患者特异性3D打印模型在MTA根尖诱导成形术培训中的接受度与操作误差
本研究比较患者特异性3D打印开根尖模型与离体天然牙在牙髓病研究生MTA根尖诱导成形术培训中的效果。21名住院医师随机分组,每组完成63例操作。3D打印模型接受度高(学业满意度96.6%),整体无误差率86.14%与天然牙相当,但天然牙组在确定工作长度(p=0.043)和获得均匀根尖屏障(p=0.004)上表现更优。
要点
- 3D打印开根尖模型在MTA根尖诱导成形术培训中接受度高,学业满意度达96.6%。
- 两组整体操作无误差率均为86.14%,但天然牙组在确定工作长度和均匀根尖屏障上更优。
- 人工模型在触感和X线性能方面存在轻微问题,但被认为可改进。
核心结论
- 患者特异性3D打印开根尖牙在MTA根尖诱导成形术培训中表现出高接受度并支持技术熟练的操作。
- 整体表现与天然牙相当,但特定操作步骤存在差异,提示人工模型需进一步改进。
研究设计与样本
- 混合体外研究(QUAL-quant),21名牙髓病学研究生住院医师随机分为对照组和实验组。
- 对照组使用63颗离体天然牙,实验组使用63颗源自体内CBCT扫描的患者特异性3D打印开根尖模型。
- 培训后完成学业满意度量表和开根尖模型问卷两项Likert量表调查,并由观察者评估所有操作的X线片。
主要发现
- 3D打印牙在学业满意度量表上 approval 评分为96.6%,在开根尖模型问卷上为70.79%。
- 两组操作无误差率均为86.14%。
- 对照组在确定工作长度(p=0.043)和获得均匀根尖屏障(p=0.004)上显著优于实验组。
- 关键操作变量(如牙科X线表现、根管进入与疏通、工作长度确定、MTA根尖屏障制作)之间存在显著相关性。
关键数值与推荐
- 统计学分析包括描述性统计、Spearman相关、验证性因子分析(CFA)、卡方检验和Fisher精确检验(p ≤ 0.05)。
- 学业满意度量表 approval 评分96.6%,开根尖模型问卷 approval 评分70.79%。
- 两组操作无误差率均为86.14%。
- 确定工作长度比较p=0.043,均匀根尖屏障比较p=0.004。
临床怎么用
- 患者特异性3D打印开根尖模型可作为MTA根尖诱导成形术培训的替代工具,尤其适用于无法获取离体天然牙的场景。
- 使用人工模型培训时需注意其确定工作长度和制作均匀根尖屏障的局限性,可结合额外指导或练习。
局限性
- 人工模型在触感和X线性能方面存在轻微问题,但被认为可改进。
- 研究为体外设计,样本量有限(21名住院医师),结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: Patient-specific 3D-printed dental models present innovative opportunities in endodontic education, offering a bridge between theoretical learning and clinical practice. This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of such models versus extracted natural teeth for training postgraduate residents in the MTA apexification technique, focusing on procedural accuracy and perception. METHODOLOGY: This mixed in vitro study (QUAL-quant) involved 21 postgraduate endodontic residents who were randomly assigned to two groups: The control group (CG), using 63 extracted natural teeth, and the experimental group (EG), using 63 patient-specific 3D-printed open-apex models derived from in vivo CBCT scans. After proper calibration, the participants performed the training sessions including identical procedural steps. Subsequently, the residents completed two Likert scale surveys: Academic Satisfaction Scale and Open-Apex Model Questionnaire. Additionally, an observer reviewed the radiographs of all practices and rated the executed procedures. Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics, Spearman's correlation, confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), chi-square and Fisher's exact tests (p ≤ 0.05). RESULTS: Patient-specific 3D-printed teeth achieved high acceptance rates among residents, with approval scores of 96.6% on the Academic Satisfaction Scale and 70.79% on the Open-Apex Model Questionnaire. Procedural accuracy was comparable across groups, with 86.14% of treatments free of errors in both. Significant correlations were identified among key procedural variables, such as dental radiographic aspect, access and negotiation of the root canal, determination of working length, and creation of the apical barrier with MTA, highlighting the internal consistency of performance patterns of the 3D model. Inferential analyses revealed significant differences in specific procedural steps: the CG outperformed the EG in determining working length (p = 0.043) and achieving a homogeneous apical barrier (p = 0.004). Minor concerns regarding the tactile sensation and radiographic properties of the artificial prototypes were noted but considered addressable. CONCLUSION: Patient-specific 3D-printed open-apex teeth demonstrated high acceptance and supported technically proficient treatments during MTA apexification training. Although overall performance was comparable to that with natural teeth, specific procedural differences suggest that further refinement of the artificial models may enhance their effectiveness as alternative training tools in postgraduate endodontic education.
引用
- Plascencia H, Contreras-Preciado MA, Brito-Ortiz JF, et al. Perceptions and Procedural Errors in the Use of a Patient-Specific 3D-Printed Model for MTA Apexification Technique Training. Int Endod J. 2025. PMID: 40673447. doi:10.1111/iej.70002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。