西班牙牙医对恒牙深龋与露髓的管理偏好调查
该调查通过匿名网络问卷评估西班牙牙医对恒牙深龋去腐和露髓管理的偏好,共收到538份回复。结果显示,牙医在去腐选择和露髓管理上与活髓治疗指南存在偏差,主要表现为适应证和病例选择方面;术后教育水平与更保守和更新的决策相关。
要点
- 深龋去腐偏好选择性去腐至坚硬牙本质,而非选择性去腐至软牙本质或阶梯式去腐。
- 无症状露髓首选直接盖髓,可逆性牙髓炎症状时比例下降。
- 不可逆性牙髓炎时,成熟牙多行牙髓摘除术,年轻恒牙多行牙髓切断术。
核心结论
- 西班牙牙医的深龋去腐和露髓管理偏好与活髓治疗指南存在偏差,主要在适应证和病例选择上。
研究设计与样本
- 一项基于网络的开放式匿名问卷调查,共收到538份西班牙执业牙医的回复,问卷包含40个问题,涵盖人口学资料、龋坏组织去除、露髓决策、直接盖髓和牙髓切断术五个部分。
主要发现
- 对于浅中层龋坏,53.7%的受访者偏好完全去腐;对于深龋,57.8%偏好选择性去腐至坚硬牙本质。
- 选择性去腐至软牙本质和阶梯式去腐分别仅占15.4%和10.9%。
- 无症状露髓牙采用直接盖髓的比例超过80%,存在可逆性牙髓炎症状时降至57.1%。
- 诊断不可逆性牙髓炎时,53.5%的受访者对年轻恒牙行牙髓摘除术,89.9%对成熟恒牙行牙髓摘除术;仅26.4%的临床医生常规行牙髓切断术。
关键数值与推荐
- 直接盖髓和牙髓切断术的决策中,患者态度和优先事项是最相关标准,其次是疼痛史和出血情况。
- 临床操作中偏好使用干棉球止血,首选材料为Biodentine。
- 研究生教育和继续教育在龋病管理和活髓治疗方面与更保守和更新的决策 consistently 相关。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应参考活髓治疗指南,优化深龋去腐和露髓管理的病例选择与适应证。
- 对于无症状露髓牙,直接盖髓是常见选择,但需结合患者态度和出血情况综合决策。
- 年轻恒牙不可逆性牙髓炎时,可考虑牙髓切断术作为替代方案。
- 使用液压硅酸钙水门汀(如Biodentine)进行活髓治疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To assess Spanish dentists' management preferences for deep caries removal and exposed pulps in permanent teeth. METHODOLOGY: A web-based open and anonymous survey was distributed by social media and a specific website for this project amongst dentists practicing in Spain. The questionnaire comprised 40 questions, divided into five sections: (1) demographic data and professional activity; (2) carious tissue removal; (3) decision-making regarding pulp exposure; (4) direct pulp capping and (5) pulpotomy procedures in permanent teeth. Results were descriptively analysed. Logistic regression (95% CI) analyses and X2 tests were carried out. RESULTS: A total of 538 responses were received. Half the respondents (53.7%) preferred to perform complete caries excavation for shallow and moderate carious dentin lesions, and selective excavation to firm dentin for deep lesions (57.8%). Selective removal to soft dentin and stepwise removal were much less indicated (15.4% and 10.9%, respectively). Exposed pulps in asymptomatic teeth were treated by direct pulp capping (over 80%), decreasing in the presence of reversible pulpitis symptoms (57.1%). If irreversible pulpitis was diagnosed, a pulpectomy would be performed by 53.5% and 89.9% of the respondents in, respectively, immature and mature teeth. Pulpotomy was performed routinely only by 26.4% of the clinicians. Patients' attitudes and priorities were the most relevant criteria when performing direct pulp capping and pulpotomy, together with the history of pain and the presence of bleeding. Regarding the clinical procedure, dry cotton was preferred to obtain haemostasis and Biodentine was the material of election. CONCLUSIONS: Caries removal preferences and management of pulp exposure by dentists practicing in Spain deviated from vital pulp treatment guidelines, mainly regarding indications and case selection. Pulp exposure was managed by direct pulp capping in asymptomatic cases, whilst immature permanent molars favoured the indication of pulpotomy when pulpitis was diagnosed. Most clinicians used hydraulic calcium silicate cement, specifically Biodentine, to perform vital pulp treatments. Postgraduate formation and continuing education in caries lesions management and vital pulp treatments were consistently related to more conservative and updated decisions.
引用
- Bailleul L, Ceballos L, Doméjean S, et al. Deep caries and pulp exposures management preferences in permanent teeth: A survey amongst Spanish dentists. Int Endod J. 2024. PMID: 39474713. doi:10.1111/iej.14159
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。