文献速递口腔修复与种植

不同三维CAD软件程序与算法用于虚拟模型对齐的准确性(正确度、精密度)及处理时间评估

Evaluation of the accuracy (trueness, precision) and processing time of different 3-dimensional CAD software programs and algorithms for virtual cast alignment.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2025-02-06

本体外研究将下颌牙颌模型经实验室扫描仪数字化获得参考STL文件,再用口内扫描仪扫描并数字复制10份,每份用6款三维CAD软件与对齐算法的42种组合与参考STL对齐,用Python记录正确度、精密度和处理时间。结果显示软件与算法对正确度、精密度和处理时间均有显著影响(p<.01);Medit Design综合表现最佳,Meshmixer准确性最低;最佳拟合与基于剖面的算法结果最好。

要点

  • 软件与算法组合显著影响对齐正确度、精密度和处理时间(p<.01)。
  • Medit Design综合表现最佳,兼具高准确性与最快处理时间。
  • Meshmixer因缺乏高级算法而准确性最低;最佳拟合与基于剖面的算法结果最好。

核心结论

  • CAD软件和对齐算法的选择显著影响对齐准确性和效率。
  • 最佳拟合和基于剖面的算法提供了最好的结果。
  • 对齐方案必须根据所用具体CAD软件程序进行调整,因为没有任何通用方案在所有测试软件中均有效。

研究设计与样本

  • 体外研究:下颌牙颌模型经实验室扫描仪(L2i)数字化获得参考STL文件(STLr),再经口内扫描仪(Primescan)扫描并数字复制10次(n=10)。
  • 每份扫描用6款三维CAD软件(Blender for Dental、BlueSkyPlan、Dental CAD App(Exocad)、Medit Design、NemoSmile、Meshmixer)与对齐算法的42种组合与STLr对齐。
  • 用Python软件(v3.8)记录对齐准确性(正确度和精密度)与处理时间;统计采用双因素方差分析(α=0.01)及事后Tukey真实显著性差异检验(α=0.05)。

主要发现

  • 基于所用软件和算法,对齐准确性存在显著差异,正确度(p<.01)和精密度(p<.01)均受影响。
  • 处理时间也差异显著(p<.01)。
  • 事后分析确定了每款软件的最佳算法,各最佳版本在正确度、精密度和处理时间上存在差异。
  • Medit Design综合表现最佳,兼具高准确性与最快处理时间。
  • Meshmixer因缺乏高级算法而准确性最低。

关键数值与推荐

  • 正确度组间差异 p<.01,精密度组间差异 p<.01,处理时间组间差异 p<.01(双因素方差分析,α=0.01)。
  • 事后Tukey真实显著性差异检验采用 α=0.05 确定排名。

临床怎么用

  • 对齐方案必须根据所用具体CAD软件程序进行调整,因为没有任何通用方案在所有测试软件中均有效。
  • 优化对齐方案可减少误差、改善修复效果,并提高临床和技工流程的可靠性与效率,最终保障更好的患者照护和治疗成功。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: This in vitro study aimed to evaluate the impact of different alignment algorithms and CAD software programs on alignment accuracy (trueness and precision) and processing time. METHODS: A mandibular typodont was digitized using a laboratory scanner (L2i) to obtain a reference standard tesselletion language (STLr) file. It was then scanned with an intraoral scanner (Primescan) and digitally duplicated ten times (n = 10). Each scan was aligned with the STLr using 42 combinations of 3D CAD software and alignment algorithms. The tested software programs included Blender for Dental, BlueSkyPlan, Dental CAD App (Exocad), Medit Design, NemoSmile, and Meshmixer. Alignment accuracy (trueness and precision) and processing time were recorded using Python software (v3.8). Statistical analysis was performed with a two-way ANOVA test (α = 0.01) to identify overall differences, followed by a post hoc Tukey Honestly Significant Difference test (α = 0.05) to establish rankings. RESULTS: Significant differences in alignment accuracy were observed based on the software and algorithm used, affecting both trueness (p<.01) and precision (p<.01). Processing time also varied significantly (p<.01). Post hoc analysis identified the optimal algorithm for each software, revealing variations in trueness, precision, and processing time among the optimal versions. Medit Design achieved the best overall performance by combining high accuracy with the fastest processing time, while Meshmixer exhibited the lowest accuracy due to its lack of advanced algorithms. CONCLUSIONS: The choice of CAD software and alignment algorithm significantly influences alignment accuracy and efficiency. Best-fit and section-based provided the best results, offering valuable insights into the optimization of digital workflows in prosthodontics. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Alignment protocols must be tailored to the specific CAD software program used, as no universal protocol was effective across all tested software. Optimizing alignment protocols reduces errors, enhances prosthodontic outcomes, and improves the reliability and efficiency of clinical and laboratory workflows, ultimately ensuring better patient care and treatment success.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Piedra-Cascón W, Burgos-Artizzu XP, González-Martin Ó, et al. Evaluation of the accuracy (trueness, precision) and processing time of different 3-dimensional CAD software programs and algorithms for virtual cast alignment. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 39922450. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105619

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。