牙科诊断错误负担:牙周病误分类研究
本研究基于电子健康记录触发工具并结合金标准人工复核,回顾性评估牙科诊断误分类率。共纳入2262份患者病历,算法标记1124例可能误分类、1138例可能正确诊断。结果显示牙周病诊断误分类观察比例为32%,且与诊所或提供者特征无显著差异。
要点
- 约三分之一的牙周病病例被误分类。
- 算法标记可能误分类时与金标准一致性极低(kappa=0.01)。
- 算法标记可能正确诊断时与金标准几乎完全一致(kappa=0.9)。
核心结论
- 约三分之一的牙周病病例被误分类,诊断错误在牙科中值得关注。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,开发并运行基于电子健康记录的触发工具,对标记病例及部分未标记病例进行两名校准领域专家的人工复核。
- 共2262份患者病历符合纳入标准。
主要发现
- 算法标记1124例为可能误分类,1138例为可能正确诊断。
- 算法标记可能误分类时,与金标准诊断的kappa统计量为0.01。
- 算法标记可能正确诊断时,与金标准复核的kappa统计量为0.9。
- 诊断误分类的观察比例为32%。
- 误分类率按诊所或提供者特征无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 诊断误分类观察比例32%。
- 可能误分类组kappa=0.01。
- 可能正确诊断组kappa=0.9。
临床怎么用
- 应重视牙科诊断准确性,可考虑利用技术辅助即时诊断决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Periodontal disease constitutes a widely prevalent category of non-communicable diseases and ranks among the top 10 causes of disability worldwide. Little however is known about diagnostic errors in dentistry. In this work, by retrospectively deploying an electronic health record (EHR)-based trigger tool, followed by gold standard manual review, we provide epidemiological estimates on the rate of diagnostic misclassification in dentistry through a periodontal use case. METHODS: An EHR-based trigger tool (a retrospective record review instrument that uses a list of triggers (or clues), i.e., data elements within the health record, to alert reviewers to the potential presence of a wrong diagnosis) was developed, tested and run against the EHR at the two participating sites to flag all cases having a potential misdiagnosis. All cases flagged as potentially misdiagnosed underwent extensive manual reviews by two calibrated domain experts. A subset of the non-flagged cases was also manually reviewed. RESULTS: A total of 2,262 patient charts met the study's inclusion criteria. Of these, the algorithm flagged 1,124 cases as potentially misclassified and 1,138 cases as potentially correctly diagnosed. When the algorithm identified a case as potentially misclassified, compared to the diagnosis assigned by the gold standard, the kappa statistic was 0.01. However, for cases the algorithm marked as potentially correctly diagnosed, the review against the gold standard showed a kappa statistic of 0.9, indicating near perfect agreement. The observed proportion of diagnostic misclassification was 32 %. There was no significant difference by clinic or provider characteristics. CONCLUSION: Our work revealed that about a third of periodontal cases are misclassified. Diagnostic errors have been reported to happen more frequently than other types of errors, and to be more preventable. Benchmarking diagnostic quality is a first step. Subsequent research endeavor will delve into comprehending the factors that contribute to diagnostic errors in dentistry and instituting measures to prevent them. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This study sheds light on the significance of diagnostic excellence in the delivery of dental care, and highlights the potential role of technology in aiding diagnostic decision-making at the point of care.
引用
- Tokede B, Yansane A, Brandon R, et al. The burden of diagnostic error in dentistry: A study on periodontal disease misclassification. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 38960000. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105221
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。