混合现实动态导航与静态计算机辅助及徒手种植精度对比:体外研究
本体外研究将45个部分缺牙上颌模型分为三组,比较混合现实动态导航(MR-DN)、静态计算机辅助种植手术(s-CAIS)和徒手(FH)三种方法植入种植体的精度。共植入135枚种植体。结果显示MR-DN精度显著优于FH,与s-CAIS总体相似;但s-CAIS在XY方向优于MR-DN,En无差异。
要点
- MR-DN在多个偏差指标上显著优于徒手植入。
- MR-DN与s-CAIS精度总体相似,但s-CAIS在XY方向更优。
- MR-DN可作为种植手术的新选择,但需临床研究验证。
核心结论
- 在本体外研究范围内,MR-DN种植精度优于FH,与s-CAIS相似。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,45个部分缺牙上颌模型(缺牙位点#15、#16、#25),分三组每组15个,共植入135枚种植体(每组45枚)。
主要发现
- 在三个种植位点上,MR-DN在XY、Z、En、Ap和An偏差上显著优于FH。
- MR-DN在Z、Ap和An偏差上显著优于s-CAIS。
- s-CAIS在XY偏差上优于MR-DN,MR-DN与s-CAIS在En上无差异。
临床怎么用
- MR-DN可作为种植手术的一种新选择,精度优于徒手,与s-CAIS相似。
- 临床推广前需进一步临床研究确定MR-DN的可行性。
局限性
- 体外设计,仅使用部分缺牙模型,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: This in vitro study aimed to compare the accuracy of dental implant placement in partially edentulous maxillary models using a mixed reality-based dynamic navigation (MR-DN) system to conventional static computer-assisted implant surgery (s-CAIS) and a freehand (FH) method. METHODS: Forty-five partially edentulous models (with teeth missing in positions #15, #16 and #25) were assigned to three groups (15 per group). The same experienced operator performed the model surgeries using an MR-DN system (group 1), s-CAIS (group 2) and FH (group 3). In total, 135 dental implants were placed (45 per group). The primary outcomes were the linear coronal deviation (entry error; En), apical deviation (apex error; Ap), XY and Z deviations, and angular deviation (An) between the planned and actual (post-surgery) position of the implants in the models. These deviations were computed as the distances between the stereolithographic (STL) files for the planned implants and placed implants captured with an intraoral scanner. RESULTS: Across the three implant sites, the MR-DN system was significantly more accurate than the FH method (in XY, Z, En, Ap and An) and s-CAIS (in Z, Ap and An), respectively. However, S-CAIS was more accurate than MR-DN in XY, and no difference was found between MR-DN and s-CAIS in En. CONCLUSIONS: Within the limits of this study (in vitro design, only partially edentulous models), implant placement accuracy with MR-DN was superior to that of FH and similar to that of s-CAIS. STATEMENT OF CLINICAL RELEVANCE: In vitro, MR-DN showed greater accuracy in implant positioning than FH, and similar accuracy to s-CAIS: it could, therefore, represent a new option for the surgeon. However, clinical studies are needed to determine the feasibility of MR-DN.
引用
- Shusterman A, Nashef R, Tecco S, et al. Accuracy of implant placement using a mixed reality-based dynamic navigation system versus static computer-assisted and freehand surgery: An in Vitro study. J Dent. 2024. PMID: 38734298. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2024.105052
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。