牙髓病学核心结局指标集(COS-ENDO)的制定:第4部分——恒牙活髓治疗研究的COS-ENDO
由美国牙髓病医师协会及其基金会支持,采用范围综述、网络调查和两轮德尔菲调查(73名参与者评估46个结局)制定恒牙活髓治疗研究的核心结局指标集。最终会议16名参与者确定9个核心结局,包括牙齿存活、疼痛、感染迹象、根尖周健康影像学证据、牙根继续发育、成功、功能性牙齿、需进一步干预及不良事件/并发症。
要点
- COS-ENDO为恒牙活髓治疗研究标准化报告9个核心结局。
- 制定过程包括范围综述、网络调查和两轮德尔菲调查。
- 仍需进一步努力建立最佳测量方法。
核心结论
- COS-ENDO是标准化牙髓病学结局报告的重要一步,确保报告一致性并提升研究实用性。
- 仍需进一步努力建立最佳测量方法。
研究设计与样本
- 由美国牙髓病医师协会及其基金会支持制定COS-ENDO。
- 结局通过范围综述和对美国牙髓病医师协会执业会员的网络调查识别。
- 两轮德尔菲调查中,临床医生、患者和研究者在9分制量表上对结局评分。
- 第1轮邀请97人,77人注册,73人(24名学术人员/研究者、26名临床医生、23名患者或其父母/照护者)评估46个结局,其中17个被排除。
- 最终会议16名参与者确定恒牙活髓治疗研究的COS-ENDO。
主要发现
- 第1轮73名参与者评估46个结局,17个被排除,4个达成纳入共识,25个缺乏共识进入第2轮。
- 第2轮70名参与者重新评分,10个结局达成纳入共识,19个缺乏共识。
- 最终会议确定的核心结局包括牙齿存活、疼痛、感染迹象、根尖周健康影像学证据、牙根继续发育、成功、功能性牙齿、需进一步干预及不良事件/并发症。
局限性
- 仍需进一步努力建立最佳测量方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Methodological heterogeneity and reporting bias complicate interpreting endodontic outcomes. Supported by the American Association of Endodontists and its Foundation, this study developed the Core Outcome Set for Endodontics (COS-ENDO) to standardize reporting for studies of Nonsurgical Root Canal Treatment/Retreatment, Surgical Endodontics, Vital Pulp Therapy, Apexification, and Regenerative Endodontics. This article, Part 4 of a 5-part series, focuses on COS-ENDO for Vital Pulp Therapy, while other parts address the remaining treatments. METHODS: Outcomes were identified through a scoping review and a web-based survey of American Association of Endodontists practicing members. In a 2-round Delphi survey, clinicians, patients, and researchers rated outcomes on a 9-point scale. Ratings were assessed against consensus criteria, and a virtual meeting finalized COS-ENDO. RESULTS: Of the 97 invited participants to Round 1, 77 registered, and 73 (24 Academicians/Researchers, 26 Clinicians, and 23 Patients or their parents/caregivers) assessed 46 outcomes, with 17 excluded. The remaining outcomes-4 achieving consensus for inclusion and 25 lacking consensus-advanced to Round 2 for re-rating by 70 participants. This resulted in 10 outcomes achieving consensus for inclusion, and 19 lacking consensus. In the final meeting, 16 participants finalized the COS-ENDO for Vital Pulp Therapy studies, including Tooth survival, Pain, Signs of infection, Radiographic evidence of maintained periradicular health, Continued root development, Success, Functional tooth, Need for further intervention, and Adverse events/Complications. CONCLUSION: COS-ENDO is an important step in standardizing outcome reporting in endodontics, ensuring consistent reporting and enhancing research utility. Further efforts are needed to establish optimal measurement methods.
引用
- Zanjir M, Cardoso E, Harman NL, et al. Development of a Core Outcome Set in Endodontics (COS-ENDO): Part 4 - COS-ENDO for Studies of Vital Pulp Therapy in Permanent Teeth. J Endod. 2025. PMID: 39892665. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2025.01.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。