文献速递口腔正畸

3D打印透明矫治器:传统热压成型矫治器的新兴替代方案?——一项系统综述

3D-printed clear aligners: An emerging alternative to the conventional thermoformed aligners? - A systematic review.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2025-02-05

本系统综述通过Scopus和PubMed检索,比较传统热压成型透明矫治器(TFA)与新兴3D打印透明矫治器(DPA)的机械化学性能、制造工艺、精度与可持续性。结果显示DPA具有形状记忆和设计灵活性,力值曲线更一致,精度、真实度和精密度高于TFA,但直接打印同样会改变厚度;关于可持续性和生物相容性的研究有限。结论认为DPA近期内可能成为TFA的替代方案,但需更高质量随机化实验研究确认。

要点

  • DPA具有形状记忆和设计灵活性,力值曲线较TFA更一致
  • DPA的精度、真实度和精密度高于TFA,但直接打印同样会改变厚度
  • 关于DPA可持续性和生物相容性的研究有限,需更高质量随机化研究确认

核心结论

  • 3D打印矫治器凭借创新和有前景的性能,近期内可能成为热压成型矫治器的替代方案。
  • 在推广给更广泛人群前,需开展更高质量证据和强调随机化的进一步实验研究,以确认当前基于实验室的研究发现并解决重要局限性。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,采用PICO格式研究问题指导文献筛选。
  • 检索数据库为Scopus和PubMed,纳入与3D打印矫治器性能相关的科学文章及与热压成型矫治器性能相关的对比交叉引用文章。

主要发现

  • 两种矫治器均具有良好的机械性能,但DPA以形状记忆和设计灵活性两种新性能而突出。
  • DPA力值曲线一致,而TFA则不然。
  • DPA的精度、真实度和精密度高于TFA。
  • 与热压成型工艺类似,直接打印也会使DPA的厚度偏离原始主STL模型。
  • 关于DPA可持续性和生物相容性的研究有限。

临床怎么用

  • 3D打印技术的设计灵活性和目前市售3D打印矫治器的形状记忆性能,可能有助于实现精确、预期的正畸结果,并可能减少临床治疗时间。

局限性

  • 关于DPA可持续性和生物相容性的研究有限。
  • 需更高质量证据和强调随机化的进一步实验研究,以确认当前基于实验室的研究发现并解决重要局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To assess the differences between the traditional thermoformed clear aligners (TFA) and the emerging 3D-printed clear aligners (DPA) by comparing their mechanical and chemical properties, manufacturing process, accuracy trueness and precision, and effect on sustainability. To evaluate whether 3D-printing is more efficient than thermoforming in the manufacturing of clear aligners. DATA: Data was collected from scientific articles related to 3D-printed aligners' properties and comparative cross-referenced articles related to the thermoformed aligners' properties. SOURCES: The sources assessed to retrieve the articles were scientific databases Scopus and PubMed. STUDY SELECTION: A PICO format research question guided the study selection by both assisting in the formulation of keyword combinations and establishing a set of inclusion and exclusion criteria to meet this review's objectives. RESULTS: The results indicate that both aligners have good mechanical properties, but the DPA distinguished themselves with two novel properties, shape memory and design flexibility. Additionally, they exerted a consistent force profile in contrast to the TFA. The DPA have higher accuracy, trueness and precision than the TFA, however similar to the thermoforming process, direct-printing also varied the thickness of the DPA from the original master STL model. There are limited studies on sustainability and biocompatibility of the DPA. CONCLUSIONS: Following this review, it can be concluded that 3D-printed aligners are likely to serve as an alternative to the thermoformed aligners in the near future, seeing their innovative and promising properties. However, further experimental studies with higher quality of evidence and an emphasis on randomization are necessary to confirm current laboratory-based studies' findings and address important limitations before promoting the aligners to a larger audience. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The design flexibility of 3D-printing technology, and the shape memory property of currently marketed 3D-printed aligners could positively impact the accomplishment of precise, desired orthodontic outcomes, potentially reducing clinical treatment time.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Torkomian T, de la Iglesia F, Puigdollers A, et al. 3D-printed clear aligners: An emerging alternative to the conventional thermoformed aligners? - A systematic review. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 39921085. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105616

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。