评估3D打印树脂复合材料后牙固定局部义齿的性能:一项3年前瞻性临床试验
本临床试验纳入49例患者(33女16男,19-60岁)的68件三单位3D打印树脂复合材料后牙固定局部义齿(FDPs),平均观察22.36个月,采用改良FDI标准评估。最终回访时64件FDPs中24件无并发症,40件失败(36件机械失败、6件生物学失败),机械失败生存率40.7%,包含生物学并发症时生存率36.2%。
要点
- 3D打印树脂复合材料后牙FDPs平均观察22.36个月,机械失败生存率40.7%。
- 40件失败FDPs中36件为机械失败、6件为生物学失败,2件同时计入两类。
- 失败主要发生在连接体区域,作者认为需进一步改进设计。
核心结论
- 三年随访结果表明3D打印树脂复合材料FDPs的失败主要发生在连接体区域,提示需要进一步改进设计。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性临床试验,2020年10月10日至2022年8月5日纳入49例患者(33女16男),年龄19至60岁,共68件三单位3D打印树脂复合材料后牙FDPs(ELS Even Stronger,Saremco,瑞士)。
- 放置后两周由两名独立观察者采用改良FDI标准评估,评估参数包括解剖形态、继发龋、边缘适合性、表面粗糙度、颜色匹配、材料断裂、表面染色、边缘染色、固位、牙龈健康和患者满意度。
- 失败分为机械失败和生物学失败,临床试验注册号NCT04600297。
主要发现
- 平均观察期为22.36个月,最终回访时64件FDPs中24件仍无任何并发症在临床服务。
- 随访期间共识别9例断裂发生在最初6个月内,1年后14例,2年后11例,3年后进一步2例。
- 40件失败FDPs中36件为机械失败、6件为生物学失败,其中2件同时计入两类;34件FDPs表现为内聚性断裂。
- 2件FDPs重新粘接,4颗基牙需牙髓治疗,2件出现牙周问题;2件FDPs表面光泽丧失、4件颜色不匹配、4件表面染色(均评分为4)。
- Kaplan-Meier分析显示机械失败生存率为40.7%,纳入生物学并发症时生存率为36.2%。
关键数值与推荐
- 改良FDI标准评估参数包括解剖形态、继发龋、边缘适合性、表面粗糙度、颜色匹配、材料断裂、表面染色、边缘染色、固位、牙龈健康和患者满意度。
- 失败分类为机械失败或生物学失败。
- Kaplan-Meier分析机械失败生存率40.7%,纳入生物学并发症时生存率36.2%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为3D打印树脂复合材料FDPs具有一定优势,但鉴于3年内主要发生机械失败,当前修复体可被视为长期临时修复体。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This clinical trial aimed to assess the clinical performance of 3D-printed resin composite fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) for posterior restorations. METHODS: From October 10, 2020, to August 5, 2022, a total of 49 patients (33 females and 16 males), aged 19 to 60, were treated with 68 three-unit 3D-printed resin composite posterior FDPs (ELS Even Stronger, Saremco, Switzerland). Two weeks after placement, the FDPs were evaluated by two independent observers using modified FDI criteria. Parameters assessed included anatomical form, secondary caries, marginal adaptation, surface roughness, color match, material fracture, surface staining, margin staining, anatomical form, retention, gingival health, and patient satisfaction. Failures were classified as either mechanical or biological. RESULTS: The mean observation period was 22.36 months. At the final recall, of the 64 FDPs, 24 remained in clinical service without any complications, indicating limited long-term success. Almost all restorations maintained normal anatomical contours throughout the follow-up period. During the initial six-month period, 9 instances of fractures were identified, followed by 14 after 1 year, 11 after two-year a further 2 cases after a three-year period of clinical service. Of the 40 failed FDPs, 36 exhibited mechanical failures, while 6 showed biological failures (2 cases exhibited both and were counted in both categories). Thirty-four FDPs showed cohesive fractures. Two FDPs were re-bonded, four abutment teeth required endodontic treatment, and two presented periodontal issues. Additionally, 2 FDPs exhibited a loss of surface luster, 4 exhibited color mismatches, and 4 exhibited surface staining (all scored 4). Kaplan-Meier analysis revealed a 40.7 % survival rate for mechanical failures and a 36.2 % survival rate when biological complications were included. CONCLUSIONS: The results of a three-year follow-up study indicated that 3D-printed resin composite FDPs present failures mainly in the connector region, suggesting the need for further design improvements. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Three-dimensionally printed resin composite FDPs offer certain advantages but current restorations could be considered as long-term provisional due to the incidence of mainly mechanical failures up to 3 years. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: Clinical Trials.Gov, NCT04600297.
引用
- Hobbi P, Ordueri TM, Öztürk-Bozkurt F, et al. Assessing the performance of 3D-printed resin composite posterior fixed dental prostheses: A 3-year prospective clinical trial. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40490049. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105887
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。