两种不同扫描技术面部扫描仪临床准确性的评估
研究纳入40名牙列完整志愿者,比较渐进采集与多视角同步采集两种固定式面部扫描仪的临床准确性。结果显示数字测量值在所有距离上均显著大于临床测量值(p < 0.001);RAYface垂直测量百分比差异大于Obiscanner(p < 0.05),Obiscanner水平测量变异性大于RAYface(p < 0.05);数字测量组内差异显著(p < 0.001),组间信度高(ICC≥0.99)。
要点
- 数字测量值在所有测量距离上均显著大于临床测量值(p < 0.001)。
- RAYface垂直测量百分比差异大于Obiscanner(p < 0.05)。
- Obiscanner水平测量变异性大于RAYface(p < 0.05)。
核心结论
- 采用渐进采集与多视角同步采集技术的两种固定式面部扫描仪在准确性上存在显著差异,每种设备各具特定优势与局限。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入40名牙列完整志愿者,由两名独立检查者用数字游标卡尺手动测量面部软组织标志点间距,随后分别使用Obiscanner(渐进采集技术,需受试者头部旋转)或RAYface(多相机同步采集完整三维图像)扫描,将扫描数据导入网格处理软件由同一批检查者进行数字测量,数据分析包括配对比较检验和组内相关系数(ICC;α = 0.05)计算。
主要发现
- 数字测量值在所有测量距离上均显著大于临床测量值(p < 0.001)。
- RAYface垂直测量的百分比差异大于Obiscanner(p < 0.05)。
- Obiscanner水平测量的变异性大于RAYface(p < 0.05)。
- 两种方法的检查者组内差异均显著(p < 0.001)。
- 检查者组间差异仅临床测量显著(p < 0.001),数字测量不显著(p > 0.05);数字测量的检查者组间信度高(ICC≥0.99)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study compared the clinical accuracy of two different stationary face scanners, employing progressive capture and multi-view simultaneous capture scanning technologies. METHODS: Forty dentate volunteers participated in the study. Soft tissue landmarks were marked with a pen on the participants' faces to measure the distances between them. Clinical measurements were manually obtained using a digital vernier caliper by two independent examiners. The participants were then scanned using one of two stationary face scanners: Obiscanner (Fifthingenium), which employs progressive capture technology requiring the subject's head to rotate during image acquisition, or RAYFace (RAY), which utilizes multiple cameras to simultaneously capture a complete 3D image. The scans were imported into mesh-processing software, and digital measurements were taken by the same examiners. Data analysis included pairwise comparison tests and the calculation of the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC; α = 0.05). RESULTS: Digital measurements were significantly longer than clinical measurements across all measured distances (p < 0.001). Comparisons between the scanners revealed that vertical measurements using RAYface exhibited greater percentage differences compared to those using Obiscanner (p < 0.05), while horizontal measurements were more variable with Obiscanner than those obtained using RAYface (p < 0.05). Intra-examiner differences were significant for both methods (p < 0.001), although inter-examiner differences were only significant for clinical measurements (p < 0.001), not for digital measurements (p > 0.05). Inter-examiner reliability for digital measurements was high (ICC≥0.99). CONCLUSIONS: Significant differences were observed in the accuracy of the two stationary face scanners using progressive capture and multi-view simultaneous capture scanning technologies, with each device demonstrating specific strengths and limitations. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Although face scanners offer relatively high accuracy and consistency, particularly across different acquisition technologies, careful consideration of their performance characteristics is essential for optimizing accuracy in facial measurements.
引用
- Srinivasan M, Leles CR, Berisha F, et al. Clinical evaluation of the accuracy of two face scanners with different scanning technologies. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39743131. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105553
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。