牙周病学与种植牙科中的美学及患者报告结局:共识报告
该共识会议评估了牙龈退缩缺损、即刻或早期/延期种植体植入及种植体周颊侧软组织开裂中的美学与患者报告体验和结局。会议基于五篇系统综述讨论,发现临床医生报告的美学评分与根覆盖指标正相关,而患者报告的美学感知无相应相关性;种植体植入后即刻加用结缔组织移植可减轻中面部黏膜水平的根向移位,但临床医生和患者报告的美学评分未反映这些变化;种植体周开裂采用结缔组织移植联合冠向推进瓣的软组织增量获得良好美学效果。结论认为临床医生与患者视角互补,需整合到特定干预中,并需专门试验报告获益与风险。
要点
- 牙龈退缩根覆盖术后,临床医生美学评分与根覆盖指标正相关,患者美学感知无相应相关性。
- 种植体植入后即刻加用结缔组织移植可减轻中面部黏膜根向移位,但美学评分未反映该变化。
- 种植体周软组织开裂采用结缔组织移植联合冠向推进瓣,临床医生和患者感知美学均良好。
核心结论
- 临床医生与患者视角为循证临床决策提供互补信息,需整合到特定干预中。
- 需要专门试验涵盖患者报告体验、患者报告结局和临床医生报告结局,并报告获益与风险。
研究设计与样本
- 共识会议基于五篇专门委托的系统综述,涵盖患者报告体验、患者报告结局和临床医生报告结局,包括有效性、美学及其他关注点。
主要发现
- 牙龈退缩缺损行冠向推进瓣联合结缔组织移植根覆盖术后,临床医生报告的美学评分与根覆盖指标呈正相关,但患者报告的美学感知无相应相关性。
- 牙种植手术中,种植体植入后即刻加用结缔组织移植显著减轻中面部黏膜水平的根向移位,但临床医生和患者报告的美学评分未反映这些变化。
- 临床医生和患者报告的美学评分均未捕捉移植对改善种植体周软组织体积的影响。
- 种植体周开裂治疗中,冠向推进瓣下使用结缔组织移植的软组织增量在临床医生和患者感知美学方面均获得良好结果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Aesthetics and patient-reported experiences (PREs) and outcomes (PROs) influence treatment choices, but have been largely overlooked in periodontology and implant dentistry. This consensus conference evaluated these factors by focusing on gingival recession defects (GRDs), immediate or early/delayed implant placement and peri-implant buccal soft-tissue dehiscences. METHODS: The workshop discussions were informed by five specifically commissioned systematic reviews covering PREs, PROs and clinician-reported outcomes (CROs), including effectiveness, aesthetics and other concerns. RESULTS: Following treatments such as coronally advanced flaps (CAFs) with a connective tissue graft (CTG) for root coverage (RC), a positive correlation was noted between clinician-reported aesthetic scores and RC measures for GRDs. However, a corresponding correlation for patient-reported aesthetic perceptions was not evident. In dental implant procedures, the addition of a CTG immediately after implant placement significantly mitigated the apical shift in the mid-facial mucosal level. However, clinician- and patient-reported aesthetic scores were not reflective of these changes. Neither set of scores captured the impact of grafting on improving peri-implant soft-tissue volume. In the treatment of peri-implant dehiscences, soft-tissue augmentation (STA), using CTG beneath CAF, resulted in favourable outcomes in clinician- and patient-perceived aesthetics. CONCLUSIONS: Clinician and patient views provide complementary perspectives for evidence-based clinical decision making. They need to be integrated into select interventions. Specific trials are needed encompassing PREs, PROs and CROs and reporting benefits and harms.
引用
- Tonetti M, Sanz M, Cairo F, et al. Aesthetics and Patient-Reported Outcomes in Periodontology and Implant Dentistry: Consensus Report. J Clin Periodontol. 2025. PMID: 40495112. doi:10.1111/jcpe.14182
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。