动态导航用于上颌前牙钙化根管治疗的学习曲线:风险调整累积和分析
本研究对45颗牙髓坏死伴根管钙化的上颌前牙进行动态导航系统(DNS)辅助治疗,由无临床DNS经验的单一术者操作,采用风险调整累积和分析评估学习曲线。结果显示根管定位成功率为93.33%(95%CI 80.7, 98.3),角度偏差、线性偏差和操作时间的均值(±SD)分别为3.21±2.23°、0.52±0.33 mm和34.14±13.18分钟,达到技术熟练约需18至28例。
要点
- DNS辅助钙化根管定位总体成功率为93.33%。
- 角度偏差峰值出现在第5和第18例,线性偏差峰值在第13和28例。
- 操作时间峰值在第7和26例,提示学习曲线约18-28例。
核心结论
- 使用DNS定位钙化根管达到技术熟练约需18至28例,存在显著学习曲线。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,由单一无临床DNS经验的牙髓科医生对45颗牙髓坏死伴根管钙化的上颌前牙行DNS辅助治疗。
主要发现
- 根管定位总体成功率为93.33%(95%CI 80.7, 98.3)。
- 角度偏差均值(±SD)为3.21±2.23°,线性偏差为0.52±0.33 mm,操作时间为34.14±13.18分钟。
- 角度偏差在5例和18例处出现两个峰值,将学习过程分为3个阶段:I期(1-5例)、II期(6-18例)、III期(19-45例)。
- 线性偏差峰值在第13和28例,操作时间峰值在第7和26例。
临床怎么用
- 临床开展DNS辅助钙化根管治疗前,应预期约18-28例的学习曲线以克服精度偏差。
- 学习过程中可关注第5、18例等关键节点,针对性反馈以缩短学习周期。
局限性
- 研究为单一术者经验,结果外推至其他操作者需谨慎。
- 样本量45颗牙,且为横断面设计,未涉及长期疗效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The dynamic navigation system (DNS) in endodontics presents a significant learning curve. This cross-sectional study aimed to assess the number of cases required to achieve consistent performance in DNS-assisted treatment of maxillary anterior teeth with pulp canal calcification. METHODS: A series of DNS procedures were performed on 45 calcified maxillary anterior teeth with pulp necrosis by a single endodontist who had no prior clinical DNS experience. Preoperative cone-beam computed tomography was obtained. After trace registration and calibration, drilling was executed using a low-speed bur. Once the canal was located and scouted to the working length, a postoperative cone-beam computed tomography was taken immediately. Angular deviation (AD), linear deviation (LD), and operating time (OT) were measured. The learning curve was evaluated using the risk-adjusted cumulative sum analysis method. RESULTS: The overall success rate in locating canals was 93.33% (95% CI 80.7, 98.3). The mean (±SD) for AD, LD and OT was 3.21 ± 2.23°, 0.52 ± 0.33 mm and 34.14 ± 13.18 minutes, respectively. For AD, 2 distinct peaks were observed at the 5th and 18th cases, identifying 3 learning phases: Phase I (cases 1-5), Phase II (cases 6-18), and Phase III (cases 19-45). Similarly, LD exhibited peaks at the 13th and 28th cases. Two peaks for OT were identified at the 7th and 26th cases. CONCLUSIONS: Achieving technical proficiency in locating calcified canals using DNS required approximately 18 to 28 cases, indicating a significant learning curve that must be overcome for optimal accuracy.
引用
- Sharma S, Haldar P, Kumar V, et al. Learning Curve for Dynamic Navigation Procedure during Endodontic Management of Permanent Maxillary Anterior Teeth with Pulp Canal Calcification: A Risk-Adjusted Cumulative Summation Analysis of a Single Operator's Experience. J Endod. 2024. PMID: 39708915. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2024.12.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。