澳大利亚牙髓专科医生与其他牙科从业者根管治疗后冠部修复中洞腔屏障偏好的问卷调查研究
该问卷调查研究对比了澳大利亚牙髓专科医生(SEP)与全科及其他专科医生(GDP+)在根管治疗牙(RFT)冠部修复中使用洞腔屏障(OB)的偏好。共457份有效回复,其中393份(86%)来自GDP+,64份(14%)来自SEP。结果显示,73.9%的从业者放置OB,材料选择集中于GIC、树脂复合材料、Cavit™和ZPC,SEP更偏好ZPC且更常因「易用性」选择,提示需进一步研究这些材料的相对性能以指导临床选择。
要点
- 澳大利亚牙科从业者中73.9%在根管治疗牙冠部修复时放置洞腔屏障。
- 最常去除根充物深度≤2 mm(91.8%),SEP较GDP+更偏好2 mm(p=.02)。
- 常用屏障材料包括GIC、树脂复合材料、Cavit™和ZPC,选择主因是易用性或封闭能力。
核心结论
- 洞腔屏障在澳大利亚牙科从业者中广泛使用,材料选择集中,主要基于易用性或封闭能力。
- 建议进一步研究这些材料作为洞腔屏障的相对性能,以指导临床医生修复根管治疗牙时的选择。
研究设计与样本
- 在线问卷调查,分发给在澳大利亚执业的牙髓专科医生(SEP)和全科及其他专科医生(GDP+)。
- 共457份有效回复:393份(86%)为GDP+,64份(14%)为SEP;429名报告进行牙髓治疗或修复。
- 使用Fisher精确检验比较分类变量,显著性水平设为p<.05。
主要发现
- 在429名报告进行牙髓治疗或修复的从业者中,317名(73.9%)放置洞腔屏障。
- 91.8%的从业者偏好去除根充物深度≤2 mm,SEP较GDP+更偏好2 mm(p=.02)。
- SEP选择ZPC的比例显著更高(p<.001),且更常因「易用性」选择(后牙p<.001,前牙p=.002)。
- 使用ZPC的SEP均偏好使用糊剂填充器/螺旋输送器,显著高于GDP+(后牙p<.001,前牙p=.002)。
- Cavit™常因「封闭能力」被选择。
关键数值与推荐
- 偏好去除根充物深度≤2 mm的从业者占91.8%。
- SEP与GDP+在偏好2 mm深度上差异显著(p=.02)。
- SEP选择ZPC的比例显著高于GDP+(p<.001)。
- SEP因「易用性」选择ZPC的比例显著高于GDP+(后牙p<.001,前牙p=.002)。
- 使用ZPC的SEP偏好糊剂填充器/螺旋输送器的比例显著高于GDP+(后牙p<.001,前牙p=.002)。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生在根管治疗牙冠部修复时可考虑放置洞腔屏障,常用材料包括GIC、树脂复合材料、Cavit™和ZPC。
- 选择屏障材料时可权衡易用性与封闭能力,并根据牙位和从业者培训背景调整。
- 去除根充物深度多选择≤2 mm,SEP更倾向2 mm。
局限性
- 研究为问卷调查研究,可能存在回忆偏倚和选择偏倚。
- 样本以GDP+为主(86%),SEP样本量较小(64份)。
- 未评估不同洞腔屏障材料的临床性能结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare the use of orifice barriers (OB) in root-filled teeth (RFT) between specialist endodontic practitioners (SEP) and general and other specialist practitioners (GDP+), and identify common materials, reasons for selection, and techniques. METHODS: An online survey was distributed to SEP and GDP+ practising in Australia. Demographic and multiple-choice questions relating to material selection and technique choices were asked to evaluate and relate usage patterns to practising and training backgrounds. Fisher's exact tests were undertaken to compare categorical variables across practitioner groups. Significance level was set at p<.05. RESULTS: There were 457 eligible responses: 393(86%) GDP+ and 64(14%) SEP. Of 429 reporting endodontically treating or restoring teeth, 317(73.9%) placed OB; preferred depth of root filling removal by most (91.8%) was ≤ 2 mm, with more SEP preferring 2 mm than GDP+(p=.02). Preferred materials for OB were conventional and resin-modified GIC (GIC), resin composite materials (RC), Cavit™ and zinc polycarboxylate cement (ZPC). 'Ease of use' was a common reason among all practitioners for GIC and RC. Significantly more SEP(p<.001) chose ZPC in all teeth and more commonly because of 'Ease of use' for both posterior (p<.001) and anterior (p=.002) teeth. All ZPC-using SEP preferred using a paste-filler/lentulo spiral, significantly more than GDP+ for posterior (p<.001) and anterior (p=.002) teeth. Cavit™ was often chosen for 'Sealing ability'. CONCLUSIONS: OB were widely placed by dental practitioners in Australia, with a small group of materials selected, most commonly for ease of use or sealing ability. The findings of this study suggest that further research should be undertaken to investigate the relative performance of these materials as OB and to inform the clinician's choices when restoring RFT.
引用
- Wylie ME, Parashos P, Fernando JR, et al. Orifice barrier preferences for coronal restoration of root filled teeth by endodontists and other dental practitioners in Australia: A questionnaire survey. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39645181. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105497
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。