无牙颌受试者垂直距离的模拟与三维测量比较
本研究纳入19例全口义齿修复的无牙颌受试者,比较面部直接模拟测量与三维面部扫描数字测量垂直距离(OVD/RVD)的可行性及可靠性。结果显示数字测量值总体上高于模拟测量,平均配对差值范围-4.86±3.2至0.42±2.7 mm,除SN-SP(p=0.110)外差异均有统计学意义。作者认为考虑到所用面部扫描仪类型的局限性,目前可能不推荐通过数字方法记录无牙颌患者的静息垂直距离。
要点
- 数字测量值高于模拟测量,平均配对差值范围-4.86±3.2至0.42±2.7 mm。
- 除SN-SP(p=0.110)外,其余差异均有统计学意义。
- 作者认为目前可能不推荐用数字方法记录无牙颌患者静息垂直距离。
核心结论
- 考虑到本研究使用的特定类型面部扫描仪的局限性,目前可能不推荐通过数字方法记录无牙颌患者的静息垂直距离。
- 数据采集过程中可能出现的误差可能影响测量的准确性和可靠性。
- 临床意义:数字方法记录无牙颌患者静息垂直距离(RVD)可能引入误差,导致咬合误差和不适,临床医生目前仍须使用传统模拟方法以确保RVD测量准确。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入19例全口义齿修复的无牙颌受试者。
- 模拟测量(对照)直接在面部进行,分别在颌骨处于静息位(不戴义齿,RVD)和正中咬合位(戴义齿,OVD)时测量面部标志点间距离:眉间(G)至软组织颏前点(SP)、鼻尖(PN)至SP、鼻下点(SN)至SP。
- 使用面部扫描仪(Class 1 LASER,Obiscanner)对受试者面部扫描两次,扫描数据导入网格处理软件进行数字测量OVD/RVD。
- 由两名研究者完成所有测量并设盲。
- 数据分析包括组内相关系数(ICC)和配对比较检验(p<0.05)。
主要发现
- 数字测量值高于模拟测量值,平均配对差值范围为-4.86±3.2至0.42±2.7 mm。
- 除SN-SP(p=0.110)外,所有差异均有统计学意义。
- RVD测量中,G-SP和SN-SP的差异效应量大(ES>0.80),PN-SP为中等效应(ES>0.50)。
- OVD测量中,G-SP为大效应(ES>0.50),PN-SP和SN-SP为小效应(ES≤0.20)。
关键数值与推荐
- 模拟测量(对照)在面部直接进行,RVD为不戴义齿静息位,OVD为戴义齿正中咬合位。
- 数字测量使用面部扫描仪(Class 1 LASER,Obiscanner)扫描两次后导入网格处理软件测量。
- 统计方法为组内相关系数(ICC)和配对比较检验,显著性水平p<0.05。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为目前可能不推荐通过数字方法记录无牙颌患者的静息垂直距离。
- 临床医生目前仍须使用传统模拟方法以确保RVD测量准确,从而获得成功的义齿修复治疗。
局限性
- 本研究结论需考虑所用特定类型面部扫描仪的局限性。
- 数据采集过程中可能出现的误差可能影响测量的准确性和可靠性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to explore the feasibility and reliability of measuring the vertical dimension of occlusion/rest (OVD/RVD) on 3D facial scans of edentulous patients. METHODS: Nineteen edentulous participants rehabilitated with complete removable dental prostheses (CDs) participated in this study. Analog measurements (control) were obtained directly on the face for each participant with the jaws positioned at the rest position (without CDs, RVD) and at centric occlusion (with dentures, OVD), between the facial landmarks: Glabella (G) and Soft Pogonion (SP), Pronasale (PN) and SP, and Subnasale (SN) and SP. Participants' faces were scanned twice, using a face-scanner (Class 1 LASER, Obiscanner). Scans were imported into a mesh-processing software, and the OVD/RVD were measured digitally. Two investigators performed all the measurements and were blinded. Data analysis included intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) and pairwise comparison tests (p < 0.05). RESULTS: Digital measurements were higher than analog measurements, and the mean paired difference ranged from -4.86±3.2 to 0.42±2.7 mm. All the differences were statistically significant, expect for SN-SP (p = 0.110). Magnitude of the differences for the RVD were large for G-SP and SN-SP (ES>0.80) and moderate for PN-SP (ES>0.50). There was a large effect for G-SP when measuring OVD (ES>0.50), and small effect for PN-SP and SN-SP (ES≤0.20). CONCLUSION: Considering the limitations associated with the specific type of facial scanner used in this study, it can be concluded that registering the resting vertical dimension in edentulous patients through digital methods may not be currently recommended. This is due to the potential errors that may arise during the data acquisition process, which could compromise the accuracy and reliability of the measurements. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Digital methods for registering the vertical dimension of rest (RVD) in edentulous patients can introduce errors, resulting in occlusal errors and discomfort. Clinicians must, for the moment, still use conventional analog methods to ensure accurate RVD measurement for a successful denture therapy.
引用
- Srinivasan M, Handel S, Bronzino I, et al. Comparing analog and 3D measurements of vertical dimension in edentulous subjects. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 39805493. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105566
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。