引导式与徒手单颗种植体植入:3年平行随机临床试验
本3年平行随机临床试验评估手术技术(手动或引导)和操作者经验(非专家或熟练)对骨嵴下1 mm植入种植体边缘骨水平稳定性的影响。60颗平台转换种植体随机分为数字静态引导组(非专家操作)和徒手组(熟练操作)。两组边缘骨水平变化差异为0.11 ± 0.22 mm,无统计学显著性(p = 0.61)。
要点
- 引导式种植由非专家操作与徒手种植由专家操作在3年边缘骨变化上无显著差异。
- 软组织高度小于3 mm的种植体在修复负载时边缘骨水平比≥3 mm者高0.33 mm,但差异无统计学显著性(P = 0.065)。
- 数字规划与手术可能帮助非专家临床医生获得与专家相当的种植结局。
核心结论
- 数字静态引导种植由非专家操作,与熟练操作者徒手种植相比,不限制边缘骨改建。
研究设计与样本
- 平行随机临床试验,3年随访,60颗种植体(引导组30颗,徒手组30颗)纳入18名患者。
- 引导组由非专家操作(专业活动中植入少于20颗种植体),徒手组由熟练操作者(专业活动中植入超过1000颗种植体)完成。
- 种植体为平台转换设计(Anyridge, MegaGen Implant Co., 韩国),带5度内锥连接,支持单颗螺丝固位固定冠,植入深度为骨嵴下1 mm。
主要发现
- 两组边缘骨水平变化差异为0.11 ± 0.22 mm,无统计学显著性(p = 0.61)。
- 修复负载时,软组织高度小于3 mm的种植体平均边缘骨水平比软组织高度≥3 mm者高0.33 mm,差异无统计学显著性(P = 0.065)。
临床怎么用
- 经过正确仔细的规划,骨嵴下植入的锥形连接平台转换种植体早期边缘骨水平可能随时间保持稳定。
- 数字规划和手术有潜力辅助非专家临床医生实现与专家相当的种植体植入结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The present parallel randomized clinical trial aimed to assess, after a 3-year follow-up period, whether the choice of surgical technique-either manual or guided-and of the operator - non-expert operator or skilled - can affect the stability of peri‑implant marginal bone levels in implants placed 1 mm sub-crestal. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients received platform-switched implants (Anyridge, MegaGen Implant Co., Gyeongbuk, South Korea) featuring a 5-degree internal conical connection and supporting single screw-retained fixed crowns. The implants were randomly assigned to be placed through a digitally static guided surgery procedure (Test group - GS) or a freehand surgical technique (Control Group - FH). A non-expert operator (fewer than 20 implants placed in his professional activity) was selected to perform procedures for the GS Group, while a skilled operator (with over 1000 implants placed in his professional activity) was chosen for the FH Group. Marginal bone level (MBL) was measured at prosthesis installation (t0) and at 1 (t1), 2 (t2) and 3 years (t3) of follow-up. Changes in MBL from t0 to t3 were analyzed through periapical radiographs. Moreover, MBL changes at all time points were correlated to different supra-crestal soft tissue heights (STH): less than 3 and ≥ 3 mm, respectively. RESULTS: 60 implants in 18 patients were examined, with 30 implants allocated to the GS group and 30 to the FH group. The difference in MBL change between the two groups was 0.11 ± 0.22 mm, which was not statistically significant (p = 0.61). At the time of prosthetic loading, the mean MBL for implants with STH less than 3 mm was 0.33 mm higher than implants with STH ≥ 3 mm, though this difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.065). CONCLUSIONS: Digitally static guided implant placement, performed by a non-expert operator, does not limit marginal bone remodeling, when compared to a freehand procedure performed by an experienced operator. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: After correct and careful planning, early marginal bone levels (MBL) around conical connection, platform-switched implants placed sub-crestally may be stable in time. Digital planning and surgery have the potential to assist non-expert clinicians in achieving implant placements with comparable outcomes to those performed by experts.
引用
- Lops D, Palazzolo A, Calza S, et al. Guided versus freehand single implant placement: A 3-year parallel randomized clinical trial. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39181431. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105317
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。