牙周风险评估沟通对首诊患者心理结局与龈上菌斑控制的效果:平行随机试验
本研究在牙周初诊后立即进行动机性访谈,随机分为联合PerioRisk预后工具反馈组(RISK组)与单纯动机性访谈组(CTR组),评估心理结局与龈上菌斑控制。结果显示两组PMT总分与菌斑指数均显著改善,但组间在PANAS、PMT总分及菌斑指数上无差异。亚组分析提示,无牙周炎致牙缺失者在动机性访谈后即刻的PMT总分高于有牙周炎致牙缺失者动机性访谈前的得分。
要点
- 牙周初诊后动机性访谈可改善心理结局与龈上菌斑控制。
- 联合PerioRisk反馈未在组间比较中显示额外获益。
- 亚组结果提示动机性访谈可能提前唤起牙周炎致牙缺失相关的意识。
核心结论
- 牙周初诊时实施动机性访谈(无论是否联合PerioRisk)对心理结局和龈上菌斑控制有实际效果。
- 联合PerioRisk反馈在PANAS、PMT总分及菌斑指数上未显示组间差异。
研究设计与样本
- 平行臂随机试验,参与者在首次牙周就诊后立即接受动机性访谈。
- 动机性访谈联合PerioRisk水平与基于PerioRisk输出的治疗目标信息为RISK组,不联合为CTR组。
- 心理结局采用正性负性情绪量表(PANAS)与保护动机理论(PMT)评估,菌斑指数(PI)在8-12周后复评。
主要发现
- CTR组与RISK组的PMT总分和PI均观察到显著改善。
- PANAS、PMT总分及PI在组间无差异。
- 亚组分析显示,无牙周炎致牙缺失者在动机性访谈后即刻的PMT总分,高于有牙周炎致牙缺失者动机性访谈前的PMT总分。
临床怎么用
- 牙周初诊后可实施动机性访谈以改善心理结局与龈上菌斑控制。
- PerioRisk反馈并非动机性访谈产生上述效果的必要条件。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate the efficacy of the PerioRisk prognostic tool in implementing the effect of motivational interviewing (MI) on psychological outcomes and supragingival plaque control. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Participants underwent MI immediately after their first periodontal visit. According to a parallel-arm, randomized study design, MI was performed with (RISK group) or without (CTR group) information on PerioRisk level and treatment goals based on PerioRisk output. Psychological outcomes were assessed using the Positive Affect Negative Affect Scale (PANAS) and Protection Motivation Theory (PMT). Plaque index (PI) was re-evaluated after 8-12 weeks. RESULTS: Significant improvements in PMT overall score and PI were observed in CTR and RISK groups, without inter-group difference in PANAS and PMT overall scores and PI. A sub-analysis showed that the overall PMT scores recorded immediately after MI in both CTR and RISK groups for subjects with no tooth loss due to periodontitis were higher than those recorded before MI in subjects with tooth loss due to periodontitis. CONCLUSIONS: At first periodontal visit, MI (implemented with without PerioRisk) has tangible effects on psychological outcomes and supragingival plaque control and seems to anticipate the awareness that is commonly generated by periodontitis-related tooth loss (ClinicalTrials.gov protocol registration ID: NCT05078411).
引用
- Farina R, Simonelli A, Guarnelli ME, et al. Efficacy of communicating periodontal risk on psychological outcomes and supragingival plaque control in patients undergoing first periodontal consultation: A parallel-arm, randomized trial. J Clin Periodontol. 2024. PMID: 38956317. doi:10.1111/jcpe.14032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。