儿童口腔科中传统与计算机控制局部麻醉注射系统注射疼痛水平的比较:系统综述与Meta分析
本系统综述纳入2015年1月至2024年11月发表的20项随机对照试验,评估计算机控制局部麻醉输送(CCLAD)系统在3-14岁儿童中减轻注射疼痛的效果。Meta分析显示,CCLAD显著降低WBS疼痛评分(SMD=-0.98,p=0.011)和心率(SMD=-0.25,p=0.013),异质性分别为高和中度;亚组分析中CCLAD较传统下牙槽神经阻滞(IANB)在WBS上显著减轻疼痛,但其他量表和方法差异多不显著。
要点
- CCLAD显著降低儿童WBS疼痛评分(SMD=-0.98,p=0.011),异质性高。
- CCLAD显著降低注射时心率(SMD=-0.25,p=0.013),异质性中度。
- 亚组分析中CCLAD较传统IANB在WBS上显著减轻疼痛,其他指标差异多不显著。
核心结论
- CCLAD有潜力作为减少儿童注射疼痛的非药物工具,尤其体现在WBS和心率评估上。
- 亚组分析中CCLAD较传统下牙槽神经阻滞注射显著减轻疼痛。
- 需要更多研究来优化治疗方案并进一步评估CCLAD对客观疼痛指标的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,纳入2015年1月至2024年11月发表的比较CCLAD与传统注射方法在3-14岁儿童中疼痛感知的随机对照试验。
- 检索Embase、Medline(通过PubMed)、Cochrane Library、Scopus、Web of Science和Google Scholar,限英文文章。
- 从1253项识别的研究中,20项符合纳入标准。
主要发现
- 基于WBS,CCLAD显著降低疼痛感知(SMD=-0.98,p=0.011),异质性高。
- 基于心率测量,CCLAD显著降低疼痛感知(SMD=-0.25,p=0.013),异质性中度。
- 亚组分析显示CCLAD较传统IANB在WBS上显著减轻疼痛,但其他量表和注射方法的结果不一,部分差异不显著。
- 其他疼痛评估参数未见显著差异。
- 五项研究总体偏倚风险低,证据确定性从极低到中等。
关键数值与推荐
- WBS疼痛评分:CCLAD组较传统组SMD=-0.98(p=0.011),异质性高。
- 心率:CCLAD组较传统组SMD=-0.25(p=0.013),异质性中度。
- 亚组分析:CCLAD较传统IANB在WBS上显著减轻疼痛,其他量表和注射方法部分差异不显著。
- 五项研究总体偏倚风险低,证据确定性范围为极低至中等。
临床怎么用
- 本研究强调CCLAD在儿童口腔科中的益处,尤其在局部麻醉注射时减轻疼痛和应激,特别是对IANB操作。
- 使用CCLAD可提升患者舒适度、改善配合度并营造积极牙科体验,从而支持需要精准低痛护理的儿童患者获得更好治疗结果。
局限性
- WBS分析的异质性高,心率分析的异质性中度。
- 其他量表和注射方法的结果不一,部分差异不显著。
- 证据确定性从极低到中等。
- 需要更多研究来优化治疗方案并进一步评估CCLAD对客观疼痛指标的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This systematic review aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of computer-controlled local anesthetic delivery (CCLAD) systems in reducing injection pain in pediatric patients aged 3-14 years, including subgroup analysis across different injection techniques. DATA: Randomized controlled trials comparing pain perception associated with CCLAD versus conventional injection methods in children published from January 2015 to November 2024 were included. SOURCES: Comprehensive searches were performed in Embase, Medline (via PubMed), Cochrane Library, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar, limited to articles published in English. STUDY SELECTION: From 1253 identified studies, 20 met the inclusion criteria. Meta-analysis revealed that CCLAD significantly reduced pain perception based on the Wong-Baker Pain Rating Scale (WBS) (SMD = -0.98, p = 0.011) and heart rate (HR) measurements (SMD = -0.25, p = 0.013), with high and moderate heterogeneity, respectively. Subgroup analysis indicated significant pain reduction with CCLAD compared to conventional Inferior Alveolar Nerve Block (IANB) on WBS, though findings varied across other scales and injection methods, demonstrating some non-significant differences. No significant differences were observed in other pain assessment parameters. The overall risk of bias was low in five studies, with evidence certainty ranging from very low to moderate. CONCLUSION: CCLAD demonstrates potential as a non-pharmacological tool for reducing injection pain in children, particularly as assessed by WBS and HR. Furthermore, CCLAD significantly reduced pain compared to conventional IANB injections in subgroup analyses. Additional research is necessary to optimize treatment protocols and further evaluate the impact of CCLAD on objective pain measures. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This study highlights the benefits of CCLAD in pediatric dentistry, particularly its effectiveness in minimizing pain and stress during local anesthetic injections, especially for IANB procedures. Using CCLAD can enhance patient comfort, improve cooperation, and foster a positive dental experience, thereby supporting better treatment outcomes in pediatric patients requiring precise and low-pain care.
引用
- Shirani M, Looha MA, Emami M, et al. Comparison of injection pain levels using conventional and computer-controlled local anesthetic delivery systems in pediatric dentistry: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 40254248. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105770
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。