应用摄影测量与口内扫描进行全牙弓数字化种植扫描的精度:一项体内交叉研究
该体内交叉研究纳入19个无牙颌牙弓,每个牙弓至少含4枚种植体,分别用口内扫描仪(IOS,3Shape Trios 3)和摄影测量(PG,Imetric ICam 4D,第一代)各扫描5次,通过空间拟合、跨牙弓距离和虚拟Sheffield测试评估精度。结果显示PG在全部三项测试中精度均更高(p < 0.0001);IOS组下颌弓精度低于上颌弓(空间拟合p = 0.040,跨牙弓距离p = 0.026,虚拟Sheffield测试p = 0.019),PG组精度与颌型无显著关联(p > 0.05)。
要点
- PG在全部三项精度测试中均优于IOS(p < 0.0001)。
- IOS组下颌弓精度低于上颌弓,三项测试均达统计学显著。
- PG组精度与颌型无显著关联(p > 0.05)。
核心结论
- PG是全牙弓数字化种植扫描中精度更高的扫描仪。
- 上颌弓扫描精度优于下颌弓,但统计学显著性仅见于IOS组。
研究设计与样本
- 体内交叉研究,纳入19个无牙颌牙弓,每个牙弓至少含4枚种植体。
- 每个牙弓用IOS(3Shape Trios 3)和PG(Imetric ICam 4D,第一代)各扫描5次,于基台水平采集数字化印模。
- 提取种植体笛卡尔坐标,进行空间拟合、跨牙弓距离和虚拟Sheffield测试。
- 采用广义估计方程(GEE)比较IOS与PG在三项测试中的精度,并评估颌型(上颌 vs 下颌)与每种设备精度的关联,显著性水平α=0.05。
主要发现
- PG在全部三项测试中均表现出更高精度(p < 0.0001)。
- PG组精度与颌型无显著关联(p > 0.05)。
- IOS组下颌弓精度低于上颌弓:空间拟合p = 0.040,跨牙弓距离p = 0.026,虚拟Sheffield测试p = 0.019。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对无牙颌固定种植修复使用传统扫描杆行IOS扫描应谨慎,尤其在下颌,因其精度较差。
- 作者认为PG是全牙弓数字化种植扫描中精度更高的扫描仪。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the precision of complete-arch digital implant scans using intraoral scanning (IOS) and photogrammetry (PG). METHODS: Nineteen completely edentulous arches were included. Each arches contained at least four implants. Abutment-level digital scans were taken using IOS (3Shape Trios 3) and PG (Imetric ICam 4D, 1st gen). Each arch was scanned five times with each device. Implant cartesian coordinates were extracted, and the Spatial Fit, Cross-Arch Distance, and Virtual Sheffield tests were conducted. A generalized estimating equation (GEE) analysis was conducted to compare the precision of IOS and PG for the three tests. A GEE was used to assess further the association between jaw type (maxilla vs. mandible) and the precision for each device in all three tests. The significance level was set at α=0.05. RESULTS: PG demonstrated greater precision in all three tests (p < 0.0001). Precision was not significantly associated with jaw type in the PG group (p > 0.05). For IOS, the mandibular arch demonstrated inferior levels of precision compared to the maxilla for the Spatial Fit (p = 0.040), Cross-Arch Distance (p = 0.026), and Virtual Sheffield (p = 0.019) tests. CONCLUSION: PG represented a more precise scanner for complete-arch digital implant scans. Maxillary arch scans were associated with superior precision compared to scans of the mandible, yet statistical significance was only found in the IOS group. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: IOS scanning for fixed implant rehabilitation of the edentulous jaw with conventional scan bodies should be approached with caution due to the poor precision, particularly in the mandible. PG represented a more precise scanner for complete-arch digital implant scans.
引用
- Negreiros WM, Sun TC, Jain S, et al. Precision of complete-arch digital implant scans using photogrammetry and intra-oral scanning. An in vivo cross-over study: Complete-Arch Implant Scans: Photogrammetry vs IOS. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40545227. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105928
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。