一项为期12周的随机对照试验:比较碳酸氢钠牙膏与常规氟化物牙膏刷牙对牙龈炎的影响
这项单中心、检查者盲法、随机、双臂平行对照试验纳入190例≥18岁、≥20颗牙、诊断为局限性牙龈炎的受试者,先用氟化物牙膏适应2周后随机分为碳酸氢钠牙膏组与常规氟化物牙膏组,每日刷牙2次共12周。结果显示碳酸氢钠牙膏组在出血位点数、改良牙龈指数和Turesky菌斑指数上较对照组有显著改善,结论认为其较常规氟化物牙膏更能减轻局限性牙龈炎。
要点
- 碳酸氢钠牙膏组从基线到12周出血位点数显著减少(p=0.0032),且与对照组相比从基线到12周显著减少(p=0.0013)。
- 碳酸氢钠牙膏组平均改良牙龈指数从基线到3、6、12周均较对照组显著降低(均p<0.0001)。
- 碳酸氢钠牙膏组平均总体Turesky菌斑指数从基线到3、6、12周较对照组显著降低(p分别为0.0012、0.0058、p<0.0001)。
核心结论
- 每日两次使用碳酸氢钠牙膏刷牙在12周内通过出血指数、改良牙龈指数和Turesky菌斑指数评估,较常规氟化物牙膏显著改善口腔健康并减轻局限性牙龈炎。
研究设计与样本
- 伦理批准的单中心、对照、检查者盲法、随机、两治疗臂平行研究,纳入知情同意的健康≥18岁、≥20颗牙、诊断为局限性牙龈炎的参与者。
- 约200例合格参与者先用氟化物适应牙膏刷牙2周,随后随机分为每日刷牙2次使用碳酸氢钠牙膏(试验组)或氟化物牙膏(对照组)。
- 研究开始前未进行预防性洁治;在基线、3周、6周和12周测量改良牙龈指数、出血指数和Turesky菌斑指数,参与者填写日记监测依从性。
- 190例参与者被随机分组,188例完成研究。
主要发现
- 试验组出血位点数从基线到12周显著减少(p=0.0032)、到6周显著减少(p=0.0031)、到3周显著减少(p=0.0091),且与对照组相比从基线到12周显著减少(p=0.0013)。
- 试验组平均改良牙龈指数从基线到3周、6周和12周较对照组显著降低(均p<0.0001)。
- 试验组平均总体Turesky菌斑指数从基线到3周(p=0.0012)、6周(p=0.0058)和12周(p<0.0001)较对照组显著降低。
- 试验组平均邻面Turesky菌斑指数从基线到3周(p=0.0022)、6周(p=0.0099)和12周(p<0.0001)较对照组显著降低。
临床怎么用
- 局限性牙龈炎可通过良好的家用口腔卫生措施解决或预防,但仅靠机械刷牙很少能达到。
- 每日两次使用碳酸氢钠牙膏刷牙在减轻局限性牙龈炎和改善口腔健康方面较常规氟化物牙膏显示出附加价值。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To determine the effect on gingival inflammation of toothbrushing with sodium bicarbonate toothpaste for 12 weeks compared to brushing with a conventional fluoride toothpaste. METHODS: An ethically-approved, single-centre, controlled, examiner-blind, randomized, two-treatment arm, parallel study in consenting healthy ≥18yr participants with ≥20 teeth diagnosed with localised gingivitis. Approximately 200 eligible participants brushed for 2weeks with a fluoride acclimatization toothpaste before randomization to brushing 2/daily with a sodium bicarbonate (test) or fluoride (control) toothpaste. No pre-prophylaxis was conducted prior to study start. Modified gingival index (MGI), bleeding index (BI) and Turesky plaque index (TPI), were measured at baseline, 3, 6 and 12weeks. Participants completed a diary for compliance monitoring. RESULTS: 190 participants were randomised, 188 completed the study. The test group demonstrated a statistically significant reduction in number of bleeding sites from baseline to 12-weeks (p = 0.0032), 6-weeks (p = 0.0031) and 3-weeks (p = 0.0091), and compared to control group from baseline to 12-weeks (p = 0.0013). The test group showed significantly (all p < 0.0001) decreased mean MGI score from baseline to 3-weeks, 6-weeks, and 12-weeks compared to control group; significantly decreased mean overall TPI score from baseline to 3-weeks (p = 0.0012), 6-weeks (p = 0.0058), and 12-weeks (p < 0.0001) compared to control; and significantly reduced mean interproximal TPI scores compared to control group from baseline to 3-weeks (p = 0.0022), 6-weeks (p = 0.0099) and 12-weeks (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Twice daily toothbrushing with a sodium bicarbonate toothpaste significantly improved oral health reducing localised gingivitis compared to brushing with a conventional fluoride toothpaste, measured by BI, MGI and TPI over 12 weeks. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Localised, gingivitis can be resolved or prevented with excellent home-use oral hygiene measures, but this is rarely achieved with mechanical brushing alone. Twice daily toothbrushing with sodium bicarbonate toothpaste demonstrated added value in reducing localised gingivitis and improving oral health compared to brushing with a conventional fluoride toothpaste.
引用
- West NX, Qiu J, Pollard AJ, et al. A randomised, controlled, trial investigating the effect of tooth brushing with a sodium bicarbonate toothpaste for 12 weeks compared to a conventional fluoride toothpaste on gingivitis. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40482904. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105886
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。