直接修复体周围继发龋检测方法的准确性:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析评估了后牙直接修复体周围继发龋的七种检测方法,纳入25项研究。合并敏感度和特异度显示,视觉检查(临床)敏感度0.82[0.23-0.99]但置信区间宽,DIFOTI特异度0.95[0.90-0.98]最高,触诊敏感度仅0.31[0.25-0.39]。结论认为所有方法均未达到满意的诊断准确性。
要点
- 临床视觉检查敏感度0.82但置信区间宽,需谨慎解读。
- DIFOTI诊断比值比30.00,但仅1项研究,证据有限。
- 触诊敏感度低,不推荐单独用于继发龋检测。
核心结论
- 七种继发龋检测方法均未在后牙直接修复体周围展现出满意的诊断准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,纳入25项评估继发龋检测方法准确性的研究。
主要发现
- 视觉检查(实验室)合并敏感度0.60[0.45-0.73],特异度0.67[0.53-0.78]。
- 视觉检查(临床)合并敏感度0.82[0.23-0.99],特异度0.77[0.15-0.98]。
- 触诊合并敏感度0.31[0.25-0.39],特异度0.95[0.78-0.99]。
- 口内放射学合并敏感度0.59[0.52-0.66],特异度0.82[0.75-0.88]。
- CBCT合并敏感度0.61[0.48-0.73],特异度0.82[0.64-0.92]。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择继发龋检测方法时需认识到现有方法准确性均不理想。
- 可结合多种方法提高诊断信心,但需注意证据局限性。
局限性
- 部分检测方法研究数量少(如DIFOTI仅1项),合并结果不确定性大。
- 视觉检查(临床)等方法的置信区间宽,提示异质性高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate and compare the accuracy of detection methods for the diagnosis of secondary caries around direct restorations in posterior teeth. DATA: Accuracy parameters including sensitivity, specificity, diagnostic odds ratio (DOR), area under curve (AUC), and partial AUC (pAUC) are generated from studies assessing the accuracy of detection methods for secondary caries. SOURCES: Publications from PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, Medline, EMBASE and Cochrane Library databases. STUDY SELECTION/RESULTS: This review included 25 studies evaluating visual examination (V(laboratory); n = 9 & V(clinical); n = 2), tactile examination (T; n = 3), intra-oral radiography (IR; n = 14), cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT; n = 4), quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF; n = 4), laser fluorescence (LF; n = 8) and digital imaging fiber-optic transillumination (DIFOTI; n = 1). The pooled sensitivity [95 % Confidence Interval, CI] and specificity [95 % CI] of detection methods for secondary caries were 0.60[0.45-0.73] and 0.67[0.53-0.78] for V(laboratory); 0.82[0.23-0.99] and 0.77[0.15-0.98] for V(clinical); 0.31[0.25-0.39] and 0.95[0.78-0.99] for T; 0.59[0.52-0.66] and 0.82[0.75-0.88] for IR; 0.61[0.48-0.73] and 0.82[0.64-0.92] for CBCT; 0.71[0.64-0.78] and 0.51[0.40-0.62] for QLF; 0.57[0.43-0.71] and 0.81[0.76-0.85] for LF; and 0.63[0.47-0.76] and 0.95[0.90-0.98] for DIFOTI. DOR values [95 % CI] of the secondary caries detection methods were V(laboratory)-2.88[2.18-3.80]; V(clinical)-16.66[3.84-72.28]; T-6.36[1.12-36.28]; IR-6.55[3.44-12.46]; CBCT-6.18[1.42-26.91]; QLF-2.25[1.39-3.63]; LF-4.86[2.40-9.82]; and DIFOTI-30.00[11.94-75.36], respectively. Respective AUC (pAUC) were V-0.645(0.535); T-0.379(0.315); IR-0.767(0.693); CBCT-0.887(0.820); QLF-0.581(0.633) and LF-0.828(0.590). AUC values were not available for DIFOTI and V(clinical). CONCLUSIONS: Among the seven types of detection method for secondary caries diagnosis, none of the detection methods demonstrate satisfactory accuracy in detecting secondary caries around direct restorations in posterior teeth. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This systematic review provides insights for the clinician and researcher in selecting the clinical detection method for secondary caries diagnosis and facilitates clinical decision making.
引用
- Ku JC, Lam WY, Li KY, et al. Accuracy of detection methods for secondary caries around direct restorations: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39719157. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105541
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。