口腔开放科学实践与引用率和Altmetric评分的关联
该研究随机抽取2000至2022年发表的龋病相关随机对照试验,评估开放科学实践与引用率和Altmetric Attention Score的关联。结果显示方案注册和开放获取发表与更高引用率及Altmetric评分相关,但全文开放获取期刊的论文引用反而更少,且校正偏倚风险后开放获取的引用优势消失。结论认为开放科学实践的影响复杂,更多与期刊影响因子相关。
要点
- 方案注册与开放获取发表与龋病RCT较高引用率相关(IRR分别为1.45和1.24)。
- 全文开放获取期刊的论文引用率更低(IRR=0.67),校正偏倚风险后开放获取失去显著性。
- 方案注册与开放获取手稿的Altmetric评分更高(IRR分别为3.74和1.69)。
核心结论
- 开放科学实践与龋病RCT的引用率和Altmetric评分呈部分相关,但效应复杂且更多与期刊影响因子相关。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为横断面分析,随机抽取2000至2022年发表的龋病相关随机对照试验,共分析323篇论文。
- 由两名独立评估者手动收集开放科学实践数据,并用Robot Reviewer工具自动评估偏倚风险。
- 采用负二项回归分析关联,以发生比率比(IRR;α=0.05)表示。
主要发现
- 57.5%(n=186)的文章至少采用一种开放科学实践,去除开放获取后降至39.6%(n=128)。
- 方案注册(IRR:1.45;95%CI:1.15,1.82)和开放获取发表(IRR:1.24;95%CI:1.01,1.53)的论文引用率更高。
- 全文开放获取期刊的论文引用更少(IRR:0.67;95%CI:0.52,0.87)。
- 校正偏倚风险后,低偏倚风险研究引用率更高(IRR:1.48;95%CI:1.14,1.91),开放获取失去显著性。
- 方案注册和开放获取手稿的Altmetric评分更高(IRR:3.74;95%CI:2.00,7.01;IRR:1.69;95%CI:1.04,2.75),校正偏倚风险和影响因子后方案注册仍显著(IRR:3.71;95%CI:1.97-6.99)。
关键数值与推荐
- 方案注册与引用率正相关(IRR:1.45;95%CI:1.15,1.82)。
- 开放获取发表与引用率正相关(IRR:1.24;95%CI:1.01,1.53)。
- 全文开放获取期刊与引用率负相关(IRR:0.67;95%CI:0.52,0.87)。
- 低偏倚风险与更高引用率相关(IRR:1.48;95%CI:1.14,1.91)。
- 方案注册与Altmetric评分正相关(校正后IRR:3.71;95%CI:1.97-6.99)。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策引用证据时需注意开放科学实践并非引用或关注度的可靠替代指标。
- 期刊声望和影响因子可能比开放科学实践更能驱动论文的引用与传播。
- 评估龋病RCT证据时应同时考虑偏倚风险和开放科学实践情况。
局限性
- 研究为观察性设计,无法确立开放科学实践与引用率或Altmetric评分的因果关系。
- 仅纳入龋病相关随机对照试验,结论外推至其他口腔研究领域需谨慎。
- 开放科学实践数据由人工收集,可能存在评估者偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: Open science, a set of principles and practices, aims to make scientific research more accessible and accountable, benefiting scientists and society. This study evaluated whether adopting open science practices (OSPs) correlates with higher citation rates and Altmetric scores. METHODS: A random sample of randomised clinical trials (RCTs) on dental caries published between 2000 and 2022 was selected. A systematic PubMed search identified relevant RCTs, and data on OSPs - study registration, open methodology, open software, open scripts, open analysis plan, open data, open peer review, and open access (OA) - were manually collected by two independent assessors. The Robot Reviewer tool automatically evaluated the risk of bias (RoB). Outcomes included the total number of citations and the Altmetric Attention Score. Associations between OSPs, RoB, and other explanatory variables with the outcomes were assessed using binomial negative regression analysis, and expressed as Incidence Rate Ratio (IRR; α =0.05). RESULTS: In total, 323 papers were analysed. At least one OSP was adopted in 57.5 % (n = 186) of the articles, dropping to 39.6 % (n = 128) without OA. Papers with protocol registration (IRR: 1.45; 95 % CI: 1.15, 1.82) and OA publication (IRR: 1.24; 95 % CI: 1.01, 1.53) had higher citation rates. Conversely, papers in full OA journals had fewer citations (IRR: 0.67; 95 % CI: 0.52, 0.87). After adjusting for RoB, low-risk studies showed higher citation rates (IRR: 1.48; 95 % CI: 1.14, 1.91), while OA lost significance. For Altmetric scores, registered and OA manuscripts showed higher scores (IRR: 3.74; 95 % CI: 2.00, 7.01; IRR: 1.69; 95 % CI: 1.04, 2.75), with registration remaining significant after adjusting for RoB and impact factor (IRR: 3.71; 95 % CI: 1.97-6.99). CONCLUSION: The adoption of OSPs demonstrated a partial correlation with citation rates and Altmetric scores in RCTs on dental caries; however, these effects are complex and seem more related to the journal's impact factor. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The citations and the attention to clinical trials in dentistry, which could drive clinical decision-making and the elaboration of policies and recommendations, seem to be driven more by the journal's prestige than by the adoption of OSPs.
引用
- Cenci J, Mendes FM, Bouter L, et al. Are open science practices in dentistry associated with higher Altmetric scores and citation rates? J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39369879. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105393
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。