自来水过滤净化系统的使用及其对氟化物和其他矿物质浓度的影响——一项基于社区的研究
本研究调查了美国印第安纳州中部居民使用水过滤和净化系统(WFPS)的普及率,并确定WFPS对自来水中氟化物、钙、镁、钾和钠浓度的效果。反渗透系统对矿物质浓度降低影响最大,而滤水壶过滤器与未过滤自来水基本相当。
要点
- 71%的参与者使用某种水过滤净化系统,滤水壶过滤器最常见(31%)。
- 反渗透系统导致最低的矿物质浓度,包括氟化物中位数0.08 ppm。
- 滤水壶过滤器对矿物质浓度无不良影响,软水器导致最高的钠浓度(78.40 ppm)。
核心结论
- 大部分研究参与者使用WFPS,滤水壶过滤器最常见。
- 反渗透系统对降低自来水矿物质水平影响最显著,滤水壶过滤器不影响矿物质浓度。
研究设计与样本
- 基于人口普查的问卷调查收集人口统计学、用水和水源数据。
- 参与者提供自来水或所用WFPS的水样,使用离子选择性电极(氟化物)和原子吸收光谱法(金属)分析。
主要发现
- 71%的参与者使用某种WFPS。
- 黑人使用WFPS的可能性低于亚裔或白人参与者(p = 0.045)。
- 拥有学士学位或更高学历者更可能使用WFPS(p = 0.003)。
- 最常用的WFPS为滤水壶过滤器(31%)、软水器(21%)、反渗透系统(11%)、水龙头安装过滤器(4%)和全屋碳过滤器(1%)。
- 反渗透系统导致最低的矿物质浓度(中位数,ppm;F-0.08,Ca-2.30,Mg-0.46,Na-4.60,P-0.35);软水器导致最高的钠浓度(78.40 ppm)。
临床怎么用
- 了解不同WFPS对自来水中各种矿物质的影响有助于消费者选择合适的系统。
- 口腔护理提供者可指导患者关于水消费和氟化物补充的需求,尤其是高龋风险者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the prevalence of water filtration and purification system (WFPS) use among residents of central Indiana (USA) and determined the effects of WFPS on the concentrations of fluoride, calcium, magnesium, potassium, and sodium in tap water. METHODS: A census-based questionnaire collected data on demographics, water use, and water sources. Participants were also asked to provide water samples from their tap water or the WFPS they used. Water samples were analyzed using ion-specific electrodes (fluoride) and atomic absorption spectrometry (metals). Mineral concentration comparisons between water sources used nonparametric tests; questionnaire associations were testing using correlations, chi-square tests, and nonparametric tests. RESULTS: One hundred and one participants completed the study, of which 71 % used some type of WFPS. Blacks were less likely to use WFPS than Asian or White participants (p = 0.045). Those with bachelor's degrees or higher were more likely to use WFPS (p = 0.003). The most used WFPS were pitcher filters (31 %), water softeners (21 %), reverse osmosis systems (11 %), faucet-mounted filters (4 %), and whole-house carbon filters (1 %). Reverse osmosis systems resulted in the lowest mineral concentrations (median, ppm; F-0.08, Ca-2.30, Mg-0.46, Na-4.60, P-0.35). Pitcher filters were largely comparable to unfiltered tap water. Water softeners resulted in the highest sodium concentrations (78.40 ppm). CONCLUSION: A large proportion of study participants use WFPS, with pitcher filters being the most common. Reverse osmosis systems had the most significant impact on reducing mineral levels in tap water, while pitcher filters do not adversely affect mineral concentrations. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Understanding how different WFPS affect the various minerals in tap water is essential for helping consumers in choosing the right system and for oral care providers to guide patients on water consumption and the need for fluoride supplementation, especially for those at high risk of dental caries.
引用
- Hazzazi LW, Soto-Rojas AE, Martinez-Mier EA, et al. Tap water filtration and purification usage and their impact on the concentrations of fluoride and other minerals - A community-based study. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39349095. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105377
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。