运用有声思维法验证牙周炎自评问卷
本研究采用有声思维访谈法,对20名英国英语流利成人进行在线录音访谈,评估牙周炎自评问卷(15个问题加2个开放性问题)的认知理解。结果显示多数问题被正确理解,但2个条目存在误读或不被多数人理解,提示自评问卷灵敏度偏低可能源于理解偏差。
要点
- 有声思维法可揭示自评问卷条目的理解偏差。
- 2个条目存在误读或不被多数参与者理解。
- 问卷理解偏差可能导致流行病学调查的信息偏倚。
核心结论
- 有声思维法揭示了英语英国居民对牙周炎自评问题的解释与理解,并提示自评问卷灵敏度值较低的可能原因。
研究设计与样本
- 采用有声思维访谈的认知验证研究,纳入20名英国居民、英语流利成人,在线录制访谈。
主要发现
- 多数自评问卷问题被参与者良好理解,但2个条目存在问题:一个被误解,另一个不被多数参与者理解。
- 对开放式问题的定性常规内容分析重申并补充了有声思维研究的发现。
- 对3名或以上参与者标记为有问题的条目考虑重新措辞。
关键数值与推荐
- 自评牙周炎问卷包含15个问题和2个开放性问题。
- 访谈由两名独立研究者根据预定义类别进行转录和编码。
临床怎么用
- 在流行病学调查中使用自评牙周炎问卷时,需注意条目理解偏差可能导致信息偏倚。
- 对理解有问题的条目应重新措辞以提高问卷准确性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The gold standard approach to diagnose periodontitis is based on clinical examination and radiographic investigations. This, however, is expensive, tedious, and not feasible in population-level assessments. The self-reported periodontitis questionnaire offers great benefit to facilitate larger epidemiological surveys. There is limited evidence on cognitive validation of self-reported periodontitis questionnaire. This study employed a think aloud approach to investigate if participants interpreted, comprehended, and understood the items in a self-reported periodontitis questionnaire, in the same way as researchers' intended. METHODS: 20 adults, resident of the UK and fluent in English participated in online recorded think aloud interviews. The self-reported periodontitis questionnaire consists of 15 questions and 2 open ended questions. The interviews were then transcribed and coded by two independent researchers according to predefined categories representing comprehension and conventional content analysis was used to analyse open-ended data. RESULTS: The think aloud approach revealed that most of the questions in the self-reported periodontitis questionnaire were well understood by the participants. Two items, however, were identified as problematic: one was misinterpreted, and another question was not understood by most of the participants. Qualitative conventional content analysis of open-ended questions reiterated and complemented the findings of the think aloud study. Further questions coded as problematic for 3 or more participants were then considered for rephrasing. CONCLUSIONS: This study revealed the interpretation and understanding of self-reported periodontitis questions by English speaking UK residents and highlighted the probable reason for lower sensitivity values of the self-reported periodontitis questionnaire. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This study employed think-aloud approach to capture the thought process of the participants as they answered questions on self-reported periodontitis questionnaire. Overall, the questionnaire was well received by the participants, however, some questions were misunderstood/misinterpreted. This study highlights the potential information bias if participants do not understand the questions in epidemiological surveys.
引用
- Krishna-Naik V, Palmer A, Hodson NA, et al. Utilisation of a think-aloud protocol to validate a self-reported periodontitis questionnaire. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39349094. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105381
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。