文献速递儿童口腔牙体牙髓病

三种乳磨牙龋病管理方法的两年随机临床试验比较

Comparison of three management approaches for dental caries in primary molars: A two-year randomized clinical trial.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2024-10-05

本研究为两年平行组随机对照试验,纳入122名3-8岁儿童,比较Hall技术(HT)、非修复性龋病治疗(NRCT)和传统充填(CR)的临床成功率。两年后HT成功率93.8%显著高于CR的60.8%和NRCT的42.5%(p<0.001),HT相对CR的绝对风险降低为0.33,需治疗人数为3(95%CI 0.02-0.58)。所有技术耐受性良好,CR更耗时,HT操作难度更高。

要点

  • HT两年临床成功率93.8%,显著优于CR(60.8%)和NRCT(42.5%)。
  • HT相对CR的ARR=0.33,NNT=3(95%CI 0.02-0.58)。
  • NRCT未见优于CR的获益,不能替代充填治疗。

核心结论

  • Hall技术临床成功率优于传统充填和非修复性龋病治疗。
  • 所有治疗技术儿童耐受性良好,传统充填更耗时,Hall技术操作难度更高。

研究设计与样本

  • 两年平行组随机对照试验,纳入122名3-8岁儿童,CR组n=52,HT组n=35,NRCT组n=35。
  • 采用Nyvad标准记录龋病,评估临床成功率/失败率、疼痛感知、行为及治疗接受度。

主要发现

  • 两年后116名参与者,临床成功率:CR=60.8%(n=31),HT=93.8%(n=30),NRCT=42.5%(n=14)(p<0.001)。
  • 主要/次要失败率:CR=17.6%(n=9)/21.6%(n=11);HT=6.2%(n=2)/0%;NRCT=33.3%(n=11)/24.2%(n=8)(p<0.05)。
  • HT与CR比较,ARR=0.33,NNT=3(95%CI 0.02-0.58);NRCT与CR比较未见获益。
  • 超过70%儿童治疗期间表现为积极/非常积极行为;疼痛强度为非常低/低的比例:CR 92.3%,HT 88.6%,NRCT 77.1%。
  • NRCT操作非常容易的比例为82.9%,CR为42.3%,HT为17.1%(p<0.05);CR耗时多于NRCT和HT(p<0.05)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 乳磨牙龋病管理可采用微创方法,尤其是Hall技术封闭龋损。
  • NRCT在提供充分机械菌斑去除和氟化物条件下可阻止龋病进展。
  • 偶尔涂氟和不控制含氟牙膏刷牙不能替代充填治疗。

临床怎么用

  • 乳磨牙龋病可优先考虑Hall技术,其两年临床成功率最高。
  • NRCT可作为微创选项,但需确保充分机械菌斑去除和氟化物使用,不能替代充填。
  • 传统充填耗时较长,Hall技术操作难度较高,选择时需考虑操作者技术与时间。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性内容。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: to compare two-year clinical success rates of caries management in children (Hall Technique HT, Nonrestorative caries treatment NRCT, Conventional restorations CR), and to evaluate pain perception, behaviour, technique acceptability by patients, parents and dentists. METHODS: 122, 3-8-year-olds were enrolled in 2-year parallel group randomised controlled trial (CR, n = 52, HT, n = 35, NRCT, n = 35). Caries was recorded using Nyvad criteria to measure clinical success/ failure rates. Child's pain perception (Visual Analogue Scale of Faces), child behaviour (Frankl scale), parents' and dentists' treatment opinions (5-point Likert scale) were assessed. Statistical analysis included Chi-square, non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis, Bonferroni-corrected Mann-Whitney U tests (p < 0.05), absolute risk reduction (ARR) and number needed to treat (NNT). RESULTS: After two years, with 116 participants, clinical success rates were: CR=60.8 % (n = 31), HT=93.8 % (n = 30), NRCT=42.5 % (n = 14) (p < 0.001). Major/minor failure rates differed: CR=17.6 % (n = 9) / 21.6 % (n = 11); HT=6.2 % (n = 2)/ 0 %, NRCT=33.3 % (n = 11)/ 24.2 % (n = 8), (p < 0.05). When comparing HT to CR, ARR = 0.33; NNT= 3 (95 % CI 0.02 -0.58); NRCT to CR, - no observed benefit from NRCT. More than 70 % of children demonstrated "positive/definitely positive" behaviour during treatment. Pain intensity was "very low/low" in 92.3 % of cases for CR, 88.6 % for HT, and 77.1 % for NRCT . NRCT was "very easy" to perform for 82.9 % of participants, compared to 42.3 % for CR and 17.1 % for HT (p < 0.05). CR were reported to take longer than NRCT and HT (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Clinical success rates of HT were superior to CR and NRCT. All treatment techniques were well tolerated by children, CR was more time-consuming and HT - technically more difficult to perform. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: caries management in primary molars can be successfully performed using minimal intervention, particularly, sealing in caries lesions with Hall technique. NRCT can prevent caries progression when adequate access to mechanical plaque disruption and fluoride is provided. However, occasional fluoride application, and uncontrolled toothbrushing with fluoride toothpaste cannot replace restorative procedures.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Narbutaite J, Santamaría RM, Innes N, et al. Comparison of three management approaches for dental caries in primary molars: A two-year randomized clinical trial. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39374732. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105390

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。