西班牙牙周病学会基金会Delphi法调查:种植体周围炎预防的临床趋势
该研究采用基于Delphi法的两步调查,由西班牙牙周病学会(SEPA)选取44名<45岁参与者,对75条关于种植体周围炎预防的陈述进行共识评估。第二轮后51/75条(68.0%)达成共识,其中36条(48.0%)同意、15条(20.0%)不同意;口腔卫生部分共识最高,手术和修复相关因素冲突最大。
要点
- 约68.0%的陈述在第二轮达成共识,口腔卫生部分共识最高。
- 手术和修复相关因素争议最大,分别有9/18和8/14条未定。
- 病因与流行病学及种植体相关因素多数条目达成共识。
核心结论
- 该研究关于种植体周围炎预防的临床趋势显示,约70%的评估陈述达成共识。
研究设计与样本
- 基于Delphi法的两步调查,由指导委员会准备75条陈述,SEPA选取<45岁参与者回答。
- 共44名参与者同意参与调查,陈述分为5个主要领域。
主要发现
- 第一轮75条中35条(46.7%)达成共识。
- 未达共识的40条中,第二轮有16条(40.0%)达成共识。
- 总体第二轮51/75条(68.0%)达成共识,其中36条(48.0%)同意、15条(20.0%)不同意。
- 手术相关因素领域9/18条、修复相关因素领域8/14条显示未定共识。
- 病因与流行病学领域14/17条、种植体相关因素领域10/13条达成共识;口腔卫生领域仅1/13条有异议。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess clinical trends to prevent peri-implantitis in applying a two-step survey based on the Delphi method. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A panel of participants aged < 45 years old selected by the Spanish Society of Periodontology (SEPA) was asked to answer a survey with 75 statements prepared by a steering committee. Items were divided into 5 major areas: etiopathogenesis and epidemiology, surgical, implant, and prosthetic-related factors on the onset/progression of peri-implantitis, and self- and professional-administered oral hygiene. Degree of agreement or disagreement among participants was reported. RESULTS: In total, 44 participants responded favorably to participate in the survey. From the 75 statements formulated, 35 were agreed on in a first round (46.7%). From the 40 statements that did not reach consensus, 16 were agreed on in a second round (40.0%). Overall, 51 out of 75 statements (68.0%) achieved consensus in a second round. From these, 36 (48.0%) were in agreement, while 15 (20.0%) were in disagreement. The sections that explored surgical-related factors and prosthesis-related factors of peri-implantitis yielded the highest level of conflict (9/18 and 8/14 statements demonstrated indeterminate agreement, respectively). In the sections on the etiopathogenesis and epidemiology of peri-implantitis and implant-related factors, most items reached consensus (14/17 and 10/13 items, respectively). The section on self- and professional-administered oral hygiene obtained the highest level of consensus, with only 1/13 items showing dissent among the participants. CONCLUSION: The results of this study on the clinical trends in the prevention of peri-implantitis showed consensus agreement for ∼70% of the statements evaluated.
引用
- Monje A, Molina A, Argibay O, et al. Clinical Trends in the Prevention of Peri-Implantitis: Spanish Society of Periodontology (SEPA) Foundation Survey Using the Delphi Method. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2025. PMID: 40874380. doi:10.1111/clr.70030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。