骨支持式与牙骨支持式正颌手术导板准确性的系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析比较骨支持式(BB)与牙骨支持式(TBB)正颌手术导板的准确性,共纳入20项研究332例患者(BB 223例,TBB 109例)。BB导板在U1标志点线性偏差略优,TBB导板在U6标志点X、Y轴及角度偏差略优,但差异总体较小且临床意义不显著。结论认为两者均为满意选择,决策应基于监管和后勤因素。
要点
- BB与TBB导板在上颌骨定位准确性上总体差异较小,临床可认为结果相当。
- BB导板在U1标志点线性偏差略优,TBB导板在U6标志点X、Y轴及角度偏差略优。
- 导板选择可综合考虑监管与后勤因素,两者均可作为满意选择。
核心结论
- BB与TBB导板均为满意选择,两者结果可比,临床决策可依据监管和后勤因素灵活选择。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,纳入截至2025年2月的研究,共20项研究332例患者(BB 223例,TBB 109例)。
主要发现
- BB导板在U1标志点X、Y、Z轴偏差分别为0.07 mm、0.10 mm、0.24 mm。
- TBB导板在U6标志点X、Y轴偏差分别为0.19 mm、0.31 mm,仅Z轴偏差0.21 mm劣于BB导板。
- TBB导板角度偏差在pitch、yaw、roll分别为0.35°、0.39°、0.02°,角度准确性更高但差异较小且临床不显著。
临床怎么用
- 临床可认为BB与TBB导板在上颌骨定位准确性上结果相当,可依据监管和后勤条件灵活选择。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Accurate repositioning of the maxilla is a crucial component of orthognathic surgery and can be facilitated by bone-borne (BB) or tooth-bone-borne (TBB) guides. AIMS: The objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to compare the accuracy of BB and TBB surgical guides in orthognathic surgery. Accuracy was defined as the difference between the planned and actual position of the maxilla, measured in linear and angular deviations across three axes. Relevant studies were identified up to February 2025. RESULTS: Twenty studies involving 332 patients (223 BB and 109 TBB) were reviewed. BB guides demonstrated slightly better accuracy at the U1 landmark, with deviations of 0.07 mm, 0.10 mm, and 0.24 mm in the X, Y, and Z axes, respectively. Conversely, TBB guides showed superior accuracy at the U6 landmark, with deviations of 0.19 mm and 0.31 mm in the X and Y axes. However, TBB guides were less accurate only in the Z-axis at U6 (deviation of 0.21 mm) when compared to BB guides. TBB guides also demonstrated higher angular accuracy, with differences of 0.35°, 0.39° and 0.02° for pitch, yaw, and roll respectively. However, these differences were generally small and clinically insignificant. CONCLUSION: Both BB and TBB guides are satisfactory choices, and the decision to use one over the other should be based on regulatory and logistical factors. The available evidence suggests that clinicians can be confident that both options yield comparable results, allowing flexibility in the decision-making process. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This review is the first to directly compare the effectiveness of BB and TBB guides. It provides valuable insights into how guide design influences surgical precision and supports clinical decision-making between the two types of guides.
引用
- Lee KJC, Yong CW, Li H, et al. "Accuracy of bone-borne versus tooth-bone-borne orthognathic surgical guides: A systematic review and meta-analysis". J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40618986. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105940
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。