结论
- 尽管全球推广微创牙科,牙釉质病变的过度治疗仍普遍存在。
- 需要解决系统性、教育和政策层面的障碍以提高循证、风险知情龋病管理的依从性。
研究设计与样本
- 标准化问卷包含咬合面和邻面活动性非龋洞性龋损四个进展阶段(E1、E2、EDJ、D1)的影像学情景。
- 调查对象为全科牙医和专科医生,共3680名牙医提供7360份有效回复。
主要发现
- 高龋风险显著预测更早干预(咬合面OR=0.34;邻面OR=0.38,p<0.001)。
- 女性牙医和修复专科医生更保守,年龄无显著影响。
- 总体指南依从率低:低风险情景22.7%,高风险情景32.7%。
- 国家间差异显著,孟加拉国和葡萄牙依从性最高,哈萨克斯坦和哥伦比亚表现出过度治疗倾向。
关键数值与推荐
- 指南一致的基准预先定义为:低风险患者为D1,高风险患者为EDJ/D1。
- 任何更早的选择被编码为过度治疗。
临床怎么用
- 临床应依据龋风险分层选择干预阈值,避免对釉质病变过度治疗。
- 低风险患者应延迟至D1,高风险患者可考虑EDJ/D1,以遵循微创原则。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess patterns across 21 countries in dentists' thresholds for initiating operative treatment of active non-cavitated carious lesions and to evaluate the influence of caries risk, clinician characteristics, and geographic variation on decision-making in accordance with current guidelines. METHODS: A cross-sectional, vignette-style web-based survey was conducted between June and October 2023 across 21 countries. A standardized questionnaire, comprising theoretical radiographic scenarios of occlusal and approximal active non-cavitated carious lesions at four progressive stages (E1,E2,EDJ,D1), was distributed to general dentists and specialists. Respondents selected the radiographic threshold at which they would initiate invasive treatment for patients with low and high caries risk. Guideline-concordant benchmarks were predefined as D1 for low-risk and EDJ/D1 for high-risk; any earlier choice was coded as overtreatment. Cumulative-link mixed models estimated determinants of thresholds; guideline concordance was summarized descriptively. RESULTS: A total of 3680 dentists provided 7360 valid responses. High caries risk significantly predicted earlier intervention (occlusal OR= 0.34; approximal OR= 0.38, p < 0.001). Female dentists and restorative specialists were more conservative, while age showed no significant effect. Overall guideline adherence was low (22.7 % in low-risk and 32.7 % in high-risk scenarios). Substantial inter-country variation was observed; Bangladesh and Portugal showed highest adherence, while Kazakhstan and Colombia demonstrated overtreatment tendencies. CONCLUSIONS: Despite global promotion of minimally invasive dentistry, overtreatment of enamel lesions remains widespread. Addressing systemic, educational, and policy-level barriers is essential to improve adherence to evidence-based, risk-informed caries management. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This multinational study highlights substantial variability and premature intervention in caries management across countries. Identifying patterns of overtreatment and guideline discordance informs dental education and policy, emphasizing the urgent need to reinforce minimally invasive, risk-based strategies in clinical practice across participating countries.
引用
- Hatipoğlu Ö, Taha N, Karobari MI, et al. Variations in dentists' thresholds for restorative treatment of active non-cavitated carious lesions: a multinational cross-sectional study. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40915495. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.106092
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。