文献速递牙体牙髓病

领先牙髓病学期刊编委会与作者身份的性别分析

Gender analysis of editorial boards and authorship in leading endodontics journals.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2025-01-12

该研究评估了2018至2023年领先全球牙髓病学期刊中女性在编委会和作者中的存在情况。共分析4本期刊、24名主编和233名副编辑,主编中无女性,副编辑中女性23名(9.8%)。8965名作者中女性2983名(33.2%),其中第一作者1288名(41.1%)、最后作者827名(27.7%)、通讯作者928名(31.1%)。女性在显要作者位置的存在与其他位置女性作者增加相关(p < .01)。

要点

  • 4本领先牙髓病学期刊的主编中无女性,副编辑中女性占9.8%。
  • 8965名作者中女性占33.2%,第一作者中女性占41.1%。
  • 女性在显要作者位置的存在与其他位置女性作者增加相关(p < .01)。

核心结论

  • 女性在领先期刊编委会和显要作者中的参与度较低,表明存在显著挑战。
  • 增加女性在显要作者角色中的存在可能促进女性在其他作者位置中的参与。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于Journal Citation Reports(JCR)影响因子和CiteScore 2022选择期刊,标准为JCR高于1且CiteScore高于1.5。
  • 编委会成员分为主编和副编辑,作者分为第一作者、最后作者和通讯作者。
  • 使用Genderize、PubMed、Scopus、ResearchGate和作者所属机构网站进行二元性别分析。
  • 采用描述性统计、泊松回归分析(计算女性作者与男性作者的患病率比PR)和卡方检验。

主要发现

  • 共分析4本期刊,识别24名主编和233名副编辑。
  • 主编中无女性,副编辑中女性23名(9.8%)。
  • 8965名作者中女性2983名(33.2%):第一作者1288名(41.1%)、最后作者827名(27.7%)、通讯作者928名(31.1%)。
  • 女性通讯作者的PR在AEJ高于JOE(1.07 [CI 1.03-1.11]),女性第一作者的PR在IEJ低于JOE(0.96 [CI 0.93-0.99])。
  • 与2023年相比,2018年女性第一作者PR较低(0.94 [CI 0.90-0.99]),2019年女性第一作者(0.94 [CI 0.90-0.98])和最后作者(0.94 [CI 0.90-0.98])PR较低。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To evaluate the presence of women on editorial boards and as authors in leading global endodontics journals from 2018 to 2023. METHODOLOGY: The selection of journals was based on the impact factor from Journal Citation Reports (JCR) and CiteScore 2022, with criteria of JCR above 1 and CiteScore above 1.5. Editorial board members were categorized as editor-in-chief and associate editor. Authorship was categorized into first, last, and corresponding author roles. The names of editorial board members and authors were extracted into an Excel spreadsheet, and gender analysis was conducted using the platforms Genderize, PubMed, Scopus, ResearchGate, and author's affiliated institutions' websites, categorized in a binary way. Descriptive statistics were used to analyse the data on the editorial board. A Poisson regression analysis was performed to investigate the prevalence ratio (PR) of female authorship compared with male authorship in the roles of first, last, and corresponding author. The Chi-square test was performed to evaluate the associations between female authors in prominent positions and the presence of other female authors. RESULTS: A total of four journals were analysed, identifying 24 editors-in-chief and 233 associate editors. None of the editor-in-chief were women, and 23 (9.8%) of the associate editors were female. Amongst the 8965 authors identified, 2983 (33.2%) were female: 1288 (41.1%) were first authors, 827 (27.7%) were last authors and 928 (31.1%) were correspondence authors. The PR for female corresponding authors was higher in AEJ than in JOE (1.07 [CI 1.03-1.11]), whilst the PR for female first authors was lower in IEJ than in JOE (0.96 [CI 0.93-0.99]). There was a lower PR for women as first authors in 2018 (0.94 [CI 0.90-0.99]) and as first (0.94 [CI 0.90-0.98]) and last (0.94 [CI 0.90-0.98)] authors in 2019 compared with 2023. The presence of women in prominent authorship positions was associated with increased female authorship in other positions (p < .01). CONCLUSION: Female participation on editorial boards and as prominent authors in leading journals is low, indicating significant challenges. Increasing female presence in prominent authorship roles may lead to greater female participation in other authorship positions.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Massa GDS, Barbosa AFA, Britto GA, et al. Gender analysis of editorial boards and authorship in leading endodontics journals. Int Endod J. 2025. PMID: 39800914. doi:10.1111/iej.14187

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。