文献速递牙周病口腔修复与种植

加载角度与材料对牙周夹板应力分布影响的有限元研究

[Effect of loading angle and fabrication materials on stress distribution with periodontal splint in compromised periodontal tissues: a finite element study].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2024-01-01

基于25岁男性锥形束CT数据建立下颌前牙有限元模型,比较PEEK、纤维带树脂和钛三种牙周夹板在0°、30°、60°、90°静态100 N加载下对牙周组织、粘接剂层及夹板本身的应力分布影响。结果显示三种夹板均能有效分散基牙牙周组织应力,PEEK夹板自身应力较小但传递至粘接剂层的应力较大。

要点

  • 三种材料牙周夹板均能有效分散基牙牙周组织应力。
  • 夹板弹性模量越大,自身应力越大,传递至粘接剂层应力越小。
  • PEEK组41牙周膜最大应力与无骨吸收组相似,大于纤维带组和钛板组。

核心结论

  • 三种材料制作的牙周夹板均能有效分散基牙牙周组织应力。
  • 相比纤维带和钛板组,PEEK夹板自身应力值较小,传递至粘接剂层的应力值较大。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于1例25岁男性锥形束CT影像数据构建下颌前牙有限元模型,包含无骨吸收组、骨吸收对照组及PEEK组、纤维带组、钛板组。
  • 于41切端中点静态加载100 N,方向为0°、30°、60°、90°,分析牙周组织、粘接剂层和夹板应力分布。

主要发现

  • 骨吸收对照组牙周膜和牙槽骨最大von Mises应力分别为15.7~50.2 MPa和38.8~130.3 MPa。
  • 无骨吸收组牙周膜和牙槽骨最大von Mises应力分别为3.6~6.4 MPa和16.5~42.7 MPa。
  • PEEK组41牙周膜最大von Mises应力为4.6~6.2 MPa,与无骨吸收组相似,但大于纤维带组和钛板组。
  • 各组牙周膜和牙槽骨最大von Mises应力主要分布于41颈部牙周膜和牙槽骨。
  • 牙周夹板弹性模量越大,夹板最大von Mises应力越大,传递至粘接剂层的第一主应力越小。

临床怎么用

  • 临床选择牙周夹板材料时需权衡夹板自身应力与粘接剂层应力,高弹性模量材料传递至粘接剂层应力较小。
  • PEEK夹板可用于分散基牙牙周组织应力,但需关注其传递至粘接剂层的较大应力。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To evaluate the effect of polyetheretherketone (PEEK) periodontal splints and splints made from other materials under static loading on stress distributions in periodontal tissues, cement layer, and splints themselves. Methods: A finite element model based on cone-beam CT imaging data of a 25-year-old male patient (treated at the Department of Prosthodontics, School of Stomatology, The Fourth Military Medical University in October 2021 for a cracked maxillary molar) with a healthy and intact mandibular dentition and periodontal health was constructed. The finite element model included anterior mandible dentition, mandibular bone model without bone resorption (WBR group), a periodontally compromised mandible model (control group), and three types of periodontal splints: a PEEK periodontal splint (0.7 mm thick, Young's modulus: 4.1 MPa), a fiber-reinforced resin (FRC) splint (1.0 mm thick, Young's modulus: 37.0 MPa), and a titanium splint (1.2 mm thick, Young's modulus: 110.0 MPa). The bone resorption models fixed with different periodontal splints constituted the experimental groups (PEEK group, FRC group and titanium group). Loading of 100 N was applied on the midpoint of the incisal edge of tooth 41. The direction was set at 0°, which was parallel to the long axis of the tooth and downward. The buccal to lingual and downward angles were 30°and 60°, respectively, perpendicular to the long axis of the tooth and 90° to the lingual side. The finite element analysis software was utilized to analyze the stress distribution characteristics of the periodontal tissues, adhesive layer, and the splint itself in the anterior mandibular teeth among the different group. Results: Under the different loading simulation, in the control group, the maximal von Mises stresses of periodontal ligament and bone were 15.7-50.2 MPa and 38.8-130.3 MPa, respectively, and in the WBR group, the maximal von Mises stresses of periodontal ligament and bone were 3.6-6.4 MPa and 16.5-42.7 MPa, respectively. Under the same loading conditions, the magnitude of maximal von Mises stresses in periodontal tissues in the PEEK group was 4.6-6.2 MPa, and the magnitude of stresses in the periodontal ligament of 41 teeth in the WBR group was similar to that in the PEEK group, but higher than that in the FRC and titanium groups. The maximal von Mises stresses of each group is primarily distributed in the periodontal ligament and alveolar bone at the cervical area of the tooth. The higher the elastic modulus of the splint, the higher its own maximal von Mises stresses, and the smaller the maximal principal stresses transmitted to the adhesive layer. In the PEEK group and titanium group, the stress distribution area in the adhesive layer and the splint was near the splint connection adjacent to tooth 41. Conclusions: Periodontal splints fabricated from three types of materials, are effective in distributing stress within the periodontal tissues of the abutment teeth. Compared to FRC and titanium group, the higher PEEK splint stress value was obtained, and the smaller the stress value was transmitted to its adhesive layer. 目的: 分析静态载荷下聚醚醚酮(PEEK)夹板与其他材料制作的牙周夹板对牙周组织、粘接剂层以及夹板本身应力分布的影响,以期为PEEK夹板的临床应用提供参考。 方法: 选取1例下颌牙列完整且牙周健康的25岁男性志愿者(2021年10月因上颌磨牙牙隐裂于第四军医大学口腔医院口腔修复科就诊)的锥形束CT影像数据,建立有限元模型,构建下前牙无骨吸收牙槽骨模型(无骨吸收组)、骨吸收模型(骨吸收对照组)和3种材料制作的牙周夹板模型:PEEK夹板(厚度0.7 mm,弹性模量4.1 MPa)、纤维带树脂夹板(厚度1.0 mm,弹性模量37.0 MPa)和钛夹板(厚度1.2 mm,弹性模量110.0 MPa),以不同牙周夹板修复的骨吸收模型为牙周夹板组(PEEK组、纤维带组及钛板组)。于41切端中点处静态加载100 N载荷,方向分别设定为平行于牙体长轴且向下的0°,从颊侧向舌侧并向下与牙体长轴分别呈30°、60°,垂直于牙体长轴且向舌侧的90°。利用有限元分析软件分析不同角度加载下各组下颌前牙牙周组织、粘接剂层和牙周夹板的应力分布特征。 结果: 不同角度加载下,骨吸收对照组牙周膜和牙槽骨最大von Mises应力值分别为15.7~50.2 MPa和38.8~130.3 MPa,无骨吸收组牙周膜和牙槽骨最大von Mises应力值分别为3.6~6.4 MPa和16.5~42.7 MPa;PEEK组41牙周膜最大von Mises应力值为4.6~6.2 MPa,与相同角度加载下无骨吸收组相似,但大于相同角度加载下纤维带组和钛板组。各组牙周膜和牙槽骨最大von Mises应力主要分布于41颈部牙周膜和牙槽骨。牙周夹板弹性模量越大,夹板最大von Mises应力值越大,传递至粘接剂层的第一主应力越小。PEEK组、钛板组粘接剂层和牙周夹板应力主要分布于邻近41的夹板连接体处。 结论: 3种材料制作的牙周夹板均能有效分散基牙牙周组织应力。相比其他牙周夹板组,PEEK夹板自身应力值较小,传递至粘接剂层的应力值较大。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fang M, Liu YC, Zhong S, et al. [Effect of loading angle and fabrication materials on stress distribution with periodontal splint in compromised periodontal tissues: a finite element study]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2024. PMID: 39472091. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20240712-00270

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。