采用不同根管消毒方法治疗磨牙后的愈合结局:一项前瞻性队列研究
这项前瞻性队列研究纳入230颗伴根尖周炎(AP)的上、下颌磨牙,分别采用GentleWave(GW)系统或超声活化(UA)联合负压冲洗(NPI)治疗,177颗有随访。严格标准下GW组成功率70.6%、UA+NPI组72.9%,宽松标准下分别为83.5%和87.1%,两种标准下组间均无显著差异,治疗类型对愈合率(PAI评分)也无影响。
要点
- 严格标准下GW组成功率70.6%,UA+NPI组72.9%,组间无显著差异。
- 宽松标准下GW组成功率83.5%,UA+NPI组87.1%,组间无显著差异。
- 治疗类型(GW vs UA+NPI)对愈合率(PAI评分)无影响,随访时间不影响结果。
核心结论
- 在本研究的局限性内,GW系统与UA+NPI在促进根尖周炎愈合方面效果相当,提示两者均为根管消毒的可行选择。
- 需要进一步研究以优化方案策略并改善临床结局。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,纳入伴根尖周炎的上、下颌磨牙230颗,分别接受GW或UA+NPI治疗。
- 所有操作由一名认证牙髓病专科医生按标准化方案完成。
- 有随访评估的患者177例,由2名设盲牙髓病专科医生独立评估治疗前后的根尖周指数(PAI)评分。
- 两次评估的平均间隔为14.9个月。
- 排除拔除病例后,统计比较GW组(n=85)与UA+NPI组(n=85)的阳性与阴性结局数量。
主要发现
- 采用严格成功标准(愈合-PAI≤2)时,GW组70.6%的病例成功,UA+NPI组为72.9%。
- 采用宽松标准(愈合-PAI下降>2)时,GW组83.5%成功,UA+NPI组为87.1%。
- 采用任一标准,两组间均未发现显著差异。
- 治疗类型(GW vs UA+NPI)对愈合率(PAI评分)无影响。
- 治疗后的随访时间未影响这些发现。
关键数值与推荐
- 严格成功标准定义为愈合-PAI≤2。
- 宽松标准定义为愈合-PAI下降>2。
- 统计采用方差分析(ANOVA)评估治疗类型是否影响愈合率(PAI评分)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为GW系统与UA+NPI在促进根尖周炎愈合方面效果相当,两者均为根管消毒的可行选择。
- 作者提出需要进一步研究以优化方案策略并改善临床结局。
局限性
- 原文在结论中写明「在本研究的局限性内」,但未具体列出各项局限。
- 原文结论提出需要进一步研究以优化方案策略并改善临床结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: To address the shortage of clinical outcome studies on contemporary root canal disinfection methods, this prospective cohort study assessed healing of apical periodontitis (AP) after use of the GentleWave (GW) system or Ultrasonic Activation (UA) combined with negative pressure irrigation (NPI). METHODS: Maxillary and mandibular molars with AP (n = 230) were treated with either GW or UA + NPI. A board-certified endodontist performed all procedures following standardized protocols. Patients with follow-up assessments available (n = 177) had radiographs assessed independently by 2 blinded endodontists who assigned a periapical index (PAI) score before and after treatment. The mean time between these assessments was 14.9 months. After excluding extractions, our statistical analyses first compared the numbers of positive and negative outcomes between GW (n = 85) and UA + NPI (n = 85) groups using strict (healed - PAI ≤2) and loose criteria (healing - decreased PAI >2). An ANOVA assessed if treatment type affected healing rates (PAI scores). RESULTS: Following treatment and adopting the strict success criteria, 70.6% of cases in the GW group were successful, compared to 72.9% in the UA + NPI group. Under the loose criteria, 83.5% were successful in the GW group compared to 87.1% in the UA + NPI group. No significant differences were found between the groups adopting either criterion. There was also no effect of treatment type (GW vs UA + NPI) on healing rates (PAI scores). The follow up time after treatment did not impact these findings. CONCLUSIONS: Within the limitations of this study, the GW system and UA + NPI were equally effective in promoting AP healing, suggesting both methods are viable options for root canal disinfection. Further research is needed to optimize protocol strategies and improve clinical outcomes.
引用
- Montero LQ, Basrani B, Ellis DA, et al. Healing Outcomes Following the Treatment of Molars Using Different Root Canal Disinfection Methods: A Prospective Cohort Study. J Endod. 2025. PMID: 40287087. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2025.04.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。