文献速递儿童口腔口腔正畸

公众对受损磨牙管理方案的估值:一项离散选择实验

Public Valuations of Managing Compromised Molars: A Discrete Choice Experiment.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent Res · 2024-12-09

本研究基于在线离散选择实验,调查英国成年普通人群对儿童受损第一恒磨牙管理路径的偏好并计算支付意愿。430名受访者完成实验,结果显示受访者重视儿童接受治疗,修复与自然或正畸间隙关闭估值相同,而部分间隙、桥修复或全间隙估值较低;偏好全科牙医、共同决策、低成本及避免未来牙科操作,并提供了边际支付意愿估计。

要点

  • 受访者重视儿童接受治疗,修复与自然或正畸间隙关闭估值相同。
  • 部分间隙、桥修复或全间隙估值低于修复或全间隙关闭。
  • 受访者偏好全科牙医、共同决策、低成本及避免未来牙科操作。

核心结论

  • 受访者重视儿童接受治疗,修复与自然或正畸间隙关闭估值相同,而部分间隙、桥修复或全间隙估值较低。
  • 受访者偏好全科牙医、共同决策、低成本及避免未来牙科操作,并提供了边际支付意愿估计可用于牙科服务估值。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于在线离散选择实验,设计信息来自半结构化访谈、文献综述及由牙医、公民和政策制定者组成的专家小组焦点小组。
  • 采用统计最优的D-efficient设计生成18个选择任务,分为2个区组,每位受访者回答一个区组的9个任务。
  • 选择任务涉及5个属性:治疗类型、提供者、决策者、避免的未来就诊次数和费用,并包含不治疗选项。
  • 使用条件Logit模型(固定效应)分析数据,计算各属性水平的边际支付意愿。
  • 共430名受访者完成离散选择实验。

主要发现

  • 受访者重视儿童接受治疗 compared with not(原文未提供具体数值)。
  • 修复受损第一恒磨牙与自然或正畸间隙关闭估值相同。
  • 部分间隙、桥修复或全间隙估值低于修复或全间隙关闭。
  • 全科牙医优于增强技能牙医,但无证据表明全科牙医优于儿童牙科专科医生。
  • 受访者偏好完全或部分参与决策过程,而非牙医单独决策;偏好低成本治疗及避免未来牙科操作。

关键数值与推荐

  • 原文未报告具体的支付意愿数值或置信区间。

临床怎么用

  • 牙科护理服务提供者在任何服务重新设计中必须考虑服务使用者对健康和非健康结果的偏好。
  • 结果提供的边际支付意愿估计可用于牙科护理服务估值。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

There is limited evidence to support optimal patient-centered management for compromised first permanent molars (cFPM) in children. Based on an online discrete choice experiment (DCE), this study elicits UK adult general population preferences and calculates willingness to pay (WTP) for pathways to manage cFPM. The DCE was designed with information from semistructured interviews and literature reviews, as well as focus groups with an expert panel of dentists, citizens, and policy makers. A statistically optimal D-efficient design generated 18 choice tasks, split across 2 blocks. Each respondent answered one block of 9 tasks to reduce survey fatigue. Choice tasks varied across 5 attributes: type of treatment, provider of care, who makes the management decision, number of future visits avoided, and cost. An opt-out was included (no treatment). Conditional logit models (fixed effects) were used for data analysis, and marginal WTP for each attribute level was calculated. An overall 430 respondents completed the DCE. Respondents valued children receiving care as compared with not. Restoring a cFPM was valued equally to spontaneous or orthodontic gap closure. In contrast, having a partial gap, prosthetic replacement with a bridge, or a full unit gap was valued less than restoration or full gap closure. General dentists were preferred to dentists with enhanced skills, but there was no evidence of a preference for general dentists over specialists in pediatric dentistry. Respondents preferred to be wholly or partly involved in the decision-making process as opposed to the dentist making the decision alone. Respondents preferred less costly treatments and the avoidance of future dental work. Dental care service providers must consider service user preferences for health and nonhealth outcomes in any service redesign. Furthermore, the results provide marginal WTP estimates that can be used to value dental care services.

来源:J Dent Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Taylor GD, Boyers D, Exley C, et al. Public Valuations of Managing Compromised Molars: A Discrete Choice Experiment. J Dent Res. 2024. PMID: 39651621. doi:10.1177/00220345241285154

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。