牙髓病学核心结局指标集(COS-ENDO)的制定:第2部分——恒牙非手术根管治疗与再治疗研究的COS-ENDO
本研究由美国牙髓病医师协会及其基金会支持,制定牙髓病学核心结局指标集(COS-ENDO),以标准化非手术根管治疗/再治疗等研究的结果报告。通过范围综述、患者定性研究和美国牙髓病医师协会执业会员网络调查识别结局,经两轮德尔菲调查(73名参与者评估39个结局)和虚拟会议,最终确定包括牙齿存留、疼痛、感染体征、根周愈合影像学证据、成功、功能性牙齿、需进一步干预及不良事件/并发症在内的COS-ENDO。
要点
- COS-ENDO由美国牙髓病医师协会及其基金会支持制定,旨在标准化牙髓病学研究的结果报告。
- 最终确定的非手术根管治疗/再治疗核心结局包括牙齿存留、疼痛、感染体征、根周愈合影像学证据、成功、功能性牙齿、需进一步干预及不良事件/并发症。
- 进一步工作需建立最佳测量方法。
核心结论
- COS-ENDO是标准化牙髓病学结果报告的重要一步,确保报告一致性并提升研究实用性。
- 需进一步努力建立最佳测量方法。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究由美国牙髓病医师协会及其基金会支持,制定牙髓病学核心结局指标集(COS-ENDO),涵盖非手术根管治疗/再治疗、牙髓外科、活髓治疗、根尖诱导成形术和再生牙髓病学。
- 通过范围综述、患者定性研究和美国牙髓病医师协会执业会员网络调查识别结局。
- 采用两轮德尔菲调查,临床医生、患者和研究者在9点量表上对结局评分,依据共识标准评估,并通过虚拟会议最终确定COS-ENDO。
- 第一轮邀请97名参与者,77名注册,73名(24名院士/研究者、26名临床医生、23名患者或其父母/照护者)评估了39个结局,其中18个被排除。
- 剩余结局中7个达成纳入共识、14个缺乏共识,进入第二轮由70名参与者重新评分,结果9个结局达成纳入共识、12个缺乏共识。
主要发现
- 第一轮73名参与者评估39个结局,18个被排除。
- 第一轮剩余结局中7个达成纳入共识、14个缺乏共识,进入第二轮。
- 第二轮70名参与者重新评分后,9个结局达成纳入共识、12个缺乏共识。
- 最终会议16名参与者确定非手术根管治疗/再治疗的COS-ENDO,包括牙齿存留、疼痛、感染体征、根周愈合影像学证据、成功、功能性牙齿、需进一步干预及不良事件/并发症。
关键数值与推荐
- 非手术根管治疗/再治疗的COS-ENDO包括牙齿存留、疼痛、感染体征、根周愈合影像学证据、成功、功能性牙齿、需进一步干预及不良事件/并发症。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需进一步努力建立最佳测量方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Methodological heterogeneity and reporting bias complicate interpreting endodontic outcomes. Supported by the American Association of Endodontists and its Foundation, this study developed the Core Outcome Set in Endodontics (COS-ENDO) to standardize reporting for studies of Nonsurgical Root Canal Treatment/Retreatment, Surgical Endodontics, Vital Pulp Therapy, Apexification, and Regenerative Endodontics. This article, Part 2 of a 5-part series, focuses on COS-ENDO for Nonsurgical Root Canal Treatment/Retreatment, while other parts address the remaining treatments. METHODS: Outcomes were identified through scoping reviews, a qualitative study with patients, and a web-based survey of American Association of Endodontists practicing members. In a 2-round Delphi survey, clinicians, patients, and researchers rated outcomes on a 9-point scale. Ratings were assessed against consensus criteria, and a virtual meeting finalized COS-ENDO. RESULTS: Of the 97 invited participants to Round 1, 77 registered, and 73 (24 Academicians/Researchers, 26 Clinicians, and 23 Patients (or their parents/caregivers)) assessed 39 outcomes, with 18 excluded. The remaining outcomes-7 achieving consensus for inclusion and 14 lacking consensus-advanced to Round 2 for re-rating by 70 participants. This resulted in 9 outcomes achieving consensus for inclusion, and 12 lacking consensus. In the final meeting, 16 participants finalized the COS-ENDO for Nonsurgical Root Canal Treatment/Retreatment, including Tooth survival, Pain, Signs of infection, Radiographic evidence of periradicular healing, Success, Functional tooth, Need for further intervention, and Adverse events/Complications. CONCLUSIONS: COS-ENDO is an important step in standardizing outcome reporting in endodontics, ensuring consistent reporting and enhancing research utility. Further efforts are needed to establish optimal measurement methods.
引用
- Zanjir M, Cardoso E, Harman NL, et al. Development of a Core Outcome Set in Endodontics (COS-ENDO): Part 2 - COS-ENDO for Studies of Nonsurgical Root Canal Treatment and Retreatment in Permanent Teeth. J Endod. 2025. PMID: 39892663. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2025.01.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。