混合现实导航与CAD/CAM导板及患者特异性手术板在Le Fort I截骨中上颌骨定位精度的临床前研究
本研究开发了基于混合现实(MR)的导航系统,并在3D打印上颌骨模型(每组10个)和人类尸体标本(MR组与PSSP组各9个)中,与CAD/CAM导板及患者特异性手术板(PSSP)比较Le Fort I截骨中上颌骨定位精度。模型上MR与PSSP的质心、垂直向和俯仰误差显著低于CAD/CAM导板;尸体上MR的俯仰精度优于PSSP。MR组平均表面偏差0.73 mm,PSSP组1.04 mm,MR手术时间稍长但术中调整更少,差异无统计学意义。
要点
- 模型上MR与PSSP定位精度优于CAD/CAM导板。
- 尸体上MR俯仰控制优于PSSP。
- MR平均表面偏差0.73 mm,PSSP为1.04 mm。
核心结论
- MR导航在模型上定位精度优于CAD/CAM导板,在尸体上俯仰控制优于PSSP。
研究设计与样本
- 开发带光学跟踪和自动配准的相邻显示MR导航系统用于实时手术引导。
主要发现
- 模型上MR与PSSP的质心、垂直向和俯仰误差显著低于CAD/CAM导板。
- 尸体上MR的俯仰精度优于PSSP。
- MR组平均表面偏差0.73 mm,PSSP组1.04 mm。
- 与PSSP相比,MR组手术时间稍长但术中调整更少,差异无统计学意义。
临床怎么用
- 所提出的MR系统可能通过提高上颌骨定位的精准性和实时可控性来辅助Le Fort I截骨手术。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Accurate maxillary repositioning is essential for successful outcomes in orthognathic surgery. Current studies on mixed reality (MR) navigation are limited and lack comparison. This study developed an MR-based navigation system and compared it with computer-aided design/computer-aided manufacturing (CAD/CAM) splints and patient-specific surgical plates (PSSPs) in Le Fort I osteotomy. METHODS: An adjacent-display MR system with optical tracking and automated registration was developed for real-time surgical guidance. Thirty 3D-printed maxillary models were equally assigned to three groups (n=10 each): MR, CAD/CAM splints, and PSSPs. Eighteen human cadaveric specimens were randomly allocated to the MR or PSSP groups (n=9 each). All procedures were performed by the same surgical team.Outcomes included centroid, translational (X, Y, Z), rotational (pitch, yaw, roll), and surface deviations; operative time; and intraoperative adjustments. Deviations were assessed by aligning the planned and postoperative STL files, followed by quantitative and visual analyses using angular plane measurements and color-coded 3D deviation maps. RESULTS: In models, MR and PSSPs showed significantly lower centroid, vertical, and pitch errors than did CAD/CAM splints. In cadavers, MR had better pitch accuracy than that of PSSPs. Mean surface deviation was 0.73 and 1.04 mm for MR and PSSPs, respectively. Compared to PSSPs, the MR group had a slightly longer operative time but fewer intraoperative adjustments, with no significant differences. CONCLUSION: MR-based navigation demonstrated superior repositioning accuracy relative to CAD/CAM splints in models and improved pitch control over PSSPs in cadavers. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The proposed MR system may support surgeons during Le Fort I osteotomy by improving the precision and real-time controllability of maxillary repositioning.
引用
- Ma C, He SX, Shang YY, et al. Accuracy of maxillary repositioning in le fort I osteotomy using a mixed reality based navigation system versus CAD/CAM splints and patient-specific surgical plates: A preclinical study. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40818515. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.106032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。