牙体牙髓科医生与全科牙医在非手术根管治疗临床方法上的差异:美国国家牙科实践研究网络PREDICT项目的前瞻性队列研究
该前瞻性队列研究纳入美国153名执业者(104名全科牙医、49名牙体牙髓科医生),对1705例患者中至少一例非手术根管治疗的操作细节进行记录。多变量分析显示,牙体牙髓科医生更倾向于使用放大倍数>5×、橡皮障隔离、次氯酸钠冲洗、EDTA或过氧化氢或氯己定冲洗、超声/声波冲洗液激活、电子根尖定位仪和X线片确定工作长度、热垂直加压和侧方加压充填技术,并报告充填致密无空隙及单次就诊完成治疗(p≤.01);牙体牙髓科医生使用润滑剂及报告充填长度不可接受(≥2 mm不足或超出影像学根尖)的可能性显著更低(p≤.01)。结论认为两者临床方法存在重大差异,需进一步研究评估这些差异对非手术根管治疗结局的影响。
要点
- 牙体牙髓科医生较全科牙医更常使用放大倍数>5×、橡皮障隔离及多种冲洗液(p≤.01)。
- 牙体牙髓科医生更常使用超声/声波冲洗激活、电子根尖定位仪及热垂直/侧方加压充填(p≤.01)。
- 牙体牙髓科医生更常单次完成治疗且充填致密无空隙,较少使用润滑剂及出现充填长度不可接受(p≤.01)。
核心结论
- 基于实际临床数据,牙体牙髓科医生与全科牙医在非手术根管治疗的临床方法上存在重大差异。
- 需进一步研究评估这些差异对非手术根管治疗结局的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列临床研究,纳入美国国家牙科实践研究网络中153名执业者(104名全科牙医和49名牙体牙髓科医生),对1705例患者中至少一例非手术根管治疗进行操作记录。
- 执业者填写术后表格记录操作数据,采用双变量和多变量分析校正混杂因素,并测试两种多变量模型以消除不稳定变量的影响。
主要发现
- 校正牙位后,多变量模型显示牙体牙髓科医生较全科牙医更可能使用放大倍数>5×、橡皮障隔离、次氯酸钠冲洗、EDTA或过氧化氢或氯己定冲洗、超声/声波冲洗液激活、电子根尖定位仪和X线片确定工作长度、热垂直加压和侧方加压充填技术、报告充填致密无空隙以及单次就诊完成非手术根管治疗(p≤.01)。
- 牙体牙髓科医生较全科牙医更不可能使用润滑剂及报告充填长度不可接受(≥2 mm不足或超出影像学根尖)(p≤.01)。
局限性
- 原文结论指出需进一步研究评估这些差异对非手术根管治疗结局的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: Information regarding differences between general dentists (GDs) and endodontists in their daily practices is limited. The aim of this prospective cohort clinical study was to compare the details of clinical approaches of GDs and endodontists when performing non-surgical root canal treatments (NSRCT). METHODOLOGY: The study was conducted among 153 practitioners (104 GDs and 49 endodontists) in the National Dental Practice-Based Research Network in the United States who performed NSRCT on at least one of 1705 patients. Practitioners completed postoperative forms to document procedural data. Bivariate and multivariable analyses were performed to adjust for the potential effect of confounders. Two different multivariable models were tested to eliminate the impact of unstable variables. RESULTS: Overall, after adjusting for the tooth type, multivariable models showed that endodontists were significantly more likely than GDs to use magnifications >5×, rubber dam isolation, NaOCl irrigation, EDTA or H2O2 or chlorhexidine irrigations, ultrasonic/sonic irrigant activation, electronic apex locator and radiographs for working length determination, warm vertical condensation and lateral condensation techniques for obturation, report adequately dense obturation without voids, and to complete NSRCT in a single visit (p ≤ .01). Endodontists were significantly less likely to use lubricants and to report unacceptable obturation length (≥2 mm short or extended beyond the radiographic apex) (p ≤ .01). CONCLUSIONS: Based on actual clinical data, this study observed major differences between GDs and endodontists in their clinical approaches when performing NSRCTs. Further studies are needed to assess the effect of these differences on the outcome of NSRCTs.
引用
- Nosrat A, Funkhouser E, Law AS, et al. Differences in clinical approaches of endodontists and general dentists when performing non-surgical root canal treatment: A prospective cohort study from the National Dental Practice-Based Research Network PREDICT Project. Int Endod J. 2025. PMID: 40445089. doi:10.1111/iej.14264
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。