文献速递牙周病口腔修复与种植

后牙牙槽嵴保存术后种植辅助植骨预测列线图模型的建立与验证

[Establishment and verification of nomogram model for predicting implant-assisted bone grafting after posterior teeth alveolar ridge preservation].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2025-01-01

本研究基于98例患者共110颗后牙的ARP术后数据构建列线图模型,按7∶3随机分为建模组与验证组,多因素分析显示吸烟史是ARP术后6个月种植时需辅助植骨的独立危险因素,模型内部验证AUC为0.90、外部验证AUC为0.97,区分度与一致性良好。

要点

  • 吸烟史是后牙ARP术后6个月种植时需辅助植骨的独立危险因素。
  • 患者年龄、失牙原因、牙周炎分期及患牙最大附着丧失与辅助植骨需要相关。
  • 列线图模型内部验证AUC为0.90,外部验证AUC为0.97,区分度与一致性良好。

核心结论

  • 患者年龄、吸烟史、失牙原因、牙周炎分期及患牙最大附着丧失与后牙ARP术后6个月种植是否需要辅助植骨有关,吸烟史是辅助植骨术的独立危险因素。
  • 以此构建的列线图预测模型区分度与一致性良好。

研究设计与样本

  • 根据样本量计算公式采用R 4.1.3软件pmsampsize程序包计算样本量后,选取2018年1月至2024年5月于中国医科大学口腔医学院·附属口腔医院牙周病科行ARP治疗的98例患者共110颗后牙。
  • 按随机数字表法以7∶3比例将患牙随机分为建模组与验证组,建模组根据ARP术后6个月种植时是否辅助植骨分为直接种植组和辅助植骨组。
  • 采用单因素和多因素分析筛选影响因素,以R软件构建列线图,绘制ROC曲线和校准曲线评估区分度与一致性,使用DCA评估临床应用价值。

主要发现

  • 单因素分析显示年龄(OR=1.06,P=0.001)、患牙最大附着丧失(OR=1.75,P<0.001)、失牙原因(OR=12.73,P<0.001)、吸烟史[<10支/d(OR=7.59,P<0.001);≥10支/d(OR=28.12,P<0.001)]和牙周炎分期[Ⅱ期(OR=2.57,P=0.430);Ⅲ期(OR=21.00,P=0.007);Ⅳ期(OR=76.50,P<0.001)]对ARP术后种植时是否需要辅助植骨术存在显著影响。
  • 多因素分析显示吸烟史[<10支/d(OR=7.02,P=0.009);≥10支/d(OR=10.27,P=0.026)]是后牙ARP术后种植时需要辅助植骨的独立危险因素。
  • 内部验证ROC曲线下面积为0.90(95%CI:0.84~0.97),H-L拟合优度检验χ2=4.79,P=0.780,一致性良好。
  • 外部验证ROC曲线下面积为0.97(95%CI:0.92~1.00),H-L拟合优度检验χ2=5.03,P=0.754,提示拟合效果较建模组稍低,模型预测值略低于真实值,可能低估患者额外手术的风险。
  • DCA曲线显示高风险阈值概率为0.06~0.93时,预测模型的临床使用价值较高。

局限性

  • 外部验证提示拟合效果较建模组稍低,模型的预测值略低于真实值,可能低估患者额外手术的风险。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: Constructing a risk prediction model to assess the impact of various factors on the need for auxiliary bone grafting with implant placement following alveolar ridge preservation (ARP) in posterior teeth. Methods: According to the sample size calculation formula, the sample size was calculated using the pmsampsize package of R 4.1.3 software, based on inclusion and exclusion criteria, a total of 110 posterior teeth in 98 patients who underwent ARP at the Department of Periodontology, School and Hospital of Stomatology, China Medical University, from January 2018 to May 2024 were conducted. Teeth were randomly divided into modeling group and validation group with 7∶3 ratio according to the random number table. The modeling group was divided into direct implantation group and auxiliary bone grafting group on the basis of whether auxiliary bone grafting was performed 6 months after ARP. Univariate and multivariate analyses were conducted to identify factors influencing auxiliary bone grafting with implant placement following ARP. Nomogram was constructed using R software. Receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curve and calibration curve were drawn to evaluate model differentiation and consistency. The decision curve analysis (DCA) was used to assess the clinical application value of the model. Results: Age (OR=1.06, P=0.001), maximum attachment loss (AL) (OR=1.75, P<0.001), reason of tooth extraction (OR=12.73, P<0.001), smoking [<10 cigarettes/d (OR=7.59, P<0.001);≥10 cigarettes/d (OR=28.12, P<0.001)] and stage of periodontitis [stage Ⅱ (OR=2.57, P=0.430); stage Ⅲ (OR=21.00, P=0.007); stage Ⅳ (OR=76.50, P<0.001)] influenced the necessity for auxiliary bone grafting with implant placement after ARP. After multivariate analysis of the above influencing factors, it was found that smoking [<10 cigarettes/d (OR=7.02, P=0.009);≥10 cigarettes/d (OR=10.27, P=0.026)] was an independent risk factor for the need of auxiliary bone grafting with implant placement after ARP. The area under the ROC curve for internal verification was 0.90 (95%CI: 0.84-0.97), and the H-L goodness of fit test results were χ2=4.79, P=0.780, indicating a good agreement. The area under the externally verified ROC curve was 0.97 (95%CI: 0.92-1.00), suggesting that the fitting effect was slightly lower than that of the modeling group, and the predicted value of the model was slightly lower than the true value, which might underestimate the risk of additional surgery in patients. Results: of H-L goodness of fit test were χ2=5.03, P=0.754. The DCA curve showed that when the probability of high-risk threshold was between 0.06 and 0.93, the clinical application value of the prediction model was higher. Conclusions: Age, smoking, reason of tooth extraction, stage of periodontitis, and maximum AL of the affected teeth were related to the necessity for auxiliary bone grafting with implant placement 6 months after ARP. Smoking was an independent risk factor for auxiliary bone grafting surgery. The constructed nomogram model had good discrimination and consistency. 目的: 通过构建风险预测模型,评估各因素对后牙牙槽嵴保存术(ARP)后种植是否需要辅助植骨的影响。 方法: 根据样本量计算公式,采用R 4.1.3软件的pmsampsize程序包计算样本量后,根据纳入及排除标准,选取2018年1月至2024年5月于中国医科大学口腔医学院·附属口腔医院牙周病科进行ARP治疗的98例患者,共计110颗后牙,根据随机数字表法,按7∶3比例将患牙随机分为建模组与验证组,其中建模组根据ARP术后6个月种植时是否进行辅助植骨分为直接种植组和辅助植骨组。通过单因素和多因素分析后牙ARP术后种植辅助植骨的影响因素;采用R软件构建列线图模型。绘制受试者操作特征(ROC)曲线和校准曲线评估模型区分度和一致性;使用临床决策曲线分析(DCA)评估模型的临床应用价值。 结果: 患者年龄(OR=1.06,P=0.001)、患牙最大附着丧失(AL)(OR=1.75,P<0.001)、失牙原因(OR=12.73,P<0.001)、吸烟史[<10支/d(OR=7.59,P<0.001);≥10支/d(OR=28.12,P<0.001)]和牙周炎分期[Ⅱ期(OR=2.57,P=0.430);Ⅲ期(OR=21.00,P=0.007);Ⅳ期(OR=76.50,P<0.001)]对ARP术后种植时是否需要辅助植骨术存在显著影响;上述影响因素的多因素分析结果显示,吸烟史[<10支/d(OR=7.02,P=0.009);≥10支/d(OR=10.27,P=0.026)]是后牙ARP术后种植时需要辅助植骨的独立危险因素。内部验证ROC曲线下面积(AUC)为0.90(95%CI:0.84~0.97),H-L拟合优度检验结果为χ2=4.79,P=0.780,一致性良好。外部验证AUC为0.97(95%CI:0.92~1.00),提示拟合效果较建模组稍低,模型的预测值略低于真实值,即可能低估患者额外手术的风险;H-L拟合优度检验结果为χ2=5.03,P=0.754。DCA曲线显示高风险阈值概率为0.06~0.93时,预测模型的临床使用价值较高。 结论: 患者吸烟史、年龄、失牙原因、牙周炎分期及患牙最大AL与后牙ARP术后6个月种植是否需要辅助植骨有关,其中吸烟史是辅助植骨术的独立危险因素;以此构建的预测模型区分度与一致性良好。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Deng JQ, Yang Z, Liu Y, et al. [Establishment and verification of nomogram model for predicting implant-assisted bone grafting after posterior teeth alveolar ridge preservation]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2025. PMID: 40268531. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20241212-00475

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。