氯己定与锦葵漱口水抗菌斑及抗牙龈炎疗效比较:随机交叉临床试验
结果显示两者抗菌斑效果无显著差异,但氯己定在控制牙龈炎症方面优于锦葵(p=0.02),且氯己定口味更受青睐、菌斑控制感知更高(p<0.05)。短期使用锦葵漱口水可作为生物膜控制的替代选择,但抗牙龈炎效果预期低于氯己定。
要点
- 0.12%氯己定与5%锦葵漱口水抗菌斑效果相似,无统计学显著差异。
- 氯己定控制牙龈炎症优于锦葵漱口水(p=0.02)。
- 锦葵漱口水短期可作为生物膜控制替代,但抗牙龈炎效果较低。
核心结论
- 两种漱口水抗菌斑效果相似,但氯己定在控制牙龈炎症方面优于锦葵漱口水。
- 短期使用锦葵漱口水可作为生物膜控制的替代选择,但抗牙龈炎效果预期低于氯己定。
研究设计与样本
- 研究期间受试者7天不进行机械性菌斑清除,第1天全口预防和口腔健康评估,第3天对侧象限牙龈炎症评估和预防,随后随机使用漱口水4天,第7天问卷及牙龈炎症和菌斑指数评估。
- 两个阶段之间至少21天洗脱期。
主要发现
- 锦葵与氯己定组在炎症和菌斑形成方面无统计学显著差异。
- 氯己定在牙龈炎症平均减少(第7天减第4天)方面显著大于锦葵(p=0.02),分别为0.01 ± 0.19和0.00 ± 0.19。
- 氯己定使用者报告更愉悦的口味和更高的菌斑控制感知(p<0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 短期可考虑使用锦葵漱口水作为生物膜控制的替代方案。
- 若需控制牙龈炎症,氯己定效果优于锦葵漱口水。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Although mechanical oral hygiene is widely practiced, it faces several challenges. Mouthwashes, such as chlorhexidine (CHX), are being explored as adjuncts to biofilm control, but their prolonged use has several side effects. Consequently, there is ongoing research into natural alternatives. This randomized crossover clinical study aimed to compare the antiplaque and antigingivitis efficacy of 0.12 % CHX and a 5 % Malva sylvestris. METHODS: Forty-four participants were involved in two phases, each comprising three stages with variations in the mouthwash solution used only. During the study, participants refrained from mechanical plaque removal for seven days. At first day, they received whole-mouth prophylaxis and oral health assessment. After three days, gingival inflammation assessment and prophylaxis in were performed in contralateral quadrants. Participants then used a randomly assigned mouthwash solution for four days. On the 7th day, they completed a questionnaire about their perception and appreciation of the mouthwash. Additionally, gingival inflammation and plaque index were also performed by a calibrated examiner. After a minimum 21-day washout period, participants entered the second phase, repeating the three stages. RESULTS: Results showed no statistically significant differences between the Malva sylvestris and CHX groups regarding inflammation and plaque formation. However, CHX demonstrated a significantly greater mean reduction (7th - 4th day) in gingival inflammation compared to Malva (p = 0.02) (0.01 ± 0.19 and 0.00 ± 0.19, respectively). Additionally, participants using CHX reported a more pleasant taste and considered higher plaque control perception (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, both products exhibited similar antiplaque effects, but CHX outperformed Malva in controlling gingival inflammation. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Mouthwashes with Malva sylvestris may be a good alternative, in a short-term period, to control biofilm. However, lower antigingivitis efficacy may be expected when compared to chlorhexidine.
引用
- Zuttion GS, Juárez HAB, Lima BD, et al. Comparison of the anti-plaque and anti-gingivitis efficacy of Chlorhexidine and Malva mouthwashes: Randomized crossover clinical trial. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 39173823. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105313
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。