牙体牙髓病学伞状综述的方法学质量:横断面研究
先验方案注册和期刊影响因子与更高的方法学质量总分显著相关。
要点
- 牙体牙髓病学伞状综述普遍存在方法学缺陷,尤其对原始研究重叠处理不足。
- 先验方案注册和发表于有影响因子的期刊与更优方法学质量相关。
- 作者撰写伞状综述时应遵循规范以提升方法学质量。
核心结论
- 牙体牙髓病学伞状综述存在若干方法学缺陷,先验方案注册和期刊影响因子与更高的方法学质量总分显著相关。
研究设计与样本
- 采用11条目清单评估方法学质量,每条目由两名独立评估者评分为1、0.5或0分。
- 采用Bootstrapped多元线性回归分析总分与五个预测变量的关联,显著性水平设为5%。
主要发现
- 仅30%的综述充分处理了单个系统综述内原始研究重叠的问题。
- 先验方案注册和期刊影响因子与显著更高的方法学质量总分相关。
临床怎么用
- 口腔科医生在阅读或引用牙体牙髓病学伞状综述时,应关注其是否处理了原始研究重叠及是否先验注册方案。
- 作者撰写伞状综述时应参考本研究揭示的局限,遵循适当规范以确保综述符合最高标准。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: In endodontics, the number of umbrella reviews has increased significantly over the last few years, but there is no evidence that they were methodologically sound. The aim of the current study was to appraise the methodological quality of umbrella reviews in endodontics, and to identify possible predictive factors associated with methodological quality. METHODS: Umbrella reviews published in the discipline of endodontics until December 2023 were included. The methodological quality of the reviews was evaluated using a checklist consisting of 11 items. Each item in the checklist was evaluated by two independent assessors who assigned a score of '1' if it was fully addressed, '0.5' if it was partially ddressed, and '0' if it was not addressed. Bootstrapped multiple linear regression analysis was used to examine the association between the total scores awarded and five predictor variables (a priori protocol registration, year of publication, number of authors, journal impact factor (IF) and continent of the corresponding author). The statistical significance level was set as 5%. RESULTS: A total of 27 reviews were included. Ninety-six per cent of the reviews adequately reported: eligibility criteria for selecting the reviews, details of the reviews, techniques for assessing the risk of bias or methodological quality of the individual systematic reviews they included. Only 30% of the reviews adequately managed overlapping primary studies within individual systematic reviews. Among the five predictors analysed, a priori protocol registration and journals with IFs were associated with significantly greater total methodological quality scores. DISCUSSION: Several methodological shortcomings in the umbrella reviews published within the field of endodontics were revealed. Umbrella reviews published in journals with IFs and those with protocols registered a priori had significantly superior methodological quality scores. CONCLUSION: In endodontics, authors intending to publish umbrella reviews should consider the limitations revealed in this study and follow the appropriate rules to ensure their reviews comply with the highest standards and provide accurate and dependable information and conclusions.
引用
- Nagendrababu V, Gopinath VK, Narasimhan S, et al. Methodological quality of umbrella reviews in endodontics: A cross-sectional study. Int Endod J. 2024. PMID: 39016048. doi:10.1111/iej.14114
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。