优化儿童口腔卫生的移动健康干预:一项析因试验
该优化试验采用2³析因设计,纳入128名5岁以下儿童的mother,测试简短动机性访谈(MI)、讲故事视频(STV)和口腔健康促进信息(OHPM)对儿童牙菌斑和母亲报告刷牙频率的影响。3个月后菌斑均值从基线1.8降至1.5,每日刷牙率从50.8%升至69.5%,但各主效应及交互作用均未显著影响两项结局。
要点
- 3个月后菌斑均值由基线1.8降至1.5,每日刷牙率由50.8%升至69.5%。
- MI带来非显著的菌斑减少和每日刷牙增加。
- OHPM与STV联合而不加MI时相互抵消。
核心结论
- 单一或联合干预组分均未显著减少菌斑或增加每日刷牙。
- MI在行为改变方面最有希望,移动口腔健康组分在与MI组合前需要修改。
研究设计与样本
- 采用多阶段优化策略(MOST)框架的优化试验,为2³析因试验。
- 共纳入128名有5岁以下儿童的母亲,随机分配至3个组分开/关组合的8种实验条件。
- 主要结局为采用Silness和Löe改良菌斑指数评估的儿童菌斑堆积,评分范围0至3。
- 次要结局为母亲自报的儿童刷牙频率,分为每日至少一次和少于每日一次。
- 采用线性回归和带logit连接函数的广义线性回归评估3个月后各组分及其交互作用对菌斑评分和每日刷牙的影响,缺失值采用多重插补。
主要发现
- 菌斑从基线均值1.8降至3个月后均值1.5。
- 每日刷牙从50.8%增至3个月后69.5%。
- MI导致非显著的菌斑减少和非显著的每日刷牙增加。
- OHPM与STV联合而不加MI时相互抵消。
- 各主效应及二向或三向交互作用均未显著影响两项结局。
关键数值与推荐
- 效应层级原则指导优化包中组分的选择,优先考虑主效应和二向交互作用而非三向交互作用。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Behavioral interventions can improve children's oral hygiene practices. The multiphase optimization strategy (MOST) offers a framework to prepare, optimize, and evaluate behavioral interventions. This optimization trial tested 3 intervention components-brief motivational interviewing (MI), storytelling videos (STVs), and oral health promotion messages (OHPMs)-in enhancing mother's self-reported brushing of their preschool children's teeth. A total of 128 mothers with children <5 y old were included in a 23 factorial trial. The primary outcome was children's plaque accumulation, assessed using the modified Plaque Index of Silness and Löe, with scores ranging from 0 to 3. The secondary outcome was mothers' self-reported frequency of brushing their children's teeth, categorized as at least once daily or less than once daily. Mothers were randomized to 8 experimental conditions based on combinations of on-off levels of the 3 components. Linear regression and generalized linear regression with logit link function were used to assess the impact of the components and their interactions on plaque score and daily toothbrushing after 3 mo. Multiple imputation was used for missing values. The principle of effect hierarchy guided the selection of components for inclusion in the optimized package, giving priority to main effects and 2-way over 3-way interactions. Plaque was reduced from mean = 1.8 at baseline to mean = 1.5 and daily toothbrushing increased from 50.8% to 69.5% after 3 mo. MI led to non-significantly less plaque and non-significantly more daily toothbrushing. Combining OHPMs and STVs together without MI canceled each other. Neither the main effects nor the 2- or 3-way interactions significantly affected the 2 outcomes. Individual or combined components did not significantly reduce plaque or increase daily toothbrushing. MI had the greatest promise for behavior change, and the m-oral health components need modification before they can be combined with MI in a health promotion package.
引用
- Ihab M, El-Sherif Y, Yassin R, et al. Optimizing mHealth Interventions for Children's Oral Hygiene: A Factorial Trial. J Dent Res. 2024. PMID: 39629936. doi:10.1177/00220345241291985
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。