牙医为何不干预根管充填牙的持续性无症状根尖周炎:全科牙医访谈研究
质性内容分析归纳出总体主题「复杂临床情境中怀疑与确定之间」,涵盖信心连续谱与支持接受两方面,动机多样。
要点
- 不再干预的决定带有一定信心,并辅以补偿策略支持该决定
- 决策兼顾患者价值与外部资源限制,也受牙医个人偏好、便利、担忧、抱负与情绪影响
- 患者自主性、风险与成本效益、情绪因素及缓解措施是接受不干预的主要理由
核心结论
- 对根管充填牙伴PAAP不再行正行或逆行再治疗或拔牙的决定带有一定信心,并结合补偿策略支持该决定。
- 决策不仅考虑对患者有益的价值和有限外部资源,也涉及牙医个人偏好、便利、担忧、抱负与情绪。
研究设计与样本
- 访谈数字化录音并逐字转录,采用归纳法质性内容分析。
主要发现
- 识别出决策过程伴随不同程度的不确定性,不干预动机具有很大多样性。
- 归纳出总体主题「复杂临床情境中怀疑与确定之间」,涵盖潜在内容。
- 第一主范畴「信心连续谱」含「经历的不确定」「勉强认可」「对不干预感到自在」三个子范畴。
- 第二主范畴「支持接受」含「患者自主性、风险与成本效益」「情绪方面」「缓解措施」三个子范畴。
临床怎么用
- 接诊根管充填牙伴PAAP时,应意识到不干预决策受牙医个人因素与情绪影响,需结合患者自主性与风险成本效益共同决策。
局限性
- 原文未报告研究局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To explore the context in which general dental practitioners (GDPs) decide to refrain from further treatment, that is, ortho- or retrograde retreatment or extraction of a root canal filled tooth with persistent asymptomatic apical periodontitis (PAAP). METHODOLOGY: Fifteen GDPs were strategically selected for in-depth interviews. The informants were encouraged to describe in their own words and in as much detail as possible, the three most recent patient cases of PAAP of a root canal filled tooth, in which they decided to refrain from further treatment. The interviews were recorded digitally and transcribed verbatim. The collected material was analysed according to Qualitative Content Analysis with an inductive approach. RESULTS: A pattern of varying degrees of uncertainty associated with the decision process was identified. The motives to refrain intervention had great diversity. The result from analysis of the qualitative data was formulated in an overall theme 'Between doubt and certainty in a complex clinical context' covering the latent content. The first main category covering the manifest content was 'The continuum of confidence' with three subcategories 'Experienced uncertainty', 'Reluctant approval' and 'At ease with refraining' illustrating the feelings and attitudes experienced by the informants. The second category was 'In support of acceptance' with three subcategories 'Patient's autonomy, risks and cost-benefits', 'Emotional aspects' and 'Relieving measures' representing the reasons for refraining from intervention. CONCLUSIONS: The decision to refrain from further treatment, that is, ortho- or retrograde retreatment or extraction of a root canal filled tooth with PAAP was made with some measure of confidence, combined with compensatory strategies to support the decision, taking into account not only values beneficial to the patient and awareness of limited external resources, but also factors related to the informants' personal preferences, convenience, concerns, ambition and emotions.
引用
- Lindström MG, Fransson H, Dawson VS, et al. Why do dentists refrain from intervention in cases of persistent asymptomatic apical periodontitis in root canal filled teeth? An interview study among general dental practitioners. Int Endod J. 2024. PMID: 39440881. doi:10.1111/iej.14158
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。